Sign up, and CougarBoard will remember which categories you want to view. Sign up
Nov 21, 2024
1:38:45pm
BYUFootballisBack Intervention Needed
In the end, realignment is the true issue with this years CFP rankings. We had
10 years of the 4 team playoff. Many have talked about this all season long, but realignment massively changed the game.

Essentially every single year in that 10 years, a 2 loss team from the P5 was ranked top 12. The problem arises now because there are just so many more teams in each of the conferences that there are waaaay more 1 and 2 loss teams. This could obviously end up shaking itself out a bit in the next 2 weeks, but as of right now this is what each conference will potentially look like, too many teams, not enough spots

2-3 ACC - 11-1 SMU, 11-1 Miami, 10-2 Clemson (they have to beat South Carolina, I don't think they will, so likely 9-3 anyway)

2-4 Big 12 - 11-1 BYU, 10-2 Colorado, 10-2 Iowa State (could also be 10-2 BYU and add 10-2 ASU, could also have 9-3 KSU and 9-3 ISU if KSU wins that game)

4 BIG - 12-0 Oregon, 11-1 Ohio State, 11-1 Penn State, 11-1 Indiana (or 12-0 Indiana and 10-2 Ohio State)

5-6 SEC - 10-2 Texas, Bama, Ole Miss, Georgia, Tennessee, Texas AM (could also be 11-1 Texas and 9-3 Texas AM)

11-1 ND (or 12-0 Army and 10-2 ND)

11-1 Boise State

12-0 Army (leads to a 10-2 ND that would still feel like they deserved a spot)

That means we end up with 15-20 teams that all feel like they deserve a spot based on the historical rankings of all 2 loss or better Power 5 teams being ranked in the top 12
This message has been modified
Originally posted on Nov 21, 2024 at 1:38:45pm
Message modified by BYUFootballisBack on Nov 21, 2024 at 1:41:53pm
BYUFootballisBack
Previous username
oddsewer
Bio page
BYUFootballisBack
Joined
Apr 29, 2007
Last login
Nov 22, 2024
Total posts
16,348 (730 FO)