My Account
Sign up, and you'll be able to ignore users whose posts you don't want to see.
Sign up
Report problem with this ad
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Oct 31, 2024
10:57
:02
am
SouthernCoug
All-American
As you did, but I was making the point that if ISU wins out, BYU gets in
with a loss to any remaining team. So both comments are true.
A point I didn't make very well, and that was not an obvious response to your comment.
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Report problem with this ad
SouthernCoug
Bio page
SouthernCoug
Joined
May 23, 2001
Last login
Jan 13, 2025
Total posts
7,507 (499 FO)
Report problem with this ad
Messages
Author
Time
Listened to Kurtz explain B12 championship & I think BYU has to win out to get
SBB
10/31/24 4:49am
His assumption is that the tie breaker will be decided by conference opponent
cougar4life55
10/31/24 4:58am
Maybe i misunderstood or fell asleep.
SBB
10/31/24 5:00am
No, I think Kurtz just missed the fact that once the first seed is placed the
cougar4life55
10/31/24 5:02am
There is some ambiguity on if the K St win would count or not. The wording in
RGGeemer
10/31/24 5:24am
I read that argument, but how would it not? Once K-state is chosen as seed one,
cougar4life55
10/31/24 5:36am
A couple of items: 1) It reads 'NEXT highest seeded team' which implies the team
RGGeemer
10/31/24 6:24am
How is KSU not the next-highest in this scenario? It doesn’t say “next-lowest”.
Japan Coug
10/31/24 6:51am
I agree #1 doesn't make sense. Most people don't interpret it that way. #2
RGGeemer
10/31/24 7:12am
RE: There is some ambiguity on if the K St win would count or not. The wording
Tricky
10/31/24 9:19am
THat's #1. I can't imagine they interpret it 'next highest' though, but it's
RGGeemer
10/31/24 10:01am
It's ambiguous
rcbyufan
10/31/24 8:27am
Number1 tie breaker is he’d to head. If we all had 1 loss most likely BYU is 1
ImuaKahuku
10/31/24 10:25am
Incorrect. Head to head is not counted in multi-team tiebreakers unless 1) all
RGGeemer
10/31/24 10:30am
You sure about that?
ImuaKahuku
10/31/24 12:17pm
Thats only for a two team tie, need to read the 3+ team tiebreaker
BYUFootballisBack
10/31/24 12:25pm
BYU gets in CCG in all 1-loss tiebreakers if our 1 L is to ASU
RGGeemer
10/31/24 5:23am
I don't think it matters who we lose to. If BYU loses to Utah, Houston, or
cougar4life55
10/31/24 5:35am
Maybe - there is ambiguity in that interpretation. The online tiebreaker
RGGeemer
10/31/24 6:25am
He gives a good breakdown of why he interprets it this way here:
RGGeemer
10/31/24 6:28am
This is just some internet rando. His opinion is no better than anyone else’s,
Japan Coug
10/31/24 6:49am
I don't agree with it either. . . But I have accepted that not everything
Zoobieman
10/31/24 7:06am
Sure, I hope he's wrong. All that matters is how the conference interprets it.
RGGeemer
10/31/24 7:12am
Unless ISU loses to KSU. Then we get in ONLY if our loss is to ASU
SouthernCoug
10/31/24 8:50am
Isn't that what I said? We get in no matter what if our L is to ASU.
RGGeemer
10/31/24 9:03am
No, but I also didn't exactly respond to what you did say either, so...
SouthernCoug
10/31/24 10:19am
How did you interpret this?
RGGeemer
10/31/24 10:24am
As you did, but I was making the point that if ISU wins out, BYU gets in
SouthernCoug
10/31/24 10:57am
Gotcha. Yep also true.
RGGeemer
10/31/24 11:02am
I thought we could lose to Houston and still be in as well (but not both)
Lanterne Rouge
10/31/24 9:12am
In a 4-way tie with Colorado, that's true. In a 3-way with ISU and KSU, it's
RGGeemer
10/31/24 10:02am
Ah, thank you. That makes sense.
Lanterne Rouge
10/31/24 10:09am
RE: Unless ISU loses to KSU. Then we get in ONLY if our loss is to ASU
Japan Coug
10/31/24 9:22am
I dont think this is true. After H2H the next rule is record against the HIGHEST
MaximusMeridius
10/31/24 12:08pm
Maybe. There is ambiguity about if the K St W would count or not in our 2-way
RGGeemer
10/31/24 12:17pm
It's a good thing BYU is at their easier part of their schedule right now.
greatbam
10/31/24 5:51am
Ha ha. Very funny.
Happy As Larry
10/31/24 9:33am
What? Do you think Utah is going to be more difficult than UCF was last weekend? I don't. ASU IMO would be the..
greatbam
10/31/24 9:42am
Utah's D will be lightyears better than UCF's.
RGGeemer
10/31/24 10:03am
It will be different though. UCF was elite 1-dimensional offense w/ bad defense
rcbyufan
10/31/24 10:31am
BYU is in good shape
I'mBatman
10/31/24 11:35am
I am just going to wait after the Kansas game to buy tickets. . .
Zoobieman
10/31/24 7:04am
BYU has the predicted best record based on past performance and opponents
NYC and Japan
10/31/24 7:24am
Colorado would need to lose another one and Iowa St would need to beat KSU
Blue Ghost
10/31/24 8:18am
We are in the CCG in all 1-loss tiebreakers if our L is to ASU.
RGGeemer
10/31/24 8:25am
Ok. I believe you. So we better beat Utah.
Blue Ghost
10/31/24 8:39am
If Iowa State beats KState, 8-1 BYU would win the tiebreaker against Colorado
Zoobieman
10/31/24 8:40am
What is the tiebreaker? We have one of the easiest Big-12 Schedules
Blue Ghost
10/31/24 8:45am
I think we would be in due to record against common opponents (7-0 vs 6-1)
SouthernCoug
10/31/24 8:53am
Record vs common opponents.
RGGeemer
10/31/24 9:03am
If we win out, we are in. If ISU wins out, we are in with one loss to anyone.
SouthernCoug
10/31/24 8:47am
<< Deleted >>
RGGeemer
10/31/24 9:03am
Doesn't Colorado already have 2 losses?
NonmormonYfan89
10/31/24 9:13am
In-conference losses
Happy As Larry
10/31/24 9:35am
Not in conference
RGGeemer
10/31/24 10:03am
Well KSU winning in Ames is a pretty tall order
runningryan
10/31/24 9:56am
Not correct. Casey Lundquist did a podcast on this & I recapped it:
MaximusMeridius
10/31/24 9:58am
Link to the podcast where he talks about the B12 official interpretation?
RGGeemer
10/31/24 10:04am
Found it, giving it a listen.
RGGeemer
10/31/24 10:04am
Yep it was in the post I linked. Definitely worth a listen
MaximusMeridius
10/31/24 10:09am
He said 'Caveat, we have sent an email to confirm we are interpreting this
RGGeemer
10/31/24 10:12am
I've been checking the site daily to see if he's gotten an update 🙁
MaximusMeridius
10/31/24 10:14am
Later he also said 'This is what we are waiting for confirmation on, but this is
RGGeemer
10/31/24 10:15am
Yep. And his interpretation makes sense..I'd be highly surprised if he's wrong
MaximusMeridius
10/31/24 11:28am
Makes sense to me. But it is up to the official conference interpretation.
RGGeemer
10/31/24 11:36am
We SHOULD win out
runningryan
10/31/24 10:13am
This isn't right, there's really only 2 scenarios a 1 loss BYU doesn't get in
stansburycoug
10/31/24 10:39am
We can still get in if KSU beats ISU with 1 loss, that 1 loss can only be to ASU
BYUFootballisBack
10/31/24 10:53am
RE: Listened to Kurtz explain B12 championship & I think BYU has to win out
Bobmarleyjr
10/31/24 2:45pm
Report problem with this ad
Posting on CougarBoard
In order to post, you will need to either
sign up
or
log in
.
Report problem with this ad