My Account
Sign up, and you'll be able to ignore users whose posts you don't want to see.
Sign up
Report problem with this ad
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
May 8, 2020
9:18
:17
pm
robin
Starter
Gary Sheide won the Sammy Baugh trophy as nations best passer and
was 8th in heisman voting.
Would you put him above Doman and Taysom for the 10th spot?
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Report problem with this ad
robin
Bio page
robin
Joined
Apr 21, 2002
Last login
Nov 24, 2024
Total posts
4,747 (2 FO)
Report problem with this ad
Messages
Author
Time
POLL: Which one is NOT a top 10 all-time QB at BYU?
Odysseus
Truly Addicted User
5/8/20 8:21pm
I had to for with Doman. He really only played one year.
Jeff75
5/8/20 8:24pm
One spectacular year.
Holy Driver
5/8/20 8:24pm
Yeah, but the others had better years.
Jeff75
5/8/20 8:25pm
Taysom had better overall stats than Doman and played a much tougher schedule.
ManicBlue
5/8/20 8:36pm
Better stats or just more overall?
Lip Gallagher
5/8/20 9:33pm
Not sure I'd put either in the top 10.
Jeff75
5/8/20 10:07pm
You're only looking at passing. Taysom has BY FAR the most rushing yards of any
ManicBlue
5/9/20 2:04am
No I didn't. Both are in there.
Lip Gallagher
5/9/20 8:02am
Didn't exactly point that fact out and only compared one year
ManicBlue
5/9/20 10:43am
I thought it was obvious when both were listed with over 4000yds & "total TDs"
Lip Gallagher
5/9/20 12:23pm
So you want to compare one year instead of careers? Granted Doman's career was
ManicBlue
5/9/20 7:58pm
No, not that either.
Lip Gallagher
5/9/20 10:31pm
Despite Taysom's partial yrs ... and bad on him for getting injured unlike Doman
ManicBlue
5/9/20 11:26pm
Lol he doesn't belong. Sorry.
Lip Gallagher
5/10/20 9:24am
You call Taysom's career 'off and on' but do you even realize that he started
ManicBlue
5/10/20 8:20pm
Sark only had one good year.
Benfica1
5/10/20 3:32pm
And one great year.
Jeff75
5/10/20 4:17pm
Yes. I was at the TA&M game. So great. Doman also had an excellent year–beat uu
Benfica1
5/10/20 4:52pm
I thought he was excellent in his first year too
D.T. Survivor
5/10/20 6:28pm
Lol at people voting the winningest QB as a not too 10. Must be Yewts.
BYUtka
5/8/20 8:29pm
Just Sandyfan voting from all of his dupe accounts
Lip Gallagher
5/8/20 9:22pm
I voted for Taysom.
SandYFan
5/8/20 10:57pm
Taysom is one of my favorite players of all time, but the fact that he never
BlueBeliever
5/10/20 8:48pm
Nielsen for sure. I never understood why he started over
fredetteaboutit13
5/8/20 8:47pm
RE: Nielsen for sure. I never understood why he started over
Odysseus
5/8/20 8:50pm
Did you know his family was big Ute fans?
Brigham
5/8/20 8:51pm
?? His dad played for the Y.
eyes4byu
5/8/20 11:09pm
Not sure how people can vote Wilson. He is #5 in my book. 3rd in Heisman voting
ayfan
5/8/20 8:58pm
11-1 his senior year.
Jeff75
5/8/20 9:00pm
Perfect regular season and a 27-yard field goal away from completely undefeated
Magathisll
5/8/20 9:22pm
Recency bias.
eddog
5/8/20 9:28pm
Also in the college football hall of fame- pure ignorance to snub him
Bill
5/8/20 9:43pm
Threw 7 touchdowns in his very first start
arizonacougarfan
5/8/20 9:56pm
He’s just a junior. And the Hawaii bowl was disappointing.
All-American
5/9/20 1:30pm
Yeah go watch the oldest game on byutv app. Wilson was the real deal. He was
buckeyecougarguy
5/9/20 11:47pm
Gut instinct was to vote Hill. But I didn’t like it.
climps
5/8/20 9:03pm
All time Qb rankings IMO
arizonacougarfan
5/8/20 9:10pm
Nielsen was 1st Team AA. He shouldn’t be below Hall & Beck
CaliWG
5/9/20 7:59am
Walsh? Really?
StalwartBraveTrue
5/9/20 7:29pm
He had a great year in 1994. Look up his stats.
eddog
5/9/20 7:33pm
He was great.
Jeff75
5/9/20 7:44pm
Walsh gets a bad rap. He was really good
arizonacougarfan
5/9/20 9:50pm
He was good. If he'd have come back for his Sr year, he'd be higher on the list.
ManicBlue
5/9/20 10:24pm
If he came back then Sark wouldn’t have come and then no 96 cotton bowl
arizonacougarfan
5/9/20 10:35pm
It's fine how it worked out for BYU but not for Walsh. It doesn't mean Walsh
ManicBlue
5/10/20 1:07am
Taysom is a top 10 athlete but not a top 10 quarterback.
eddog
5/8/20 9:10pm
Gary Sheide won the Sammy Baugh trophy as nations best passer and
robin
5/8/20 9:18pm
Probably would
Mot
5/8/20 9:42pm
Which one of those has the least impressive signature win?
lilpenny
5/9/20 5:28am
I love Hill, but this is not about what could have been or how he might end up
Fdnman
5/9/20 6:24am
Taysom did not become what he should have been. I’m still miserable about it
YIsForBrigham
5/9/20 9:33am
Taysom may be top 10 as far as NFL career, but not college. He also never beat
MikeDitka'sStache
5/9/20 9:38am
You gave 7 choices. Need to be 11 choices. Love Doman.
Dr MoBYU
5/9/20 10:20am
Seems he believes the top 4 are not in question. I agree.
Soupie
5/9/20 10:24am
Just noticed that John Walsh isn't on this list.
eddog
5/9/20 10:21am
should be so we can vote him not top 10
AFitisemanu
5/9/20 5:58pm
Definitely recency bias w/ Wilson
Hill4Heisman
5/9/20 3:16pm
Marc my words. You are wrong.
StalwartBraveTrue
5/10/20 12:30am
RE: POLL: Which one is NOT a top 10 all-time QB at BYU?
Robydad
5/9/20 4:18pm
We should do a most underrated QB in history.
StalwartBraveTrue
5/9/20 7:29pm
Hancock, Walsh, and Carter are underrated
arizonacougarfan
5/9/20 9:52pm
And sheide
D.T. Survivor
5/11/20 9:23pm
It’s between Doman hill and sarkisian. The way the question is phrased I went
buckeyecougarguy
5/10/20 12:02am
Let's try not to forget Doman benefited from the single best season by a BYU RB
ManicBlue
5/10/20 1:14am
I hate to say it but I hold not beating Utah against taysom. If he beats them
buckeyecougarguy
5/10/20 5:58am
Taysom played against utah when utah was finally a good program. The rest didn't
ManicBlue
5/10/20 8:21pm
i would have given him more credit for beating utah then Sarkisian beating them
buckeyecougarguy
5/11/20 11:53am
Doman or Hill are really the only options.
Gentleman Stan
5/10/20 12:04am
ok.. gotta ask WHICH Wilson.. WHICH Nielsen are you asking about?
relic
5/10/20 8:58am
There's only one Nielsen. The other is a Nelson.
shakarocks
5/10/20 9:28am
Right.. I stand corrected...Thanks
relic
5/10/20 9:46am
I've heard some pronounce it the same way.
Jeff75
5/10/20 4:19pm
This might be a Wasatch Front linguistic anomaly. I have a very educated,
eyes4byu
5/11/20 10:24am
In this case they aren't pronounced the same.
shakarocks
5/11/20 6:55pm
To my mind, Neilson never should be pronounced Nelson; just anecdotal evidence
eyes4byu
5/12/20 8:25am
It's crazy people don't think Hill is a top 10 QB at BYU.
Vincent's Picks
5/11/20 10:47am
I don't.
D.T. Survivor
5/11/20 11:03am
Football was also a lot different then. TH would have dominated.
Vincent's Picks
5/11/20 11:14am
Would have, could have, should have
shakarocks
5/12/20 11:56am
He had some crazy highlight reel moments, but no ranked finishes, didn't beat
Gentleman Stan
5/11/20 11:58am
Yeah, it's either Doman or Hill. Probably Hill, as much as it pains me to say it
Ham
5/11/20 6:02pm
Report problem with this ad
Posting on CougarBoard
In order to post, you will need to either
sign up
or
log in
.
Report problem with this ad