It should have been holding.

Report problem with this ad

Oct 19, 2024
7:39:28pm

Cnation All-American

Report problem with this ad

Cnation

Bio page: Cnation
Joined: Sep 19, 2011
Last login: Oct 20, 2024
Total posts: 8,152 (2 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Does anybody else think that the Hinkley Ropati INT

COUGSFAN338

Oct 19, 4:57pm

Do the rules specify if it's accidental is ok?

Mississippi

Oct 19, 4:59pm

If they think it's incidental contact. But, it was defensive holding before that

LifeLongLakerFan

Oct 19, 5:01pm

It shouldn’t have been called at all. That was an ARod special. We were moving

Coug98

Oct 19, 5:00pm

Poorly designed play to middle of the field, even more poorly executed

Mitty

Oct 19, 5:04pm

I’m sure you had the same thought on the TD to LJ last week

Charles Darwin

Oct 19, 5:09pm

That was a better play design, less risky, and better executed

Mitty

Oct 19, 5:10pm

Less risky? He threw into triple coverage

SUAVO

Oct 19, 10:18pm

And then way underthrew it

icecougar

Oct 19, 11:39pm

Of course, way less risky to go to the sideline than to the middle.

Mitty

Oct 20, 12:54am

Not when the ball is thrown short. If you take risk out of a sideline throw it's

SUAVO

Oct 20, 1:23pm

That one should have been picked too

Coug98

Oct 19, 5:25pm

Many coaches like to put stuff on film just to make Ds prepare for it. ARod

NYC and Japan

Oct 19, 9:25pm

Lol. Just pretend that ARod trick plays never work

MaxxPower

Oct 19, 10:14pm

Not even sure it was incidental, no penalty but horrible throw.

TeeKaa

Oct 19, 5:00pm

The ball wasn’t even close to the receiver. The play was a bad play call. BYU

PhilPete

Oct 19, 5:00pm

It wasn’t close to the receiver because of the contact by the defender that

cougaman

Oct 19, 5:05pm

It’s useless- argued the same point last night but I’m not one of the smart

Bushmaster

Oct 19, 5:09pm

I didn’t say that. I don’t think the pass into essentially triple coverage on

cougaman

Oct 19, 5:19pm

I agree with you. Ropati didn’t realize with the speed of the game it

Bushmaster

Oct 19, 5:27pm

...and also throwing it into the wrong zip code

cajuncoug

Oct 19, 6:52pm

I could be wrong, but if you go back and watch the play, the ball didn’t even get to the tripped receiver if it went way

KYU

Oct 19, 7:37pm

The receiver fell down. It wasn’t a good throw, but the receiver would have been

cougaman

Oct 19, 7:41pm

So you didn’t think that the pass was underthrown And intercepted before it even got to the tripped receiver?

KYU

Oct 19, 8:18pm

What does that even mean? Let me make this simple.

cougaman

Oct 19, 9:05pm

It’s obviously not simple if we both obviously are struggling to comprehend what the other is thinking.

KYU

Oct 20, 1:21am

The ball was 50 feet in the air. The receiver would have adjusted and been close

cougaman

Oct 20, 7:25am

Thanks for sharing your perspective.

KYU

Oct 20, 8:13am

It should have been holding.

Cnation

Oct 19, 7:39pm

Ropati should’ve been called for a bad decision and even worse throw

Rhubarb

Oct 19, 5:02pm

I think you could have called holding before the ball was thrown but it was a

Charles Darwin

Oct 19, 5:08pm

Bad call. BYU just need to run the ball before getting cute. Bad execution.

Benfica1

Oct 19, 5:08pm

Contact occurred before ball was thrown. He grabbed Lassiter as he saw the play

RalphWiggam

Oct 19, 5:14pm

Your backup RB should never be throwing a pass, ever

RenoCoug

Oct 20, 12:27am

It was a terrible play call but there was a defensive hold. Long before the ball

RalphWiggam

Oct 19, 5:09pm

Last week when Kingston got lucky on the double pass, he said ...

calbearcoug

Oct 19, 7:12pm

I didn't like the play call

ElmerAlbert

Oct 19, 7:20pm

That INT was on ARod. Absolutely terrible play call.

WillsPitStop

Oct 19, 7:27pm

We have enough guys that can sling the ball.

DizzyDean

Oct 19, 7:35pm

It honestly looked like he was playing 500 and just lofted it up for anyone.

Blew

Oct 19, 7:38pm

No idea. They only showed it one time. No replay. Super annoying

Stucoug83

Oct 19, 8:23pm

Looked like a horrible horrible throw

BYU4eVeR

Oct 19, 11:21pm

On a non-QB pass play they are taught not to throw if covered

Bobmarleyjr

Oct 19, 11:34pm

Definitely not

palangi

Oct 20, 12:09am

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad