Question for people who voted stay independent

May 5, 2021
10:49:09am

Magathis In Pope We Trust

What would independence offer at that point? Would you really be willing to give up access to the playoffs for the chance to schedule more P5 games in the regular season? That doesn't seem like a good trade-off

Report problem with this ad

Magathis

Previous username: kakapo
Bio page: Magathis
Joined: Sep 2, 2018
Last login: Jun 25, 2024
Total posts: 22,698 (9,203 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

POLL: If the NCAA expands the playoff to 8 and guarantees at least 1 G5 team a spot what should BYU do?

ZacSeljaas'Stache

5/5/21 10:25am

Although it wouldn't be NCAA that would do this

Bandersnatch

5/5/21 10:27am

True, I should have said CFP. Regardless the question is the same

ZacSeljaas'Stache

5/5/21 10:28am

I think AAC all sports could include the Zags. Boise already wants out of MWC.

Moops

5/5/21 10:29am

If the AAC could get BYU and Boise for all sports and Gonzaga for basketball

ZacSeljaas'Stache

5/5/21 10:31am

This is a situation I would like. A perennial top 3-5 basketball conference,

bigbossbyu

5/5/21 2:29pm

It won’t happen, but nice hypothetical

2FarGone

5/5/21 10:31am

If they go 8 I bet there is an auto bid to the highest rated G5 with some minimum ranking threshold-maybe 10 or 12

TEXAS

5/5/21 10:39am

It would be fun to see the best G5 team be ranked #13 at the end of every single year

Magathis

5/5/21 10:49am

I think we have a better chance of getting an invite to the Big 12

2FarGone

5/5/21 12:37pm

Either are better shots than Indy, where our ceiling is 8 wins

TEXAS

5/5/21 1:42pm

Wait to see the fallout of the upcoming SCOTUS ruling, and determine if BYU will

shoganai

5/5/21 10:33am

BYU and all Independents should push to be recognized as a group to be included

ManicBlue

5/5/21 10:35am

Should definitely give a spot to best of BYU, Army, Liberty, UMass, and UConn

jreid191

5/5/21 10:37am

Could the Independents set up a 'conference' and 'championship game'?

ZacSeljaas'Stache

5/5/21 10:45am

You did not mention ND.

ParentingNotForSissy

5/5/21 2:03pm

They're practically in the ACC even if they technically aren't

jreid191

5/5/21 2:11pm

From a playoff prospective ND is independent. That is all that is relevant here.

ParentingNotForSissy

5/5/21 3:14pm

They have special. Privledges. What we should really lobby for is the same

ColonelMustard

5/5/21 3:23pm

Odds of getting in even an 8 team field are remote

ManicBlue

5/5/21 3:25pm

Question for people who voted stay independent

Magathis

5/5/21 10:49am

This. Indy would really make 0 sense in the outlined scenario.

Moops

5/5/21 12:49pm

Benefits of being an Independent for BYU have been outlined many, many times.

ManicBlue

5/5/21 1:32pm

Playoff access for independents isn't going to happen though. In the situation outlined in the OP there is no reason to

Magathis

5/5/21 1:40pm

Yeah right smh

ManicBlue

5/5/21 2:15pm

The AAC is nearly as repugnant as the MWC. And they make no sense...

Zastava

5/5/21 1:35pm

They don't do that now with the auto birth for G5, why would they change that?

Moops

5/5/21 2:06pm

Because I can’t see them leaving independents “out” in the new playoff...

Zastava

5/5/21 2:19pm

They absolutely wouldn't lump BYU with the rest of the G5 for an autobid

TEXAS

5/5/21 2:11pm

I think they’d rather do that than give an independent not named Norte Dame

Zastava

5/5/21 2:32pm

They'd better if they want to avoid any potential anti-trust lawsuits

ManicBlue

5/5/21 2:55pm

The G5 autobid is how they get around that. Not their fault BYU isn’t in a conference and I tend to agree. Also ND

TEXAS

5/5/21 4:11pm

An anti-trust lawsuit could make that interesting

ManicBlue

5/5/21 4:15pm

Why should anybody be forced to join a conference when it’s not in their best

Zastava

5/5/21 4:37pm

Nobody is forced to. Just don’t get the same benefit of everyone else having a tougher path

TEXAS

5/5/21 4:41pm

Not all conferences are created equal, and Norte Dame’s schedule is...

Zastava

5/5/21 5:02pm

I agree. And if not having a shot at the CFP is worth it to you then Indy should be your goal

TEXAS

5/5/21 5:56pm

We could join the AAC, go undefeated, and still get left out. Then what?

SLIVER

5/5/21 1:58pm

If would rather see a BOTR league.

Traveling Coug

5/5/21 3:58pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad