With Taysom Hill. To me to be a top ten byu qb you need to have quarterbacked byu to special seasons, beat Utah, won big bowl game, passed for a ton of yards and have a great byu career and won a lot of games.
Sarkisian and domans best seasons were more successful and better teams than taysoms. And the reason is injury and coaching. Take away injuries and a senior year with new coordinators and Taysom has steve young’s byu career.
But yeah newsflash: injuries badly impacted taysoms byu career and legacy.
The early qbs also had the benefit of better offensive coaches/schemes.