I for one didn't ever want Bronco to be fired. Had he lost to horrible teams

Feb 19, 2018
7:41:30pm

cougaman All-American

then I would disagree. BYU has lost to Pacific, LMU and San Diego this year. You cannot compare any season Bronco had to this season for Rose.

Worst Case scenario getting a new coach... Having more seasons like this one imo.

This message has been modified

Originally posted on Feb 19, 2018 at 7:41:30pm

Message modified by cougaman on Feb 19, 2018 at 7:42:15pm

Report problem with this ad

cougaman

Bio page: cougaman
Joined: Mar 11, 2006
Last login: Nov 27, 2024
Total posts: 72,659 (5,414 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

It is crazy to me that someone could hold this opinion after seeing what

boorad

2/19/18 8:19am

I’m ok with taking chances. What would have happened

carlstud

2/19/18 8:24am

That's the thing. BYU is not, by any definition, mediocre in hoops right now.

Westsider

2/19/18 8:28am

Actually, perennial 3rd place finishes in the 13th best basketball conference...

Cougar Insider

2/19/18 9:58am

Um, not when team #1 and #2 are perennial top 25 teams.

Westsider

2/19/18 10:39am

And so your saying you would

SaintJeff

2/19/18 10:44am

How many coaches are like Bennett or Few?

D.T. Survivor

2/19/18 1:58pm

Just 2

icecougar

2/19/18 6:10pm

Do you really believe SM would be top 25 if they were in the big12 or...

blackshirts

2/19/18 11:49am

they would have Big 12 resources so they wouldn't be the st Mary's of the WCC

SUAVO

2/19/18 2:14pm

I would say St. Mary's is more an occasional top 25 team than a perennial one.

cwilke1

2/19/18 2:46pm

They've been ranked about 50% of the time since we joined the league

Westsider

2/19/18 6:30pm

do you have a spreadsheet with weekly rankings?

cwilke1

2/19/18 6:40pm

When you’re program is a dumpster fire like Crowton was then it’s not really

boorad

2/19/18 8:32am

Crowton had three straight losing seasons and numerous scandals

BYU Fan

2/19/18 9:04am

With Bronco it started with him lowering expectations and then making excuses...

icecougar

2/19/18 1:33pm

That’s a terrible comparison. Crowton went 5-7, 4-6, and 5-6...

TrappistF

2/19/18 5:40pm

I’d rather take that chance. What do we have to lose? 3rd place in the WCC? Oh well.

Mr. Belding

2/19/18 8:26am

we could be 6th

demon_llama

2/19/18 8:40am

We could be. But we could be first. Or maybe win a conference tourney once.

Mr. Belding

2/19/18 8:42am

3 or 6 in the Weak College Conference is sixes..

blackshirts

2/19/18 9:24am

As sad as it is, I agree. If we get worse, maybe we don't make it to the NIT

Yucaterco

2/19/18 8:44am

The NIT cares about people in the seats. They will give BYU a home game

Cougtruth

2/19/18 11:48am

That may be true, but we're not exactly selling out every week

Yucaterco

2/19/18 12:41pm

Almost guaranteed the same thing would happen, given the names i have seen on CB

roseyscenario

2/19/18 8:26am

I found coach Rose to be very friendly

BYU Fan

2/19/18 9:18am

Have found the same.

roseyscenario

2/19/18 3:23pm

<< Deleted >>

roseyscenario

2/19/18 3:25pm

It seems unlikely that BYU will move on before Rose finishes up his current

JuicyJam

2/19/18 8:32am

Believe it's 2 more seasons and yes, I believe he deserves the right to finish the contract & decide when he leaves.

soupie

2/19/18 8:58am

IIRC we didn't take a chance on another guy, Bronco left to UVA on his own, no?

BYUfan92

2/19/18 8:50am

Bronco was going to leave sooner rather than later...the UVA offer was good timing for him...

Bonoman

2/19/18 9:58am

You realize Bronco left, right?

cougXor

2/19/18 10:12am

I think the bigger question was why did he leave?

BYU Fan

2/19/18 10:33am

Most of the above.

byujdmba

2/19/18 12:43pm

When he took the byu job he said something about imagining being here for 10

IceCreamButt

2/19/18 8:15pm

Even if we dropped down to 6th

SaintJeff

2/19/18 10:31am

We heard this same argument with Steve Cleveland. That he was not replaceable.

Richbyu

2/19/18 11:12am

RE: It is crazy to me that someone could hold this opinion after seeing what

Lip Gallagher

2/19/18 11:35am

Rose beat all 4 instate teams. Kalani lost to both. Keep Rose fire Kalani

Coogar2

2/19/18 11:58am

Judged against your peers. Gotta compete for a conference championship.

Richbyu

2/19/18 1:12pm

If Kalani just competed for a bowl game it would help

Coogar2

2/20/18 12:05am

After 2 seasons?? That's a little early

icecougar

2/19/18 1:37pm

Wasn’t too early to fire S Kaufusi, Ty etc

Coogar2

2/20/18 12:04am

Ty was historically bad. Even his first year when he had two future nfl players

IceCreamButt

2/20/18 1:03am

A proven 8-4 coach, a most likely bowl loss, a for sure Utah loss and guaranteed

Paul Hewson

2/19/18 3:11pm

Ever noticed the biggest Bronco worshipers are the biggest Rose critics.

Paul Hewson

2/19/18 3:13pm

The two things are not comparable at this point.

TheLoneCougar

2/19/18 4:32pm

Rose is 60, Bronco was 48. Also, I feel like our cupboard has much more options

Cougarfan777

2/19/18 5:30pm

People seem to forget Bronco said he only planned to coach about 10 yrs...

icecougar

2/19/18 6:17pm

I for one didn't ever want Bronco to be fired. Had he lost to horrible teams

cougaman

2/19/18 7:41pm

Lucky for you he wasn't fired.

Richbyu

2/19/18 9:32pm

Winning 1/4 of our games = bad, but not as bad as winning 1/25 of our games,

jaba166

2/20/18 2:07am

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad