No shot, and we shouldn’t. There are essentially 9 conferences after this year. A 5 loss conference champ is not

Nov 14, 2024
7:09:58am

RealTaysomHill All-American

getting in. Nobody is ranking a 7-5 BYU (or any other Big 12 school) over an 11-1 or even 10-2 AAC/MAC/MWC/Sun Belt/C-USA/PAC champ.

Report problem with this ad

RealTaysomHill

Previous username: Alpi Gusto
Bio page: RealTaysomHill
Joined: Feb 7, 2011
Last login: Nov 14, 2024
Total posts: 15,993 (2,330 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

So let me get this straight. Prior to the Big 12, BYU had to be perfect to make

Borg

Nov 13, 11:05pm

Just win.

Aircooled

Nov 13, 11:06pm

^^^^^^^THIS^^^^^^^^

Pangare

8:30am

BYU can lose one and maybe 2 games and still get in with a CCG win.

Uno Doctoro

Nov 13, 11:07pm

Boise & Army (if they beat ND) could edge us out in that scenario.

zerome4sooners

5:10am

not if you win the CCG. No G5 will ever get an at large bid...

kaladin58

5:57am

Not talking about G5 getting at large. Boise and army would be top 5 conf champs

zerome4sooners

6:09am

G5 only gets one auto. they would have to be ranked in the top 12...

kaladin58

7:00am

If Boise is ranked 9th, Army 15th, and BYU 16th...we (and B12) are odd man out.

zerome4sooners

7:16am

I stand corrected. no auto bids. I guess army could sneak in but not likely

kaladin58

7:18am

right. if they beat ND, then convo is interesting. see last para of ESPN article

zerome4sooners

7:47am

BYU would need 2 losses to fall below Army. 11-2 BYU still decent chance of CFP

NYC and Japan

8:39am

"Could" but do you really see the 24th ranked team jumping 12+ spots by beating

BYUFam1

7:44am

You don't have to be perfect if you win the Championship Game.

Blue Ghost

Nov 13, 11:07pm

Quit raining on his pity parade with truth.

Big Daddy D

Nov 13, 11:11pm

RE: Quit raining on his pity parade with truth.

Borg

Nov 13, 11:16pm

Top 4 highest ranked conference champions. If for example Boise is ranked higher than the Big12 champ guess what???

GangstaLean

Nov 13, 11:14pm

Any conference? MWC over a Big 12 conference champ gets the bye…

Borg

Nov 13, 11:17pm

<< Deleted >>

zerome4sooners

5:12am

Top 5. Not top 4

Eddie

Nov 13, 11:33pm

Top 5 get in, the top 4 get a bye.

JohnnyComeLately

Nov 13, 11:35pm

13-0 bye. 12-1 in with potential bye. 11-2 in with CCG win.

insanobueno

Nov 13, 11:11pm

^^^ This

TLCougar

Nov 13, 11:16pm

Not at 10-3 or 9-4. ESPN Playoff Predictor has AAC champ as 5th highest conferen

Coug-Ida

2:04am

I'm not sure that's right. I think there's still AQ status for P4 teams.

WVU_Prof

4:58am

Nope. Wording is top 5 highest ranked.

cougarfan84

5:46am

Incorrect. Nothing protects P4. 5 highest Conf champs get in, 4 highest get byes

Coug-Ida

10:25am

Not this year. But could happen in other years if the loss is early OOC

insanobueno

7:47am

I agree not this year, I responded to you saying at 9-4 BYU would get in if CC.

Coug-Ida

10:35am

It is literally impossible for BYU to be 9-4 and conference champion.

NYC and Japan

8:42am

This year yes...but I think the 9-4 discussion is hypothetical.

WVU_Prof

9:02am

Impossible this year. Very unlikely but could happen other years

insanobueno

9:05am

Literally not even a 1 in a million chance to be a 4 loss champion AND in CFP

NYC and Japan

9:36am

Not to repeat myself, but w/ 2 losses we’ll need Boise or Army to lose 1 more

zerome4sooners

5:13am

It isn’t about straight up wins and losses.

Eddie

Nov 13, 11:11pm

No they couldn’t. A 5 loss Big 12 champ isn’t getting an auto bid. The MWC and AAC champs would get in over us

RealTaysomHill

Nov 13, 11:19pm

Depends on what they are ranked.

Eddie

Nov 13, 11:32pm

VERY doubtful a 5 loss B12 champ gets in over AAC champ. Possible but unlikely.

Coug-Ida

2:11am

No shot, and we shouldn’t. There are essentially 9 conferences after this year. A 5 loss conference champ is not

RealTaysomHill

7:09am

a 5 loss conference champion is highly unlikely and will never be in CFP, unless

NYC and Japan

8:44am

Indy BYU probably wouldn't have made it in even without a loss under the 4 team format.

ManicBlue

Nov 13, 11:12pm

Not even an undefeated FSU made it in last year. Indy BYU would have to have

wildwilderness

12:02am

Just need to win CCG. Don’t have to be perfect. Just can’t lose CCG.

Boring

Nov 13, 11:18pm

<< Deleted >>

Shawarma

Nov 13, 11:22pm

A 12-1 byu team is in. 2 losses and definitely not

cougarfann888

Nov 13, 11:34pm

It's not a sham. We are still happy w our opportunity.

VenomFarmer

Nov 13, 11:38pm

We can lose 2 of the next 3, if we get in the CCG and win, we're in.

rtNelson

Nov 13, 11:49pm

12-1 BYU would absolutely get in. That would mean we got to 12-0 and were ranked

andrewg3

12:09am

That’s his point. It’s a potential no. 12-1 could lose out to a 3 loss SEC team.

ImuaKahuku

5:43am

12-1 will not lose out to a 3-loss SEC team. No chance of that. I don't think

cougarfan84

5:48am

Never underestimate the dark side (SEC).

gopman

6:45am

Look at the CFP rankings, only 1 SEC in top 6, 2 in top 9. You're not paying

NYC and Japan

8:48am

I actually agree with you. SEC hacks in the media are starting to develop

gopman

9:32am

Not sure the disconnect but SEC/B1G are all about only one team from all other

ImuaKahuku

5:51am

0 chance B1G has more than 4 teams in CFP. SEC highly unlikely to have 5 or more

NYC and Japan

8:50am

Not true

cougforever

7:07am

It went from P5 to P2 with one round of conference realignment.

Spiff

7:45am

If BYU is undefeated and loses the conference championship

canuckchuck

7:55am

One more reason 12 teams is still crap. Go to 24-28 like ALL the other divisions

RUNBYU1

10:12am

Well technically it's still true because you can be a two loss team and win the

YOHONOMOTO

11:21am

WSU and Oregon State did more damage to us by partnering with the MWC. Boise' looks better with a now ranked WSU win.

AltTabbins

11:26am

BYU could be 11-2 and make the CFP

Bobmarleyjr

11:27am

Florida State went 13-0 and finished #5 and missed the playoffs

Zoobieman

11:41am

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad