he started 13 games for OSU last year. If this is true, I'm fine being patient with him. But, he shouldn't be starting over a more productive player until he's ready to beat out the other guy and perform.

No need for us to ever make anyone on the team a scapegoat. Play the best player, try to develop those who aren't into the best players. Those with the athleticism and work ethic will eventually rise to the top of the depth chart.