The offense hasn't played a complete game all season. They've been buoyed by defensive and special teams TDs and

Report problem with this ad

Nov 17, 2024
8:22:08am

foofcoug Wonder what the character limi

the defense has put them on many favorable spots with turnovers deep in scoring territory.

This message has been modified

Originally posted on Nov 17, 2024 at 8:22:08am

Message modified by foofcoug on Nov 17, 2024 at 8:23:32am

Report problem with this ad

foofcoug

Bio page: foofcoug
Joined: Jul 7, 2004
Last login: Nov 17, 2024
Total posts: 138,485 (51,474 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Y'all need to stop looking 4 scapegoats. ARod isn't the problem. He's a good OC

runnincoug

8:12am

He's not a good OC. FIFY.

foofcoug

8:13am

Nice argument. What's your evidence?

runnincoug

8:17am

Recruiting. Clock management. Game management. Situational awareness. Play calling. Execution. Player development.

foofcoug

8:19am

Yeah let’s rehire Anae! He sent lots of guys to the NFL … oh wait

puntersarepeople

8:24am

Why do BYU fans want to retread so many coaches? "If it's not our current guy, then it has to be the guy who coached

foofcoug

8:26am

Arod statistically is an above average OC. If you fire him, you have a greater

runnincoug

8:28am

13 points against the worst defense they faced all year. 13.

foofcoug

8:29am

You don't fire someone because of an off night. Yes they missed twice in the ...

runnincoug

8:38am

KU took away its OC's playcalling and started winning games.

88Coug

8:40am

It has been much more than 1 off night. But continue to see it that way if you like.

foofcoug

8:40am

Two off nights. Before that we led the league in scoring (or were 2nd?)

puntersarepeople

9:01am

I bring up Anae because he is a good comparison for what you would get from an

puntersarepeople

9:00am

Nice argument, where's your evidence? Any actual data like I provided?

runnincoug

8:25am

The data you provided like attributing him to recruiting 2 guys he didn't? Just because it's data doesn't mean it's fact

foofcoug

8:27am

I've shared lots more data on this thread.

runnincoug

8:28am

There was also lots of data for keeping Tuiaki - giving up yards not points. Does mean he was a good DC or that BYU

foofcoug

8:30am

ARod is the biggest thing holding the team back.

88Coug

8:14am

"holding us back?" We're 9-1. How common do you think that kind of record is?

runnincoug

8:19am

It is not because of him but in spite of him.

88Coug

8:20am

Who has he recruited himself? He doesn’t.

Magneto

8:14am

three straight NFL QBs for starters. Maybe he's great at finding lower rated

runnincoug

8:18am

Zack and Jaren were both Grimes and Kalani.

Magneto

8:22am

ARod was the offensive consultant and passing game coordinator that recruited

runnincoug

8:25am

I believe it was Grimes, Kalani, and Fesi who went after him.

Magneto

8:32am

Arod was involved. he was offensive consultant in 2017 & then Wilson's QB coach

runnincoug

8:35am

ARod coached him correct. He did not recruit Wilson nor Hall.

Magneto

9:05am

He’s Tuiaki but for offense. There’s a reason teams aren’t trying to poach him. He needs to head to FCS where he belongs

byuTX

8:16am

That's just not true at all. Tuiaki's defenses were legit horrible. Our offense

runnincoug

8:18am

He should have been let go last year after a bottom 20 offense

byuTX

8:20am

If we had done that, we wouldn't be 9-1 this year, I guarantee that.

runnincoug

8:21am

We might have been 10-0

88Coug

8:26am

Wouldn’t have lost last night for sure

byuTX

8:28am

He's not the reason we lost last night. We lost because:

runnincoug

8:32am

How can you blame KS for not calling a timeout on a false start? He didn’t

Cougarite

9:31am

He shouldn’t have called a timeout on 4th and short only to then send out the FG team

byuTX

9:37am

I'd have to look at it again, but if it seems the offense is confused or rushing

runnincoug

9:43am

I would have to look at it again too. I just remember the entire line moving

Cougarite

9:44am

If only we had a coach to coordinate this offense

byuTX

9:38am

We are 9-1 because of luck in spite of QB/coaching. Hard to say whether we would have the same luck again. D would

byuTX

8:27am

As an example, this data shows firing an OC usually doesn't help.

runnincoug

8:22am

The offense hasn't played a complete game all season. They've been buoyed by defensive and special teams TDs and

foofcoug

8:22am

Ludwig has had more success as an OC and has had to deal with a serious number of injuries last 2 seasons...

Coug

8:22am

And how did that work out for Utah, firing Ludwig twice?

runnincoug

8:23am

Made zero difference... Just like keeping ARod it's made zero difference

Coug

8:28am

Utah has a great defense and hasn’t gone 9-1 either of the last 2 years.

puntersarepeople

8:26am

CB: Whitt is horrible at managing OCs! He's so dumb! Also CB: Fire ARod despite

runnincoug

8:26am

131st in RedZone production our last 3 games, 3 offensive TD's in the last 10 quarters of football

Coug

8:36am

Now do all year. BYU is 21st in the country in red zone production.

runnincoug

8:40am

We have no significant injuries to account for the bad trend at all... It's complacentcy...

Coug

8:46am

Or ... let's think about this ... we played our rival/best defense in the conf &

runnincoug

8:54am

So a coach who regresses to the mean is awful?

puntersarepeople

9:04am

Biggest thing holding Ludwig back is the same reason every other Utah OC left

LV Coug

8:31am

And I would hire Ludwig in a second over ARod.

Coug

8:38am

He’s average. He’s not awful, like some are saying. But he’s not great either. He has terrible and good games. Average

bag

8:58am

Statistically above average. I'll agree he's not exceptional. But not the reason

runnincoug

9:44am

I like him. I think he’s innovative and adapts to his personnel. He tries to get

Cougarite

9:51am

I do prefer ARod over Grimes

Posting on CougarBoard