It would have been enforced on the extra point

Report problem with this ad

Nov 11, 2024
8:59:08pm

CougarEat Playmaker

It would have been enforced on the extra point

Report problem with this ad

CougarEat

Bio page: CougarEat
Joined: Jul 21, 2008
Last login: Nov 22, 2024
Total posts: 1,415 (0 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Probably already discussed, but it would have been hilarious if Utah had pulled off a miracle on the kick return

Skeptical Optimist Political Junky

Nov 11, 8:38pm

I think that penalty wouldn't have called back a TD.

momowagon

Nov 11, 8:43pm

How?

Nov 11, 8:44pm

The rulebook wording indicates that unsportsmanlike conduct on a non-player is always considered a dead-ball penalty

CougPrime

Nov 11, 8:46pm

It would have been enforced on the extra point

CougarEat

Nov 11, 8:59pm

Which wouldn't be played since a two point swing couldn't turn the game at that point.

CougPrime

Nov 11, 9:06pm

Why did we get the ball back in 2012 then?

RGGeemer

Nov 11, 9:09pm

Different penalty.

momowagon

Nov 11, 9:10pm

Different penalty for the same infraction? They could have called it 12 men on

RGGeemer

Nov 11, 9:17pm

Way to move the goalposts though haha

RGGeemer

Nov 11, 9:18pm

It matters what the ref says. Unsportsmanlike is a different penalty than

momowagon

Nov 11, 9:25pm

Nonsense. A non player could enter the field and block one off our players and the TD would still count

Skeptical Optimist

Nov 12, 4:27am

If it effects play it's a different penalty.

momowagon

Nov 12, 4:32am

Gif course it would. It would be a re-kick

stoils

Nov 11, 8:45pm

It was called as unsportsmanlike, not interfering with play.

momowagon

Nov 11, 8:47pm

Why did we get the ball back when they rushed the field in 2012 then?

RGGeemer

Nov 11, 8:51pm

That was called as sideline interference. They got in the way of the ballcarrier

momowagon

Nov 11, 8:53pm

No they didn't. Falslev was clear on the other side of the field.

RGGeemer

Nov 11, 8:57pm

Nope.

momowagon

Nov 11, 9:01pm

Yep

RGGeemer

Nov 11, 9:04pm

Another angle

RGGeemer

Nov 11, 9:07pm

And the call. Live ball foul.

RGGeemer

Nov 11, 9:08pm

Exactly. Not unsportsmanlike which is a dead ball foul. It's a different penalty

momowagon

Nov 11, 9:14pm

Of course not because we would decline it.

RGGeemer

Nov 11, 9:16pm

Sure. But why would it be enforced differently in that situation?

momowagon

Nov 11, 9:26pm

That's what I'm asking you. Same infraction. Shpuld be the same enforcement no?

RGGeemer

Nov 11, 10:03pm

Oh man, too bad he didn’t run to the far sideline. He would have gotten lost in their fans running on the field

Nov 11, 9:11pm

I don't know the answer and I'm not really following the debate, but I do

Nov 11, 10:11pm

Even better if one of our players just laid him out. He’s fair game IMO.

The Y's Insider

Nov 11, 8:58pm

Somebody got a great deal

mncstr

Nov 11, 9:45pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad