You’re looking at this season. Some of us are looking at the next 4.

Nov 26, 2023
12:21:28pm

AltTabbins All-American

And frankly they don’t look good. No QB in a school historically known for being a QB factory, and some of the lowest recruiting ratings in the NCAA.

Report problem with this ad

AltTabbins

Previous username: Lloose
Bio page: AltTabbins
Joined: Sep 30, 2017
Last login: Oct 15, 2024
Total posts: 3,509 (7 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Are people really saying a guy who has seasons of 11-1, 10-3, 9-4 and 8-5

BlueWand

11/26/23 9:47am

I’m seeing a steady regression there, he has to be bowl eligible next year imo

1984coug

11/26/23 9:48am

These are just some of his best seasons, not necessarily in order

BlueWand

11/26/23 10:18am

A few bounces the other way and this team would be 3-9, maybe even 2-10.

El Presidente

11/26/23 9:52am

A win is still a win. Regardless of opponent or circumstances

BlueWand

11/26/23 10:20am

A few bounces the other way and we are 7-5 this year...

Cougzilla

11/26/23 10:22am

Or 2-10.

Forzaitalia

11/26/23 5:20pm

<< Deleted >>

zerigke

11/26/23 9:53am

He’s had two losing seasons with historically bad offenses. He’s had more

Beggar

11/26/23 9:53am

2/5 losing seasons since lavells first year are his…

1984coug

11/26/23 9:54am

I don't know why this is shocking to you. Much of Cougarboard was saying that

BeardedSpock

11/26/23 9:54am

BYU would get significant negative press and bad PR from the coaching community if they fired Kalani

JOPE

11/26/23 9:54am

I don’t think so after 8 years. It’s not like he only got 2 or 3 years. I doubt anything happens to him until his

coastcat

11/26/23 12:50pm

This is CB- the right answer is to always fire the coaches

Junior Deputy

11/26/23 9:55am

They would want to fire Andy Reid too. 3 straight games 0 points in 2nd half

Belboz

11/26/23 9:57am

You ignored 4-7. 11-1 has a covid asterisk. 8-5 w/3 NFL talents was underperform

Forzaitalia

11/26/23 9:58am

Lots of teams go 8-5 or worse with more NFL talent

JOPE

11/26/23 10:02am

When playing in a P5 league. Not vs. mighty ECU, Liberty.

Forzaitalia

11/26/23 11:31am

<< Deleted >>

BYUFan2010

11/26/23 3:38pm

He’s beat USC, Tennessee, Mich St, Baylor, ASU, Arizona, Boise St, etc.

BlueWand

11/26/23 10:17am

You do realize most of those teams were...not great. Or even very good.

krindorr

11/26/23 1:42pm

He should get credit for developing NFL talent; not counted against him.

BYUFan2010

11/26/23 5:02pm

I’m not on the fire Kalani train, but to say “a few bounces the other way….” Is not a good take. This team severely

cruiserhead

11/26/23 9:59am

Unequivocally yes

maxpowers

11/26/23 9:59am

4-7, 7-6, 7-6, and losing the ONLY difficult game the Covid year

Endocoug

11/26/23 10:04am

We demolished a ranked Boise team in Boise in 2020, 51-17.

Junior Deputy

11/26/23 10:11am

They dropped out of the rankings after that loss, and didn't finish ranked

BeardedSpock

11/26/23 10:23am

Still a good team- that was the year San Jose had an amazing team and beat

Junior Deputy

11/26/23 10:42am

Didn’t they inexplicably beat us in Provo the next year?!

Endocoug

11/27/23 5:38am

A few bounces the other way and we are 3-9. I don’t think BYU is in a position to fire KS this year. Losing season next

shimmy

11/26/23 10:06am

Agreed.

JOPE

11/26/23 10:17am

It just goes to show how some bounces and calls can derail a season

BlueWand

11/26/23 10:25am

I don't think they are saying he should be gone "because of one season that was not so great." It's because there are

No touching

11/26/23 10:07am

Yep This is not about 1 bad game or season. It is about a pattern of collapses

Forzaitalia

11/26/23 11:35am

Kalani doesn't have the mental horsepower to be even an avg HC. He's not

TeeKaa

11/26/23 10:41am

Except he has objectively performed as an average coach. I get the criticism,

Polecat

11/26/23 11:42am

Not an emotional/irrational lashing out. It's simply obvious Kalani doesn't

TeeKaa

11/26/23 2:45pm

The results are average, it doesn't matter what you say. Plus... I guarantee

Polecat

11/26/23 6:02pm

I didn’t mention Bronco. I’ll stick with the piss poor coaching of Kalani.

TeeKaa

11/26/23 7:03pm

You won't say it, but you know darn well you and most on this board

Polecat

11/26/23 7:33pm

I have no answer to your obsession with Bronco. I’m sticking with the present

TeeKaa

11/26/23 7:45pm

You’re looking at this season. Some of us are looking at the next 4.

AltTabbins

11/26/23 12:21pm

As long as Kalani gets a new offensive staff, and improves discipline, I'm on

CharlottesvilleCoug

11/26/23 12:45pm

Wasn’t there a losing season in there as well. Seems like you’re cherry picking

zerome4sooners

11/26/23 12:47pm

No way we are celebrating 9-4 and 8-5 seasons 💀💀💀

TheMediator

11/26/23 1:04pm

A few bad bounces and we could have been 2-10

Hill4Heisman

11/26/23 1:24pm

A few good bounces and we could have been 8-4. You can play “what if” all day.

andrewg3

11/26/23 2:59pm

I’m referring to Kansas, OU, and Ok St by the way

andrewg3

11/26/23 2:59pm

These were all games where we weren’t losing at halftime & started 2H with ball

andrewg3

11/26/23 3:00pm

The few bounces and calls our way is what got us 5 wins this year.

Turn and Cough

11/26/23 2:09pm

I actually believe Sitake is not the problem after convos I’ve had with staff

andrewg3

11/26/23 2:58pm

So what do you understand the problem(s) to be?

Zenoch

11/26/23 3:32pm

Talent. We don't have the dudes yet. But let's give the Big 12 a couple years.

andrewg3

11/27/23 1:57pm

PREACH!!!!!!

BYUFan2010

11/26/23 3:34pm

Not only that

electricutahn

11/26/23 3:51pm

No but the jury is out as to him being someone that is capable of getting BYU

Countcougula

11/26/23 5:45pm

Just let us get past the grieving stage. KS contract well orchestrated by agent

fan32

11/26/23 7:10pm

Take of the blue glasses.

dizthewiz

11/26/23 7:40pm

Stop. "A few bounces..." We got trucked/embarrassed in 4 of our 7 losses.

IronPotato

11/27/23 1:10pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad