Answer me this: If their jobs are on the line, why would a coach not start who

Sep 9, 2024
1:19:08pm

rockhound All-American

really thinks is the best player? Why wouldn't he do that?

Are coaches wrong sometimes? Sure. Do 20 year old athletes screw up? Sure. But why do you think the coaches would make incorrect decisions on purpose?

Report problem with this ad

rockhound

Previous username: stanc
Bio page: rockhound
Joined: Jul 5, 2002
Last login: Sep 18, 2024
Total posts: 8,955 (5 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

One of the bizarre takes I see on here is that we should all just trust the

Czar-castic

Sep 9, 12:04pm

People said the same about Tuiaki.

BYUtka

Sep 9, 12:05pm

Well said - if it was neck and neck we should have seen a change

Swish

Sep 9, 12:07pm

Exactly, therefore, it wasn't neck and neck.

2FarGone

Sep 9, 12:14pm

If it were neck and neck, they each should have a chance to prove it in game

ochobeeguy

Sep 9, 12:29pm

apparently we are to believe that our coaches are dirty filthy liars and

Czar-castic

Sep 9, 12:36pm

You believe everything that coaches say?

Sea Chicken

Sep 9, 12:10pm

It wasn't neck and neck, but Hillstead wasn't as ready as hoped for so they needed to keep Bohanon as QB2

2FarGone

Sep 9, 12:14pm

One of the bizarre takes I see here is that the coaches don't care as much about winning as

Skeptical Optimist

Sep 9, 12:19pm

I don't think that is a take you see on here, I think you made it up

Czar-castic

Sep 9, 12:20pm

It is absolutely a take you see on here

2FarGone

Sep 9, 12:21pm

I mean, isn't that exactly what you are saying in this thread?

Skeptical Optimist

Sep 9, 1:09pm

link to anything I remotely said about them lying? That's beyond ridiculous

Czar-castic

Sep 9, 1:10pm

Maybe you can clarify what you meant when you said we shouldn't trust the coaches

Skeptical Optimist

Sep 9, 1:16pm

Maybe you could just read it again, no clarification needed, also you know very

Czar-castic

Sep 9, 1:22pm

Show one person that has said that.

ochobeeguy

Sep 9, 12:31pm

[crickets]

Czar-castic

Sep 9, 12:39pm

I don't think that the coaches are infallible at all.

Eddie

Sep 9, 12:24pm

then you effectively see them as infallible

Czar-castic

Sep 9, 12:34pm

So you think doctors and surgeons are infallible?

Eddie

Sep 9, 12:42pm

uhhhhh, what?? lol! I'd ask you to step me through that logic, but nah

Czar-castic

Sep 9, 12:44pm

You're attacking the wrong logic.

Eddie

Sep 9, 1:03pm

This such an ironic comment: don't trust the coaches, but trust that they said it was neck and neck

2FarGone

Sep 9, 12:25pm

allow me to help you. Open your imagination for a moment to a world where

Czar-castic

Sep 9, 12:37pm

They did not say it was a cin flip. They have been saying Retzlaff won the job.

fattycoug

Sep 9, 12:33pm

can you point to when they said this and at what point they were able to

Czar-castic

Sep 9, 12:38pm

Coordinators corner and kS show after the 1st game are 2 that come to mind

fattycoug

Sep 9, 2:29pm

The thing is, the coaches are the ones making the decisions. Whining about it

RGGeemer

Sep 9, 12:46pm

then why do you post here?

Czar-castic

Sep 9, 12:49pm

Maybe whining isn't the only way to post? 😉

Eddie

Sep 9, 1:11pm

To discuss BYU football with fellow BYU fans?

RGGeemer

Sep 9, 1:45pm

Interesting. I think that's what the rest of us are doing, too. Hope that help

Czar-castic

Sep 9, 1:50pm

Answer me this: If their jobs are on the line, why would a coach not start who

rockhound

Sep 9, 1:19pm

Where did I even remotely suggest they're making bad decisions on purpose?

Czar-castic

Sep 9, 1:24pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad