No im not.

Sign up, and you'll be able to vote in polls. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Sep 8, 2024
12:53:49pm

NanoFab Coug All-American

No im not.

Report problem with this ad

NanoFab Coug

Previous username: bdoggy
Bio page: NanoFab Coug
Joined: Apr 30, 2007
Last login: Sep 19, 2024
Total posts: 37,103 (6,137 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Retzlaff has a career 7:10 TD to turnover ratio. 7:15 if you include his fumbles that BYU recovered. 4:10, 4:14 vs FBS.

byuTX mutual friends

Sep 8, 8:46am

It’s not sustainable

Idacoug

Sep 8, 8:47am

Playing an FCS QB with a P4 schedule usually isn’t

byuTX

Sep 8, 8:48am

Do we have any non fcs qbs on the roster?

NYCougz

Sep 8, 8:50am

We have three that have had much more success than JR

byuTX

Sep 8, 8:51am

So they aren’t fcs qbs? Whew excellent. Once those guys come in, we

NYCougz

Sep 8, 8:56am

We have two that are at least G5 (an upgrade) and one that was P4 in the past (also likely an upgrade)

byuTX

Sep 8, 9:09am

Didn’t that p4 play for south Florida last year?

NYCougz

Sep 8, 9:14am

Because Retzlaff is objectively terrible

Sep 8, 9:18am

And the guy who threw as many ints as TDS last year at s Florida

NYCougz

Sep 8, 9:21am

That was south florida

Sep 8, 9:48am

People are using his success at Baylor.

NYCougz

Sep 8, 10:19am

That’s silly. We have all the proof we need that JR can’t do it now & 3 guys that have at least been competent. Bench JR

byuTX

Sep 8, 10:50am

Seriously?

NYCougz

Sep 8, 10:51am

How many games do you need? He’s 0 for 5 in showing he’s an FBS QB

byuTX

Sep 8, 10:54am

So we are using last years games

NYCougz

Sep 8, 10:56am

GB has shown in the past that he is capable. JR has never shown anything but terrible. 0 is less than 1. Hillstead 1>0

byuTX

Sep 8, 11:00am

Why didn’t he beat JR?

NYCougz

Sep 8, 11:04am

Not sure that matters as these coaches lack judgment. Do you agree JR was and is bad?

byuTX

Sep 8, 11:07am

Your judgement is better?

NYCougz

Sep 8, 11:11am

Mine, almost all fans and all neutral observers all have better judgment re Retzlaff. Do you think JR is bad?

byuTX

Sep 8, 11:17am

He stunk Saturday.

NYCougz

Sep 8, 11:19am

And all 4 last year. His numbers were slightly better vs SMU than last year. The time to move on was spring.

byuTX

Sep 8, 11:19am

Right but GB stunk last year

NYCougz

Sep 8, 11:21am

Not missing. We don’t know how he will do at BYU. Nor do we know how the other transfers or Lugo will do. All should

byuTX

Sep 8, 11:23am

We have different players as well.

NYCougz

Sep 8, 11:24am

Retzlaff is the one making it an obvious choice

byuTX

Sep 8, 11:58am

lol! Based on your analysis.

NYCougz

Sep 8, 12:34pm

I think you’ve sufficiently outed yourself as JRs family member…

Sep 8, 12:37pm

Well no offense but you use one game from this year

NYCougz

Sep 8, 12:47pm

No im not.

Sep 8, 12:53pm

Lots of QBs are getting benched. You should watch CFB. It’s fun and you see how functional teams and QB’s operate

byuTX

Sep 8, 12:47pm

Who?

NYCougz

Sep 8, 12:53pm

Where. Who got benched based on one horrible game?

NYCougz

Sep 8, 12:55pm

lol. One horrible game

byuTX

Sep 8, 12:56pm

This year - both had bad games last year.

NYCougz

Sep 8, 12:57pm

JR was the worst QB in 50+ years heading into the season (pass eff., min 100 passes). He’s so bad. SMU game “he stunk”

byuTX

Sep 8, 12:59pm

So using mostly last years stats in his first year as a starter

NYCougz

Sep 8, 1:03pm

You take it all into consideration. Hoping for something better trumps playing known bad. JR shouldn’t see a snap until

byuTX

Sep 8, 2:28pm

Lol… k dude. Like I said you will be benching quarterbacks every 14 days.

NYCougz

Sep 8, 3:06pm

Proof he could do it in the past >>>>>>>> proof JR can’t in the present, future

byuTX

Sep 8, 10:46am

But last year doesn’t matter?

NYCougz

Sep 8, 10:50am

It matters. Which is why we know Retzlaff can’t do it. You try GB this week. If he’s the ‘23 version go to Hillstead

byuTX

Sep 8, 10:55am

So how long does GB get before we move on?

NYCougz

Sep 8, 10:56am

Less than the 6 games JR has had

byuTX

Sep 8, 10:59am

We will be out of QBs soon with you at the

NYCougz

Sep 8, 11:13am

I’ve been busy in a different state and career. What’s the coaches’ excuse?

byuTX

Sep 8, 11:18am

You are not making much sense.

NYCougz

Sep 8, 11:27am

At least you acknowledge you shouldn’t

NYCougz

Sep 8, 11:28am

Something Sitake and I have in common

byuTX

Sep 8, 2:33pm

Ummm okay man … have a good one

NYCougz

Sep 8, 3:11pm

Oh it’s sustainable. Just sustainably losing.

macdizzle

Sep 8, 8:49am

The upshot is fumble recoveries are generally a 50/50 proposition

bythenumbers

Sep 8, 8:48am

Looking on the bright side is going to eventually cost Sitake his job if he can’t figure it out

byuTX

Sep 8, 8:52am

Seems like a reasonable take. If it doesn't happen cause he's just that much better than the others, then the spotlight

unctoothman

Sep 8, 8:55am

And that’s with an offense supposedly designed to limit turnovers.

CougGolf

Sep 8, 9:04am

There is a zero percent chance that Bohanon is worse than Retzlaff... There is no way...

Coug

Sep 8, 9:14am

And if he is worse there are 3 others that deserve a shot over a proven bad JR

byuTX

Sep 8, 10:50am

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad