This is how I remember it as well. To this day I, a non-medical person, assumed

Nov 14, 2024
10:27:43pm

bythenumbers Intervention Needed

it's cool to play on a lisfranc injury cause Taysom was told it's ok. So that's how I've been approaching how I think about this similar situation with Rose.

This message has been modified

Originally posted on Nov 14, 2024 at 10:27:43pm

Message modified by bythenumbers on Nov 14, 2024 at 10:29:04pm

Report problem with this ad

bythenumbers

Bio page: bythenumbers
Joined: Mar 16, 2020
Last login: Nov 14, 2024
Total posts: 2,447 (2 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

If it really did happen in the second quarter, Drake Toll is right.

cougfanblue Assistant to the manager

Nov 14, 5:20pm

Yeah, no other program would ever have a QB keep playing on a lis franc injury. Right?

Tokolosh

Nov 14, 5:23pm

Not when their healthy starter is ready to go.

Brandoblueblood

Nov 14, 5:25pm

Wilson pretty clearly got benched. He wasn’t the starter

RealTaysomHill

Nov 14, 5:31pm

Wilson was ready to go and he was the starter for most games

Brandoblueblood

Nov 14, 9:07pm

Why did he not start vs. BYU? Was he injured?

RealTaysomHill

Nov 14, 11:10pm

For the entire game? No.

Ironhide

Nov 14, 5:29pm

Did they ask rose if he wanted to play or did they tell him he had too?

here's to hoping

Nov 14, 7:43pm

I think o ce I heard a player with that injury say that he was told by trainers that he wouldn’t injure it any more to

KYU

Nov 14, 8:13pm

Wow

44C

Nov 14, 10:00pm

Are you thinking about the Kaufusi injury? I don't think it was Lisfranc.

ParentingNotForSissy

Nov 14, 10:27pm

I think it was taysom. He played a few drives after the injury. Knowing what it was

KYU

Nov 14, 11:53pm

That’s a bad take when BYU did the exact same thing with Taysom.

cougaman

Nov 14, 5:23pm

Didn't he only play like 2 series after it happened?

thewaterboy

Nov 14, 5:24pm

Yes, limited, and they put in the backup. In this case, Rose was the backup

Brandoblueblood

Nov 14, 5:26pm

2 or 3. He still played though.

cougaman

Nov 14, 5:26pm

So until it was apparent he had an injury and the backup would be better?

Brandoblueblood

Nov 14, 5:30pm

No. It was apparent he had an injury BEFORE HE WENT BACK IN. And it’s been

cougaman

Nov 14, 5:31pm

At halftime Taysom was told he had lis franc season ending.

JoeExotic

Nov 14, 5:45pm

That’s exactly the way I remember it.

ledfoot

Nov 14, 6:54pm

I think it was bad advice. You can make anything worse by playing on it.

JoeExotic

Nov 14, 6:57pm

4 series, entire 3rd quarter and bronco pulled him when BYU lost the lead

NarfUte

Nov 14, 5:30pm

Narfute:

Toubibe

Nov 14, 5:45pm

And that was Bronco's last year, so we can say anything we want

spidercoug

Nov 14, 5:25pm

When did they do that? His lisfranc against Nebraska - he left after a quarter of play

Bob Vance

Nov 14, 5:30pm

He played into the 4th quarter.

byubyu

Nov 14, 5:36pm

You're right. But it was the beginning of the 4th quarter after a successful run. I seem to recall from Taysom that

Bob Vance

Nov 14, 5:52pm

My memory is that Taysom asked if it would become more injured by playing and

here's to hoping

Nov 14, 7:41pm

It’s not appropriate for me to share the details

Medute

Nov 14, 10:22pm

Well, as a Ute, you would know more about BYU than me. That was what was being

here's to hoping

Nov 14, 10:27pm

I don't think he's saying you're wrong, I think he's saying that was a bad.

bythenumbers

Nov 14, 10:28pm

I was mostly just being cheeky. I do genuinely assume he knows more about the

here's to hoping

Nov 14, 10:35pm

This is how I remember it as well. To this day I, a non-medical person, assumed

bythenumbers

Nov 14, 10:27pm

I don’t agree with this take at all. If he was a better option than Wilson

Pee Wee Reese

Nov 14, 5:27pm

It would be the second time this season that a QB was injured early, and played throughout the entire game only to

Bob Vance

Nov 14, 5:30pm

Begs the question. How much in the dog house is Isaac Wilson?

Squirt

Nov 14, 5:30pm

I don't see a problem with this unless Rose didn't want to play.

Team Chaos

Nov 14, 5:34pm

We don’t know enough. Taysom wanted to play…

cajuncoug

Nov 14, 7:04pm

There are plenty of things to hate on Utah about. This is a really dumb one.

bythenumbers

Nov 14, 5:35pm

I think this is a result of the compound effect of Drake seeing problem after

YOHONOMOTO

Nov 14, 6:56pm

Frankly, I think this is nowhere near as bad as when they played Rising hurt

krindorr

Nov 14, 5:42pm

The Rising one was the real head scratcher. He was hurting the team.

bythenumbers

Nov 14, 5:47pm

Concussion is one thing, lower leg injury is not the same. If you can bear the

Powerbait DPM

Nov 14, 5:47pm

I remember Riley Nelson played injured all the time.

Shore10

Nov 14, 6:03pm

But do you remember him playing healthy?

sah22

Nov 14, 8:20pm

But he had Grit..

Recipefordisaster

Nov 14, 10:44pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad