RE: What happened to this board rule?

Sign up, and you can make all message times appear in your timezone. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Sep 9, 2024
9:54:11am

Mikey All-American

RE: What happened to this board rule?

Report problem with this ad

Mikey

Bio page: Mikey
Joined: Jul 12, 2002
Last login: Nov 9, 2024
Total posts: 16,979 (998 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

What happened to this board rule?

RGGeemer

Sep 9, 9:51am

RE: What happened to this board rule?

Mikey

Sep 9, 9:54am

Doesn’t matter. Now hyper focused on petty political suspensions and other suspensions related to pet projects.

mulletino

Sep 9, 9:54am

It's become so rampant that it can't be moderated? Sad but likely one reason.

coug10278

Sep 9, 9:58am

I don't think that rule can exist on a college spots message board. I think it's more a justification for the last

shimmy

Sep 9, 10:00am

The Mods are already bad and you want them to do more?

Grock

Sep 9, 10:10am

Not talking about the mods at all. People can follow rules without policing.

RGGeemer

Sep 9, 10:12am

I would say a vast majority of the "negative" comments since Friday

bythenumbers

Sep 9, 10:16am

I've seen a few. More of them on Sitake and ARod.

Plantagenet

Sep 9, 10:38am

He didn't include the part of the rule that says we allow more criticism of coaches

El Jefe

Sep 9, 11:25am

Most of the feedback is supporting the team by identifying need changes

Swish

Sep 9, 10:29am

Bless your heart.

Accipiter

Sep 9, 10:35am

Would like CB 100x more if this rule were enforced.

MaxxPower

Sep 9, 11:16am

Most posts we've seen - particularly about Retzlaff - fit the "constructive criticism that explores the weaknesses as

Referee

Sep 9, 11:17am

We've deleted several posts for excessive negativity, especially towards players

El Jefe

Sep 9, 11:24am

Why not just make a separate category for complaining?

Sep 9, 3:08pm

well, now that they are paid performers, aren't they open to criticism?

bald man

Sep 9, 11:25am

Technically, they can't be paid for performance (yet)

El Jefe

Sep 9, 11:28am

This is a point worth talking about. When they're viewed as paid pros, and ...

KCFan85

Sep 9, 12:23pm

I’m sorry, this board still has moderators?

NonmormonYfan89

Sep 9, 11:35am

It would appear that you have misconstrued posting facts and constructive

tkh9

Sep 9, 11:51am

It's gone way overboard the past 3-4 days - well past facts and constructive

RGGeemer

Sep 9, 11:54am

Any examples?

tkh9

Sep 9, 11:57am

Don't see anything from you that crosses the line. But there are plenty of

RGGeemer

Sep 9, 12:08pm

Fair enough

tkh9

Sep 9, 12:15pm

Would saying that Jake is the worst byu qb of all time be considered to be

YOHONOMOTO

Sep 9, 2:21pm

I would say yes. Hyperbolic and unhelpful

RGGeemer

Sep 9, 2:38pm

It’s not hyperbolic if it’s true though. I’m still waiting for someone to point

YOHONOMOTO

Sep 9, 3:04pm

He's obviously not the worst byu QB in history. That's just crazy talk.

RGGeemer

Sep 9, 3:05pm

He has about the same passing efficiency as

RGGeemer

Sep 9, 3:15pm

He has a slightly better passing efficiency than Jake Heaps

RGGeemer

Sep 9, 3:17pm

Also higher than these notable players:

RGGeemer

Sep 9, 3:21pm

Ok you have to throw a lot of those out

YOHONOMOTO

Sep 9, 3:25pm

162 in 2006, but 112 if you include 2004

RGGeemer

Sep 9, 3:32pm

Ah that’s fair then

YOHONOMOTO

Sep 9, 7:14pm

So Jake is definitely not the worst qb in byu history. Hyperbolic and unhelpful

RGGeemer

Sep 9, 8:15pm

I mean we just looked at passer rating. We could do turnovers next if you want.

YOHONOMOTO

Sep 9, 8:20pm

If you want. Ty Detmer threw 65 INTs

RGGeemer

Sep 9, 8:26pm

Heaps 114. Retzlaff now 115. So you’re right (for now).

YOHONOMOTO

Sep 9, 3:22pm

If you were discussing his stats, that would be fine

El Jefe

Sep 9, 3:01pm

Rule$ are $elective?

Sep 9, 12:02pm

There truly and literally aren't really "rules" on CB per se

Czar-castic

Sep 9, 1:29pm

Coach X needs some improvements with his play calling, his recruiting, and his

Cooouuugs

Sep 9, 2:46pm

This rule should help kick off some of the yewts in Cougar clothing here

Brandoblueblood

Sep 9, 4:25pm

Even the mods want Retzy benched.

Haysom Till

Sep 9, 4:42pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad