How many times are U going to move the goal posts. There are 65 or so P5

Jan 25, 2022
12:22:56pm

Cougarbib All-American

schools. It is more likely than not that he stays at USC or picks a school not named BYU whether he thinks he can compete at BYU or not.

Report problem with this ad

Cougarbib

Bio page: Cougarbib
Joined: Jul 28, 2003
Last login: Sep 20, 2024
Total posts: 40,950 (111 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Idk, but it would seem to me if BYU is that interested in Dart and

FT487

1/25/22 12:02am

Na lol. You’re getting NFL talent at a premium position

BrutustheBrash

1/25/22 12:04am

I get that but kids don't want to sit much and wait these days

FT487

1/25/22 12:28am

Have you paid attention to injuries at the QB position?

Y05

1/25/22 3:46am

If he comes to BYU, he’ll have a real good shot at being QB1. Because he’s

russkiejedi

1/25/22 6:48am

I think there is confusion because you don’t think Dart is the best option

dixieutahbyuzag

1/25/22 1:04am

Without knowing that for certain, we have to at least

SinkingQuffa

1/25/22 2:10am

Neither did Wilson in 2019. Time will tell if Hall makes the off-season leap ZW

Cougarbib

1/25/22 9:58am

Zach Wilson demonstrated excellent vision & ball placement as a true Frosh.

SinkingQuffa

1/25/22 10:25am

Yes. ZW was inconsistent in 2019 right from the start. His off-season effort

Cougarbib

1/25/22 10:33am

It should be noted his shoulder rehab following his Frosh year

SinkingQuffa

1/25/22 10:42am

Hero ball, forced things, didn’t handle pressure well. He was always

Cougarbib

1/25/22 10:46am

It’s clear that Dart wants that and that Kalani is telling him it’s his to

The_Cuss

1/25/22 1:27am

If Dart comes to BYU, I think Conover is in the portal the next day

Borg

1/25/22 3:14am

I think he's too level-headed & sure of himself to do that on a whim.

SinkingQuffa

1/25/22 3:34am

I hope you're right!

Borg

1/25/22 7:47am

What whim are you talking about? Conover has had weeks to contemplate what he

GilbertAZCougar

1/25/22 7:49am

That, or he could be extra-motivated to own Spring camp a month from now.

SinkingQuffa

1/25/22 7:55am

Still wondering what whim you are talking about.

GilbertAZCougar

1/25/22 8:16am

The whim was supplied by Borg

SinkingQuffa

1/25/22 8:38am

Less whimsical if Conover waits until he sees if he can compete with Dart in

Cougarbib

1/25/22 10:02am

Yeah, if he left before knowing Dart was for sure coming —

SinkingQuffa

1/25/22 10:28am

That's my take. Dart isn't coming to sit.

FT487

1/25/22 11:51am

There is something to loyalty that would be lost if Dart came

Pretorian

1/25/22 4:22am

If I could take myself to believe #1, & could believe that #2

SinkingQuffa

1/25/22 4:31am

RE: There is something to loyalty that would be lost if Dart came

deliciousmocha

1/25/22 6:00am

^ This is the only way to accurately regard the QB situation. Like it or not, P5 ball means you treat things like a

unctoothman

1/25/22 6:19am

You’re probably right but it feels wrong… thus the battle in my head

Pretorian

1/25/22 7:39am

I kinda disagree with you. if you listen to Great QBs they all talk about how

Pretorian

1/25/22 7:35am

Completely different era. You’re also dealing with a different young man.

deliciousmocha

1/25/22 8:30am

Giff, Marc Wilson, McMahon, and maybe Young were all on the roster at the

Cougarbib

1/25/22 10:09am

^^ good point

Pretorian

1/25/22 10:59am

How many of them would have stayed in the current era?

FT487

1/25/22 11:35am

That is not the point being discussed. Someone was worried about the

Cougarbib

1/25/22 11:55am

But it is the point. Players can transfer much easier now. I doubt some of them

FT487

1/25/22 12:02pm

What does that have to do with their psyche when on the field?

Cougarbib

1/25/22 12:03pm

The real question is if they’d stay how many would turn out to be better players

Pretorian

1/25/22 11:59am

Who knows all speculation

FT487

1/25/22 12:03pm

Totally agree it’s a different era but that doesn’t change the psyche of players

Pretorian

1/25/22 10:58am

bringing a guy in (that's not even the same class as your starter) is not

fattycoug

1/25/22 10:42am

I highly doubt the other QBs in the room feel that way

Pretorian

1/25/22 11:01am

so, wheat's the strategy? Only get a QB every 4 years?

fattycoug

1/25/22 11:03am

I’d say go after a QB in recruiting each year so they can be developed just like

Pretorian

1/25/22 12:50pm

BYU fans aren’t used to P5 depth charts and it shows.

Corn

1/25/22 6:19am

Oh brother!

FT487

1/25/22 11:49am

Thumbs down for all but the last sentence

TEXAS

1/25/22 6:27am

When coaching is your occupation you try and make your team the best and when a

Baseball77

1/25/22 6:33am

Hall and Conover get it. They might transfer if they lose the competition, but i

russkiejedi

1/25/22 6:41am

I was noncommittal on the situation until rumblings started of a Lisfranc injury to Hall, that has me very concerned

byujag

1/25/22 7:09am

And that might be why but otherwise I can only come

FT487

1/25/22 11:28am

When you have any opportunity to get 5* QBs you do it

CougarCanuck76

1/25/22 7:14am

If he comes, he gets a shot. If he doesn't get the job, he will transfer again...see Tate Martell.

Tweege

1/25/22 7:23am

Why don’t you want BYU to get as many of the best players as they can get? That’s what makes no sense.

Turnpike Lane

1/25/22 7:49am

And where did I say that? All I said is I thought

FT487

1/25/22 11:43am

BYU supposedly had 3 starters in 2021. One supposed starter just entered

Cougarbib

1/25/22 12:00pm

True but I dont see Dart going to a situation to battle it out or waiting for

FT487

1/25/22 12:08pm

How many times are U going to move the goal posts. There are 65 or so P5

Cougarbib

1/25/22 12:22pm

Haha 3rd string?

COACHdrn

1/25/22 8:15am

Maybe it's a issue with Conover... But this has nothing to do with Hall.

ReggaeCoug

1/25/22 8:25am

Maybe maybe not I just find it weird. I think it's something else

FT487

1/25/22 11:47am

Maybe you didn't watch the 1992 football season

NYC and Japan

1/25/22 8:53am

If I am Dart....

Cougstreak

1/25/22 9:03am

Not if he thinks he is NFL material. He has 3 years eligibility left. He is not

Cougarbib

1/25/22 10:16am

1992 had 5 soph QBs. QB4 transferred after fall camp. QB 5 started Bowl game

Cougarbib

1/25/22 10:14am

This isn’t Kalani’s mindset. He wants that room

BYUAnime

1/25/22 9:08am

When's the last time we had a run-first QB finish a season. Let them compete

Malacis

1/25/22 9:09am

Why is this so hard for some of you? Good teams pursue talent at every position

Jimmerfan32

1/25/22 9:18am

If he comes he still has to learn the offense. He's coming from a pure Air Raid.

CaliWG

1/25/22 9:20am

Such a poor take. You go after a 5 star QB regardless of who is on your team.

ImDaBear

1/25/22 9:27am

You should always go for the best talent available

SeattleBYUfan

1/25/22 11:04am

Most of you don't read well. I never said it was a bad thing

FT487

1/25/22 11:46am

Some gave you $100 last year Now someone if offering another $100 Do you say no?

Posting on CougarBoard