My Account
Sign up, and you'll be able to customize your font size and more!
Sign up
Report problem with this ad
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Nov 17, 2019
6:58
:14
pm
Cougarbib
All-American
He may not have been fully healthy then. He has been quoted last week
that his throwing arm is now stronger than it was earlier.
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Report problem with this ad
Cougarbib
Bio page
Cougarbib
Joined
Jul 28, 2003
Last login
Sep 20, 2024
Total posts
40,950 (111 FO)
Report problem with this ad
Messages
Author
Time
ZW has to be better. He's struggled this year.
SpiffCoug
All-American
11/17/19 2:36pm
Doesn’t have to be.. just play Romney
cougfanz
11/17/19 2:38pm
Exactly the point. Smart fans see the stats & his game vs rivals is far better.
ToasterChive
11/17/19 2:52pm
I don't know why it's hard for people to say Romney has been every bit as
777
11/17/19 3:33pm
He also had tougher competition
BYUCougarsFan
11/17/19 2:42pm
Did you even look at the stats?
Klompus
11/17/19 2:48pm
No 😂
BYUCougarsFan
11/17/19 2:56pm
Oh haha. Ok we still friends.
Klompus
11/17/19 3:09pm
He’s played mostly good teams with athletes we don’t have.
bigbossbyu
11/17/19 2:44pm
And right after healing from shoulder surgery
2FarGone
11/17/19 2:45pm
Exactly. It’s tough to say if he’s ever really been “100%” this year.
bigbossbyu
11/17/19 2:46pm
If that’s the case, play the guys who are 100% and have played better
Dangerous
11/17/19 2:51pm
Critchlow it is. He's the only 100% healthy QB.
foofcoug
11/17/19 2:53pm
Critchlow outplayed Wilson Saturday by quite a bit. 197 vs 127 PER
Cougarbib
11/17/19 3:38pm
lol love it
bigbossbyu
11/17/19 3:40pm
The game vs BSU showed Romney should be playing, he has the poise of a winner.
ToasterChive
11/17/19 2:51pm
How'd he look against mighty Liberty?
foofcoug
11/17/19 2:53pm
Offense was fine. Defense sucked.
KL2BYU
11/17/19 2:54pm
Pretty good.
ToasterChive
11/17/19 2:54pm
Definitely not as "sharp" as he looked against BSU. Struggled at times vs inferior competition.
foofcoug
11/17/19 2:57pm
He was much better than Wilson was against ISU.
Dangerous
11/17/19 3:33pm
Looked really good I thought
bluelands
11/17/19 3:00pm
Great. Look at the numbers in the chart above. Those numbers
Cougarbib
11/17/19 3:51pm
Why are we all supposed to be invested in Zach developing as a player?
KL2BYU
11/17/19 2:54pm
I am not sure that is the case, and I am very high on Romney
2FarGone
11/17/19 3:01pm
Look at the numbers. Wilson compared to the averages of the other teams that pl
Cougarbib
11/17/19 3:58pm
Agreed. Unfortunately it feels like we are married to ZW no matter what because
byulover
11/17/19 3:26pm
This
Jacksonian76
11/17/19 4:07pm
RE: Agreed. Unfortunately it feels like we are married to ZW no matter what
Fakalata
11/18/19 1:00am
And we won with Zach!!!
Fakalata
11/17/19 8:27pm
A d we lost with Zach.
CarolinaCoug
11/20/19 2:37pm
Thanks for data. Small error on Toledo line. Also,
Cougarbib
11/17/19 2:58pm
Fixed the Idaho St.
SpiffCoug
11/17/19 2:59pm
I think it's hilarious people leave Hall out of these discussions.
shakarocks
11/17/19 3:05pm
Because his concussion history suggests he won’t play football again
claw
11/17/19 3:09pm
No it doesn't
shakarocks
11/17/19 3:15pm
Uh if it is the only 2 games you’ve ever started and you cannot finish either...
claw
11/17/19 3:24pm
Glad you're a concussion expert
shakarocks
11/17/19 3:42pm
I prefer Romney over Hall
2FarGone
11/17/19 3:09pm
I do not have a favorite but I could argue it either way.
shakarocks
11/17/19 3:54pm
If you can't see that this data adjusts for tougher teams, just ignore
Cougarbib
11/17/19 4:10pm
He's unfortunately very likely to get knocked out next time he plays.
ToasterChive
11/17/19 3:21pm
I don't leave Hall out. He has performed below Romney but close. Well above ZW.
Cougarbib
11/17/19 4:01pm
No they are not
Fakalata
11/17/19 8:30pm
Baylor has played incredibly well for being a walk-on who has seen limited reps.
rainorsnow
11/17/19 3:27pm
We did miss 2 FG's in the Toledo game too.
ManicBlue
11/17/19 3:28pm
Field goals were a strength early and have been a problem lately
Cougarbib
11/17/19 4:30pm
I guess you didn't get that it does affect the Pts Differential.
ManicBlue
11/17/19 5:34pm
PER does not care about points differential. The defense scored 7points
Cougarbib
11/17/19 6:41pm
The OP listed it if you had paid attention.
ManicBlue
11/17/19 10:38pm
Yes. It is listed. Has nothing to do with PER. Just additional info
Cougarbib
11/17/19 11:05pm
I know what both mean. I only responded to the one piece before you went crazy
ManicBlue
11/17/19 11:14pm
You mean the ridiculous "ponder that" post you made?
Cougarbib
11/17/19 11:20pm
Which post was that?
ManicBlue
11/17/19 11:25pm
Must have confused you with someone else worrying that
Cougarbib
11/17/19 11:36pm
I also wonder how much of that can be attributed to scheme.
wilsdad
11/17/19 4:14pm
His performance vs ISU should debunk all difficult opponent and scheme excuses
Cougarbib
11/17/19 4:21pm
Agreed.
wilsdad
11/17/19 4:24pm
😂😂😂 you really have an axe to grind
puntersarepeople
11/17/19 5:53pm
smh
ManicBlue
11/17/19 6:01pm
Whatever happens, one will start
CrimsonCardinal
11/17/19 4:58pm
If the process is fair, they may both stay and continue to compete.
Cougarbib
11/17/19 6:56pm
You have to remember he wasn’t fully healthy until the season started and then
puntersarepeople
11/17/19 6:34pm
He may not have been fully healthy then. He has been quoted last week
Cougarbib
11/17/19 6:58pm
Yep his arm might be back but he was rusty
puntersarepeople
11/17/19 9:01pm
He’s not our best QB.
UNHuskerCoug
11/17/19 7:15pm
Just quit throwing pick 6’s or almost pick 6’s.
Yohy
11/17/19 7:20pm
is points differential adjusted for defensive TDs?
bruincoug
11/17/19 8:46pm
Only change would be vs Idaho St.
SpiffCoug
11/17/19 9:02pm
For our points, yes. For avg points allowed, there likely would be others.
Cougarbib
11/17/19 11:09pm
Meh sophomore slump
BYU Grounds
11/17/19 10:08pm
RE: ZW has to be better. He's struggled this year.
Doogal McCougar
11/20/19 2:46pm
You sure up play ZW and downplay BR in your comments.
Cougarbib
11/21/19 12:55am
IMO Wilson hasn’t run the same offense. I’m
gwalker
11/20/19 3:07pm
See Idaho State Game. He was terrible. He probably
Cougarbib
11/21/19 12:58am
Zach still beat them quite easily
puntersarepeople
11/21/19 7:16am
If he is, I agree, but he looked the worst at the end. And, in
Cougarbib
11/21/19 8:23am
Report problem with this ad
Posting on CougarBoard
In order to post, you will need to either
sign up
or
log in
.
Report problem with this ad