The OP listed it if you had paid attention.

Report problem with this ad

Nov 17, 2019
10:38:50pm

ManicBlue All-American

Report problem with this ad

ManicBlue

Bio page: ManicBlue
Joined: Jan 10, 2005
Last login: Sep 20, 2024
Total posts: 51,256 (937 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

ZW has to be better. He's struggled this year.

SpiffCoug All-American

11/17/19 2:36pm

Doesn’t have to be.. just play Romney

cougfanz

11/17/19 2:38pm

Exactly the point. Smart fans see the stats & his game vs rivals is far better.

ToasterChive

11/17/19 2:52pm

I don't know why it's hard for people to say Romney has been every bit as

777

11/17/19 3:33pm

He also had tougher competition

BYUCougarsFan

11/17/19 2:42pm

Did you even look at the stats?

Klompus

11/17/19 2:48pm

No 😂

BYUCougarsFan

11/17/19 2:56pm

Oh haha. Ok we still friends.

Klompus

11/17/19 3:09pm

He’s played mostly good teams with athletes we don’t have.

bigbossbyu

11/17/19 2:44pm

And right after healing from shoulder surgery

2FarGone

11/17/19 2:45pm

Exactly. It’s tough to say if he’s ever really been “100%” this year.

bigbossbyu

11/17/19 2:46pm

If that’s the case, play the guys who are 100% and have played better

Dangerous

11/17/19 2:51pm

Critchlow it is. He's the only 100% healthy QB.

foofcoug

11/17/19 2:53pm

Critchlow outplayed Wilson Saturday by quite a bit. 197 vs 127 PER

Cougarbib

11/17/19 3:38pm

lol love it

bigbossbyu

11/17/19 3:40pm

The game vs BSU showed Romney should be playing, he has the poise of a winner.

ToasterChive

11/17/19 2:51pm

How'd he look against mighty Liberty?

foofcoug

11/17/19 2:53pm

Offense was fine. Defense sucked.

KL2BYU

11/17/19 2:54pm

Pretty good.

ToasterChive

11/17/19 2:54pm

Definitely not as "sharp" as he looked against BSU. Struggled at times vs inferior competition.

foofcoug

11/17/19 2:57pm

He was much better than Wilson was against ISU.

Dangerous

11/17/19 3:33pm

Looked really good I thought

bluelands

11/17/19 3:00pm

Great. Look at the numbers in the chart above. Those numbers

Cougarbib

11/17/19 3:51pm

Why are we all supposed to be invested in Zach developing as a player?

KL2BYU

11/17/19 2:54pm

I am not sure that is the case, and I am very high on Romney

2FarGone

11/17/19 3:01pm

Look at the numbers. Wilson compared to the averages of the other teams that pl

Cougarbib

11/17/19 3:58pm

Agreed. Unfortunately it feels like we are married to ZW no matter what because

byulover

11/17/19 3:26pm

This

Jacksonian76

11/17/19 4:07pm

RE: Agreed. Unfortunately it feels like we are married to ZW no matter what

Fakalata

11/18/19 1:00am

And we won with Zach!!!

Fakalata

11/17/19 8:27pm

A d we lost with Zach.

CarolinaCoug

11/20/19 2:37pm

Thanks for data. Small error on Toledo line. Also,

Cougarbib

11/17/19 2:58pm

Fixed the Idaho St.

SpiffCoug

11/17/19 2:59pm

I think it's hilarious people leave Hall out of these discussions.

shakarocks

11/17/19 3:05pm

Because his concussion history suggests he won’t play football again

claw

11/17/19 3:09pm

No it doesn't

shakarocks

11/17/19 3:15pm

Uh if it is the only 2 games you’ve ever started and you cannot finish either...

claw

11/17/19 3:24pm

Glad you're a concussion expert

shakarocks

11/17/19 3:42pm

I prefer Romney over Hall

2FarGone

11/17/19 3:09pm

I do not have a favorite but I could argue it either way.

shakarocks

11/17/19 3:54pm

If you can't see that this data adjusts for tougher teams, just ignore

Cougarbib

11/17/19 4:10pm

He's unfortunately very likely to get knocked out next time he plays.

ToasterChive

11/17/19 3:21pm

I don't leave Hall out. He has performed below Romney but close. Well above ZW.

Cougarbib

11/17/19 4:01pm

No they are not

Fakalata

11/17/19 8:30pm

Baylor has played incredibly well for being a walk-on who has seen limited reps.

rainorsnow

11/17/19 3:27pm

We did miss 2 FG's in the Toledo game too.

ManicBlue

11/17/19 3:28pm

Field goals were a strength early and have been a problem lately

Cougarbib

11/17/19 4:30pm

I guess you didn't get that it does affect the Pts Differential.

ManicBlue

11/17/19 5:34pm

PER does not care about points differential. The defense scored 7points

Cougarbib

11/17/19 6:41pm

The OP listed it if you had paid attention.

ManicBlue

11/17/19 10:38pm

Yes. It is listed. Has nothing to do with PER. Just additional info

Cougarbib

11/17/19 11:05pm

I know what both mean. I only responded to the one piece before you went crazy

ManicBlue

11/17/19 11:14pm

You mean the ridiculous "ponder that" post you made?

Cougarbib

11/17/19 11:20pm

Which post was that?

ManicBlue

11/17/19 11:25pm

Must have confused you with someone else worrying that

Cougarbib

11/17/19 11:36pm

I also wonder how much of that can be attributed to scheme.

wilsdad

11/17/19 4:14pm

His performance vs ISU should debunk all difficult opponent and scheme excuses

Cougarbib

11/17/19 4:21pm

Agreed.

wilsdad

11/17/19 4:24pm

😂😂😂 you really have an axe to grind

puntersarepeople

11/17/19 5:53pm

smh

ManicBlue

11/17/19 6:01pm

Whatever happens, one will start

CrimsonCardinal

11/17/19 4:58pm

If the process is fair, they may both stay and continue to compete.

Cougarbib

11/17/19 6:56pm

You have to remember he wasn’t fully healthy until the season started and then

puntersarepeople

11/17/19 6:34pm

He may not have been fully healthy then. He has been quoted last week

Cougarbib

11/17/19 6:58pm

Yep his arm might be back but he was rusty

puntersarepeople

11/17/19 9:01pm

He’s not our best QB.

UNHuskerCoug

11/17/19 7:15pm

Just quit throwing pick 6’s or almost pick 6’s.

Yohy

11/17/19 7:20pm

is points differential adjusted for defensive TDs?

bruincoug

11/17/19 8:46pm

Only change would be vs Idaho St.

SpiffCoug

11/17/19 9:02pm

For our points, yes. For avg points allowed, there likely would be others.

Cougarbib

11/17/19 11:09pm

Meh sophomore slump

BYU Grounds

11/17/19 10:08pm

RE: ZW has to be better. He's struggled this year.

Doogal McCougar

11/20/19 2:46pm

You sure up play ZW and downplay BR in your comments.

Cougarbib

11/21/19 12:55am

IMO Wilson hasn’t run the same offense. I’m

gwalker

11/20/19 3:07pm

See Idaho State Game. He was terrible. He probably

Cougarbib

11/21/19 12:58am

Zach still beat them quite easily

puntersarepeople

11/21/19 7:16am

If he is, I agree, but he looked the worst at the end. And, in

Cougarbib

11/21/19 8:23am

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad