Yikes. All those guys were duds.

Sign up, and you'll be able to vote in polls. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Dec 24, 2024
8:16:48am

Magneto Truly Addicted User

Yikes. All those guys were duds.

Report problem with this ad

Magneto

Bio page: Magneto
Joined: Jul 1, 2022
Last login: Dec 25, 2024
Total posts: 8,916 (17 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

247's all-time BYU commits list. If this doesn't make you depressed....

Indy Coug Loquacious Lummox

Dec 24, 8:08am

It might. If I could read it.

Brigham

Dec 24, 8:09am

RE: It might. If I could read it.

MaximusMeridius

Dec 24, 10:51am

BYU didn't have very good luck with its best football commits but

Archaea

Dec 24, 8:11am

Since LaVell arrived in 1972 we're a program that lives off of

gopman

Dec 24, 11:02am

Top athletes tend to not perform with BYU

Cougz19

Dec 24, 8:12am

It’s sad how small that 4* sample size is

Dec 24, 8:13am

Here's the next 5 on that list

Indy Coug

Dec 24, 8:16am

Yikes again. Bronson was good but that’s it.

Magneto

Dec 24, 8:17am

Bronson was great

Cougz19

Dec 24, 8:17am

So many of the good ones had injury issues. Hinds and Tuifua would have been

cougaman

Dec 24, 8:34am

Would have figured KVN, and Apo would have been up there.

Tuskaloosa Cougar

Dec 24, 9:11am

Apo is rated BYU's #7 best recruit ever

AFcoug7

Dec 24, 1:29pm

Yikes. All those guys were duds.

Magneto

Dec 24, 8:16am

Matt Reynolds? Dude was a stud. Scott Young was fine too.

WP17

Dec 24, 10:13am

Hinds was plenty good, but was chronically injured and never had a chance

Threw and Through

Dec 24, 1:38pm

Any chance Walt Williams could still be coming along with Eddie Scipio to revolutionize the defensive backfield.

Spiff

Dec 24, 8:17am

If. It them, maybe their kids

TADOW

Dec 24, 8:23am

I heard Walt’s kid is a senior this year….

BYU Grounds

Dec 24, 12:53pm

At least 3 had decent to solid careers. Wow, need to do better going forward.

NorCal_Coug

Dec 24, 8:17am

The infamous Walt Williams

crimedog

Dec 24, 8:18am

Any chance 247 had some of these guys ranked too high?

Tuskaloosa Cougar

Dec 24, 9:09am

My favorite was Walt Williams. Dude could play.

kimdaddy35

Dec 24, 9:44am

He was a D2 1st team All-American after leaving JC

Indy Coug

Dec 24, 10:36am

So he still has eligibility?

Dec 24, 1:30pm

Like I said, he could play.

kimdaddy35

Dec 24, 3:03pm

Lesson here is don't get to hyped over ANY recruit until they play CFB

SoValleyCOUG

Dec 24, 10:24am

Illuminating. 247 is a media company with subscriptions and ads run by journalists w/ fans and journalists as customers

GoodBetterBestBYU

Dec 24, 10:32am

Now do the top transfers to BYU. This would be a much more interesting list

SnickSnack

Dec 24, 11:31am

I'd look up schools who consistently have recruiting classes that high but then

Ripliancum

Dec 24, 11:37am

Withing 6 years we'll have a signing class that matches this all time list.

Ripliancum

Dec 24, 2:11pm

Hopefully much sooner than 6 years.

SnickSnack

Dec 24, 4:44pm

I heard Walt Williams is on his way to campus

Your Royal Blueness

Dec 24, 2:24pm

Mangum would’ve been amazing absent mental health issues.

WP17

Dec 24, 7:20pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad