Yeah, there are probably programs in the top 12 that don't deserve it, but BYU certainly isn't doing a good job making a case. They are squeeking by opponents and finally lost to a 3-6 team. They still have time to recover and can finish the last few games strong, but lose to ASU and they are probably out. Have to survive at least the next 2 weeks to have a shot to go to the CFP.