But they didn’t both win. Sanders did. Jeanty didn’t.

Dec 17, 2024
3:01:25pm

Greg Kite's 'stache All-American

Jeantybis a great player. Will be fun to watch what he does at the next level.

I don't personally believe he was as far outside the normal relative to the competition and time he played in than Sanders was.

Jeanty was great. Sanders was otherworldly.

Report problem with this ad

Greg Kite's 'stache

Bio page: Greg Kite's 'stache
Joined: May 18, 2011
Last login: Dec 18, 2024
Total posts: 8,441 (453 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Ok, I'm gonna come out and let the elephant out in the room on Jeanty. We're all thinking this.

BIG XII Coug Unemployed BIG XII advisor

Dec 17, 12:25pm

Kind of a side note, but I'm really proud of my kids for recognizing how awful

benny1982

Dec 17, 12:29pm

My 15 year old daughter told her friend's dad in a Utah sweater that the ward party wasn't an ugly sweater contest. She

byuTX

Dec 17, 12:31pm

In the national guard, in the time after you enlist but before you go to

TheNerd

Dec 17, 12:41pm

Kid's a baller

BaylorBear

Dec 17, 4:29pm

How can you not? You look at it and it just repulses a normal person. It's

EM_Puma

Dec 17, 12:36pm

Imagine if Barry Sanders played a weak schedule with 14 games instead of 11 vs. better teams

byuTX

Dec 17, 12:29pm

and got a camouflage uni for his home field. Not unreasonable to think he would have racked up 3,000 maybe 4,000

BIG XII Coug

Dec 17, 12:31pm

It’s like catching a cheetah in the Serengeti. Put the cheetah in a Walmart

Fatalplacebo

Dec 17, 12:37pm

Here's a comparison between Jeanty and Sanders after Jeanty's and Sander's regular seasons

Greg Kite's 'stache

Dec 17, 12:34pm

Jeanty sat out the 2nd half of two games. Based on his carries I think Barry

citron

Dec 17, 12:38pm

Regardless-they have the exact same amount of carries after their respective regular season were over

Greg Kite's 'stache

Dec 17, 2:58pm

But you have no idea

BYU '80

Dec 17, 5:02pm

Except Jeanty wasn't running against Sanders. Both could win in their respective years.

Soupie

Dec 17, 2:29pm

But they didn’t both win. Sanders did. Jeanty didn’t.

Greg Kite's 'stache

Dec 17, 3:01pm

Barry beat 0-11 Kansas st, 0-10 Miami Ohio, 1-10 kansas. That one win for KU

citron

Dec 17, 12:35pm

Yes. But he never played USU. That’s cakewalk.

Fatalplacebo

Dec 17, 12:39pm

Correct. Jeanty didn't play after halftime in that one.

citron

Dec 17, 12:41pm

Overall still a much easier schedule for BSU

byuTX

Dec 17, 12:39pm

No, not really. Barry played 2 ranked teams during regular season. Lost both.

citron

Dec 17, 12:51pm

That has nothing to do with it. How many yards did he have. What was his YPC?

Socrates Johnson

Dec 17, 2:16pm

I didn't start this discussion on SOS.

citron

Dec 17, 3:56pm

Right but who won the game isn't the measure. it's how barry played.

Socrates Johnson

Dec 17, 4:20pm

My point was that he only played 2 ranked teams...this idea that he played a

citron

Dec 17, 4:38pm

So you look at the top end games and ignore the rest. Top to bottom

BYU '80

Dec 17, 5:03pm

Well if you actually followed the thread you would see I started at the bottom.

citron

Dec 17, 5:31pm

And two ranked teams. That leaves 5-6 other games including the bowl

BYU '80

Dec 17, 7:32pm

they did play an easy schedule. and jeanty has a MWC oline. people act like

FieroCoug

Dec 17, 12:40pm

Oline wasn’t really important. Teams he played don’t know how to tackle.

bluecougar1985

Dec 17, 12:43pm

His yards after contact is insane.

JuicyJam

Dec 17, 12:50pm

He went against the weakest D1 defenses in the country, except Oregon.

Mabuhay Coug

Dec 17, 4:40pm

except they stacked completely stacked the defenses against him.

FieroCoug

1:40am

And you know Sanders didn’t sit second halves at all?

BYU '80

Dec 17, 5:08pm

I never made that claim, but I do remember watching him in college and pro

Mabuhay Coug

Dec 17, 7:29pm

Jeanty is just Tyler Allgeier who stayed healthy

BYU Fan

Dec 17, 12:31pm

the dude has almost 2000 YAC. if it was easy, everyone would do it.

FieroCoug

Dec 17, 12:41pm

In a P4 conference, nobody (Jeanty, Sanders, any NFL RB) would do it.

bluecougar1985

Dec 17, 12:44pm

And they are tied in Heismans

byuTX

Dec 17, 1:02pm

Except for this fact. The Lone Star HS product is one of the most difficult players to tackle, setting College Football

airwolf

Dec 17, 1:08pm

Of course he is. He's literally invisible to start every play and then defenders just see a blur. Much harder to tackle

BIG XII Coug

Dec 17, 1:21pm

Was there a significant difference in his production home v. away?

WVU_Prof

Dec 17, 2:49pm

weak MWC is likely a bigger factor that the turf

Hill4Heisman

Dec 17, 1:20pm

Why does this never come up for teams that wear green? Is baylor camo'ed in Waco

NGB

Dec 17, 1:54pm

Or Tulane?

neboutefan

Dec 17, 2:34pm

Doubt it impacts the players but it sure messes with your eyes watching on TV. Difference w/ green is

Soupie

Dec 17, 2:39pm

Not buying it. I rejoice every time BYU plays BSU and wins, but I can see talent

BoiseBYU1

Dec 17, 2:24pm

Oregon St and Washington St were horrible on D. Oregon was his only good D

Mabuhay Coug

Dec 17, 4:44pm

Well, UNLV has the 20th best rushing defense and Jeanty ran for 128 (33)

BoiseBYU1

Dec 17, 8:28pm

Washington st and Oregon st are g5. Boise State had a terrible schedule.

slccoug

Dec 17, 6:59pm

Boo hoo hoo.

coastcat

Dec 17, 3:08pm

You do realize the players aren’t looking at him from above like we are, right?

byuinva

Dec 17, 3:12pm

Thanks for coming out.

maweien

Dec 17, 3:25pm

I don't buy this.

Dwide_Schrude

Dec 17, 4:27pm

People actually really believe this nonsense?

CougStuckOnTheHill

Dec 17, 5:35pm

Are you sure it was an elephant? And where was it before?

StoneyCurtis

Dec 17, 6:00pm

Jeanty was the best player in college football this year, by far!

coot20

Dec 17, 7:37pm

Best RB, maybe. Best player was Hunter. He’s guaranteed a top 5 pick in the

slccoug

Dec 17, 7:45pm

There is absolutely no way that a player that is going to beat Barry Sanders

jaba166

Dec 17, 8:02pm

Bit over the top with dramatics but I do agree the Jeanty should have won IMO.

Soupie

Dec 17, 8:54pm

It's the actual objective data / numbers that are dramatic

jaba166

Dec 17, 8:56pm

The criteria for voting for Heisman, is Best Player. Not most yardage.

slccoug

Dec 17, 9:04pm

RE: Ok, I'm gonna come out and let the elephant out in the room on Jeanty. We're

Str8CashCougar

Dec 17, 8:43pm

Yeah, and no one can see Michigan State and Marshall because there jerseys are

coventry94

Dec 17, 9:54pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad