Each one is unique. BYU has a big campus and massive enrollment that can feel impersonal. Hawaii is tiny and feels a bit like high school. Rexburg is somewhere in between.
Nobody is saying there aren’t amazing, intelligent kids at all these schools.
Now compare the ACTs and GPAs of these schools and tell me which one is elite.
My original post was mostly tongue in cheek. The reactions from the BYU Idaho people are hilariously insecure.