Someone needs to reply with detailed study of all 2024 B12 tiebreaker scenarios

Report problem with this ad

Sep 30, 2024
11:39:00am

Cooouuugs All-American

And breakdown of every possible scenario that could occur if BYU, Colorado and ISU go undefeated

Report problem with this ad

Cooouuugs

Previous username: Coooooogs
Bio page: Cooouuugs
Joined: Jul 9, 2015
Last login: Sep 30, 2024
Total posts: 2,106 (8 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

This isn’t ideal… it’s possible for BYU, Iowa State and Colorado to go undefeated in conference.

touchdownbyu All-American

7:40am

I guarantee that won’t happen

RdF3

7:40am

Is that a beefy burrito promise?

Longseason

7:48am

Yes RdF3, are you willing to be a REAL college football fan and back up that

BYU Sportz Fan

7:58am

RE: Is that a beefy burrito promise?

NonmormonYfan89

9:11am

Board name checks out

Cooouuugs

9:36am

A frozen beefy burrito challenge

Knight-who-says-ni

10:50am

You beat me to it 😂

Pretorian

11:27am

We go undefeated in conference, we're actually undefeated. We wouldn't be left

paulb

7:42am

It looks like that’s a tiebreaker after conference SOS

squirrelyearl

8:07am

I’m sure this will never happen, but theoretically, how does a coin toss work

byuinva

11:49am

Probably either flip 3 coins simultaneously and odd man out is out of the CC

squirrelyearl

1:01pm

Extremely unlikely to have a 2 way tie for the second spot after all those tie-

SoBlueitHurts

1:06pm

An undefeated P4 team would almost certainly earn at at large bid

Stalwart Man

12:11pm

That should favor us (at least for now) since KSU, Utah, Arizona, and maybe OkSt

SoBlueitHurts

12:53pm

I don’t think the undefeated thing will be an issue this year, but a 16 team, divisionless conference

Indy Coug

7:43am

Even *if* we were left out of the B12 champ game (in that scenario), we'd be a

Ferb

7:43am

Very true. The only downside is we'd be locked out of the opportunity to claim

Corn Pop

7:58am

A home playoff game would be better than a buy but don't see that ever happening

johnnybyu

8:00am

been or beaten? I can't like a post saying would have "been Utah"

SoBlueitHurts

12:54pm

It would be fine because all 3 would make the playoff so no big deal.

BYUCLA

7:54am

A lot of the playoff projections have

oilman

9:06am

A 12-0 Big 12 team is not getting left out and neither is a 12-1 for that matter

BYUFootballisBack

10:32am

Agree on 12-0, disagree on 12-1 for at large

SoBlueitHurts

12:56pm

How many 12-1 P5 teams have not been ranked top 12 ever?

BYUFootballisBack

1:43pm

2 loss p5 teams don't always make it, but most of the time they are still top 12

BYUFootballisBack

1:49pm

The caveat to this is that #12 would have been left out most years as the G5

BYUFootballisBack

1:51pm

So the lowest a 1-loss P5 team has been ranked is #7 but some think a 1-loss

BYUCLA

1:50pm

People don't realize just how few teams go undefeated or only 1 loss every year

BYUFootballisBack

1:52pm

Seems you have forgotten Gary Barta's mental gymnastics.

SoBlueitHurts

1:56pm

New era with a new level of SEC and B1G bias

SoBlueitHurts

1:54pm

The committee will find ways to justify it (not that it will happen so we won't

SoBlueitHurts

1:55pm

All 12-1 or better P4 teams will be in the playoff (barring a historical season

BYUFootballisBack

2:05pm

You heard Gary Barta in 2020. Do you really think the committee will not find a

SoBlueitHurts

2:42pm

There are almost never more than 12 P5 teams with 2 or less losses, I could see

BYUFootballisBack

2:48pm

I think we are saying that even with 2-loss B1G/SEC teams ahead of 1-loss Big 12

BYUCLA

2:48pm

Exactly this, 1 loss power 4/5 teams have ALWAYS been top 10, always, there just

BYUFootballisBack

2:49pm

I am more confident in the math of two loss teams than I am the rankings

SoBlueitHurts

3:13pm

A 2 loss Big12 team likely only gets in if they win the CCG

BYUFootballisBack

3:28pm

This seems likely, but we were talking 2 loss from those and 1 from ours. Very

SoBlueitHurts

3:08pm

Problem with past year comparisons is the cream of the crop has consolidated in

Cooouuugs

2:05pm

Every P4 undefeated team makes the playoff. Loser of the CCG might miss, because

NYC and Japan

11:00am

Aside from the 5 autobids playoff selection is an individual team not conference

BYUCLA

11:29am

I think they think we will beat each other up. But I really question how ACC

SoBlueitHurts

12:55pm

In that scenario, it would come down to tiebreaker rule 4 (in-conference SOS)

zuko

8:00am

I think that would be ideal.

fbguru

8:13am

Big 12 would have a decent shot to get 3 teams in the CFP. That is ideal.

Doogal McCougar

8:39am

We play tougher teams than Colorado in conference and are 3-0 noncon

Veep

8:52am

Congrats! You win the "silliest thing to worry about" award for the day!

Roko's Basilisk

9:44am

Always nice to realize that anyone we play won't go undefeated. 🙂

VB2

10:09am

Fortunately each will only have one loss.

Ripliancum

10:16am

Why didn't you think of this before the season started?

VB2

10:20am

Yikes, the Colorado hype would be insufferable.

Bluedarts

11:09am

Someone needs to reply with detailed study of all 2024 B12 tiebreaker scenarios

Cooouuugs

11:39am

There have literally only been 13 undefeated P5(4) teams in the playoffs in 9 yr

NYC and Japan

12:21pm

VERY IDEAL! Best way to get 3 teams in CFB Playoff!

SoBlueitHurts

12:51pm

I hate large conferences for this reason. The champion can still be subjective.

seacougar

1:42pm

If we go undefeated in conference but get left out of the championship, we get a

NorthernCougifornia

1:46pm

Ain't gonna happen for ANY of us. KState's the favorite to win the conf, imo. Their huge slip-up vs us notwithstanding.

Posting on CougarBoard