No I'm not, I'm just not fine with saying "Well, they played a tougher schedule,

Report problem with this ad

Dec 21, 2024
3:41:06pm

benny1982 Your Mom

so their 3 TD loss to a very middling Oklahoma team and their loss to a middling Vanderbilt team don't matter at all."

Report problem with this ad

benny1982

Bio page: benny1982
Joined: Oct 18, 2003
Last login: Dec 22, 2024
Total posts: 63,396 (26,688 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

I care about entertainment more than fairness, so just give me Bama at PSU, Ole

Odysseus

Dec 21, 12:41pm

So you would rather be entertained than have BYU make the playoffs?

spidercoug

Dec 21, 12:43pm

If we are one of the top 12 teams then I would love to be in the CFP

Odysseus

Dec 21, 12:46pm

But none of three you're asking for are, so why would BYU get in?

NGB

Dec 21, 1:01pm

You don’t think Bama is better than Indiana, SMU, or Boise? I bet they’d be

Odysseus

Dec 21, 1:09pm

Huh?

NGB

Dec 21, 1:46pm

You lost me

Odysseus

Dec 21, 2:33pm

Why should Ole Miss get in?

NGB

Dec 21, 2:47pm

#7 in Sagarin, #8 FPI, top 5 QB, beat UGA and SCar by 3 scores

Odysseus

Dec 21, 3:32pm

How much was Bama favored over Vanderbilt or Oklahoma?

benny1982

Dec 21, 1:56pm

I want the CFP committee to pick who they think are the best 12 teams. I don’t

Odysseus

Dec 21, 2:33pm

If Alabama really wanted to prove that they were one of the best 12 teams

benny1982

Dec 21, 2:43pm

Absolutely

NGB

Dec 21, 2:47pm

Also, don't take this as a defense of BSU, SMU, or anyone else. I just don't

benny1982

Dec 21, 2:58pm

That’s like saying an undefeated 1A school has a stronger résumé than a 3-loss

Odysseus

Dec 21, 3:18pm

No. That's not what I was saying at all. Read my other post.

benny1982

Dec 21, 3:25pm

You are ignoring the disparity in schedule strengths… and I’ll go a step farther

Odysseus

Dec 21, 3:34pm

No I'm not, I'm just not fine with saying "Well, they played a tougher schedule,

benny1982

Dec 21, 3:41pm

Who said it doesn’t matter at all? I’d just weight SOS and big wins more

Odysseus

Dec 21, 3:42pm

Well, I'm not saying ignore SOS, either.

benny1982

Dec 21, 3:43pm

What I WANT will never happen--more P5 teams playing each other in OOC games.

benny1982

Dec 21, 3:47pm

Then why do you want Colorado in?

spidercoug

Dec 21, 3:23pm

Have you checked out WWE? Pretty entertaining.

Unibro

Dec 21, 12:49pm

Maybe if you’re into that stuff.

bluecougar1985

Dec 21, 12:53pm

This is why the CFP people get away with it. Make stuff up. And people take it.

KCFan85

Dec 21, 1:05pm

At the end of the day, the “CFP people” have to make subjective decisions

Odysseus

Dec 21, 1:14pm

Screw that...let's just make playoff spots based on top12 in preseason rankings so all the bluebloods are taken care of

CLCougar

Dec 21, 1:18pm

I’ve been telling my friends this—CFP will just turn people to the NFL

Ski-U-Mah

Dec 21, 1:35pm

Most watched, most followed CFB season in a long time, maybe ever

byuTX

Dec 21, 1:38pm

Only because of the novel playoff structure. Once folks realize it’s just more

Ski-U-Mah

Dec 21, 1:57pm

People have been saying the sport is doomed forever. It’s just gonna get more popular, despite what get off my lawns say

byuTX

Dec 21, 2:01pm

Bad take. NIL, transfer Portal, etc. are making CFB more like the NFL

NGB

Dec 21, 2:38pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad