What I don't get is why they got it on the 10 yard line. If he was out

Sep 22, 2024
5:15:14pm

jaba166 All-American

, they should have had it where he stepped out. If they deemed he did not step out, it should have been a TD for KSU. Maybe I'm missing something, but the entire sequence has me confused.

Report problem with this ad

jaba166

Bio page: jaba166
Joined: Aug 20, 2010
Last login: Sep 22, 2024
Total posts: 4,269 (8 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Okay but hear me out - hear me out...

CougarLegend

2:19pm

RE: Okay but hear me out - hear me out...

CougPrime

2:20pm

Yeah, finally seeing the TV replay made me even more confused. I feel like

westsidecoug

2:22pm

What I don't get is why they got it on the 10 yard line. If he was out

jaba166

5:15pm

They called holding on the OL

eyebleedblu

5:17pm

The ruling was holding. They took the penalty and moved back 10 yards.

refunder

5:19pm

OK, I see. Missed that. Thanks!

jaba166

6:01pm

Penalty pushed it back. Question was if BYU should decline and take the ball

Socrates Johnson

8:25pm

It was super close. Had they called him out it would have stood as called. There was one angle that looked definitive

Haysom Till

2:24pm

Who called him in was my question

WorfoSAUR

2:26pm

This - I assumed the call on the field was out because of that signal

CougPrime

2:29pm

Avery was even mad at the ref because he told him he was out

YIsForBrigham

2:43pm

This was so confusing! I don't think anyone signaled a TD!

Great38

3:37pm

Exactly. The ref with the best view of it that should have had the ultimate

westsidecoug

8:54pm

One angle, definitive = indisputable.

StarMan

2:27pm

There was no ref that signaled TD

maxpowers

2:49pm

That's the thing about angles. When you get the right one it's clear.

TailgateU

8:48pm

They left it on the big screen in stadium for quite some time. Obviously out

O Gaucho

2:25pm

In the stadium I watched the sideline ref and he marked him short. No touchdown signal was ever given. 🤷🏼‍♂️

TANK

2:29pm

Yeah it was bizarre didn’t make any sense

ABCoug

2:36pm

Some of the angles were unclear, I wonder what they were able to review

Projectoor

2:41pm

I agree. But I was actually ok with giving them 3 and getting the ball back at

blackandblue

2:54pm

If nothing else, it can nullify claims of BYU winning by too much home cooking.

Forzaitalia

3:01pm

Must not have qualified as indisputable. I was stunned too.

IronPotato

3:27pm

ESPN announcers were so convinced they were having the discussion around the

Samurai Jack

4:58pm

I was telling my friend during the game as the three other officials stood on

stoils

6:11pm

Is there accountability for refs? I’m not mad in the least. But bizzare things

ColonelMustard

5:01pm

Yes there is. Every call and missed call is reviewed and graded.

Conan

5:56pm

The game announcers and other officials

BYUvermont

5:28pm

Is there a video clip of it?

Conan

5:58pm

RE: Okay but hear me out - hear me out...

coug4evah2347

6:05pm

Blessing in disguise. Probably would have turned it over at the one

gp232

6:24pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad