Solid list

Sign up, and you'll be able to ignore users whose posts you don't want to see. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Dec 2, 2024
7:52:52pm

cajuncoug Truly Addicted User

Solid list

Of those, I'll take Collie, Nacua, and Kozlowski over Roberts with practically no hesitation

The remaining are probably arguable one way or another. Is Roberts better than all of them? Probably not. But he's close enough to where calling him an all-time great isn't crazy at all.

Report problem with this ad

cajuncoug

Bio page: cajuncoug
Joined: Aug 8, 2003
Last login: Dec 4, 2024
Total posts: 10,682 (186 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Current player I think could go down as one of the best at their position

Dec 2, 3:45pm

I love all these guys and they are very good but none come close to best ever

Bluforever

Dec 2, 3:48pm

Chase Roberts?

Dec 2, 3:49pm

He's good. Top ten good? I don't know.

cambo

Dec 2, 3:51pm

Name 9 WRs better

Dec 2, 3:53pm

RE: Name 9 WRs better

The Y's Insider

Dec 2, 4:09pm

IMO, Roberts is better than Miller (less deep speed) Boyce (lesser speed and

Threw and Through

Dec 2, 6:37pm

Solid list

cajuncoug

Dec 2, 7:52pm

When he's done with the NFL, there won't be 10 BYU receivers with more NFL receiving yards. He's definitely top 10.

HarlemCoug

Dec 2, 8:39pm

IMO, Roberts will struggle in the NFL. He just isn't fast enough.

Lance71

Dec 2, 9:46pm

6’4”, tough, great hands, excellent routes - he’ll make it.

Bluforever

Dec 2, 10:00pm

When you said one of the best, that meant top 2 or 3 to me. Chase is prob top 10

Bluforever

Dec 2, 3:53pm

I meant top 10 for all of them

Dec 2, 3:54pm

I think Roberts absolutely fit's the Puka, Collie line of greats...

Coug

Dec 2, 3:52pm

The difference between Puka @ Y and Puka @ Rams is enormous and speaks to NFL QB

MrSandman

Dec 2, 3:58pm

You mean there is a difference between a former #1 overall pick, 15-yr vet ...

Coop

Dec 2, 4:08pm

I didn’t realize J. Hall was a juco transfer. Guess he’ll never sniff the NFL

MrSandman

Dec 2, 6:15pm

Right, that is the proper comparison, and Jaren and Stafford are identical

Coop

Dec 2, 9:02pm

This is a huge issue with Arod. Collie called him out on it

Frankfromtheballpark

Dec 2, 8:41pm

Puka also missed majority of his final year in Provo. I think he shows out a

Riseandshoutboys

Dec 2, 11:20pm

I’d choose JoJo Phillips … needs more reps and will be amazing.

CougFan4EverEver

Dec 2, 3:49pm

You mean JoJo the Drop Ball King?

GoodGuyGary1

Dec 2, 7:16pm

He’s a redshirt freshman.

HiLife

Dec 2, 7:41pm

Micah Simon was a bad WR until he wasn’t

puntersarepeople

Dec 2, 8:33pm

Lassiter has lots of drops, too.

Forzaitalia

Dec 2, 9:23pm

Glasker is and will continue to be better than Taggart

SV72 Sale

Dec 2, 4:02pm

I’d put in $100

I'mBatman

Dec 2, 4:07pm

I'd like to think this is pretty close.

JuicyJam

Dec 2, 11:52pm

Any idea how much of the sales revenue goes to the player?

HarlemCoug

Dec 3, 8:25am

I firmly believe Glasker has NFL potential. He and Jack Kelly are the only two I

Riseandshoutboys

Dec 2, 6:33pm

Lassiter, Roberts, and JoJo do as well IMO

puntersarepeople

Dec 2, 8:35pm

I can see JoJo developing into an nfl guy. You lose me with Roberts and Lassiter

Riseandshoutboys

Dec 2, 11:18pm

Well, someone that must have some credibility is whispering the contrary to

Jasbo

Dec 2, 11:27pm

Probably a mix of NFL agents and a desire to be done with college ball.

Riseandshoutboys

Dec 2, 11:40pm

Milne made a roster multiple years and these two aren’t any worse than him

puntersarepeople

Dec 2, 11:55pm

Milne is a tough comp imo. He, like Zach, benefitted greatly from the 2020

Riseandshoutboys

Dec 3, 12:04am

Taggart led us in tackles coming into the ASU game,

Threw and Through

Dec 2, 6:56pm

Wow thats crazy to have that kind of speed at inside linebacker

RUNBYU1

Dec 2, 8:27pm

You think any of those guys could be top 5 all-time at their position?

Projectoor

Dec 2, 4:39pm

Marion is probably a top 5 all time KR after this year. Definitely pushing it

puntersarepeople

Dec 2, 6:16pm

He’s returned a couple for TD’s but he’s also tried to return about 25 over past

Bluforever

Dec 2, 6:38pm

An extra 80 yards every once in a while makes up for tons of 5 yard losses

y2kougar

Dec 2, 10:11pm

Not for me. We started in the hole far too many times; it’s tough to drive 80 yd

Bluforever

Dec 2, 10:19pm

Statistically it’s much better, trust me

y2kougar

Dec 2, 10:57pm

I’m not sure enough of those are on him for it to matter

puntersarepeople

Dec 2, 11:37pm

Agree re: Glasker

cajuncoug

Dec 2, 7:59pm

Ferrin

ochobeeguy

Dec 2, 10:09pm

Jakob Robinson is a Top 5 CB at BYU.

Dec 2, 10:17pm

He is the one from this year's team. He was phenomenal.

kimdaddy35

Dec 2, 11:47pm

What kicker would be picked over Will Ferrin with the game on the line?

Kolipoki

Dec 2, 10:31pm

I think you’re right. But if I had to choose one kicker to deliver a big hit…

Reasonable1

Dec 2, 10:37pm

Totally agree. If Payne is in the HoF then they should already be prepping

Kolipoki

Dec 2, 11:06pm

I don’t want a kicker to hit. I want one to clutch kick. Payne cost

pappabear246

Dec 3, 12:18am

He was not as good as a young Jake Oldroyd. So hopefully he can stack some seasons together.

kimdaddy35

Dec 2, 11:49pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad