For College Basketball, the NCAA tournament selection committee are provided with "resume rankings" which are basically strength of record types of rank, but are also provided with "quality rankings" which don't factor in W/L record but simply look at things like efficiency and MOV types of numbers. Both are factored in to their decision making, but the resume ranks typically have a much stronger correlation to eventual seeding.

The CFB Playoff committee doesn't have any such compilation of rankings provided to them as far as I'm aware, but I decided to create my own composite of "resume ranks" and "quality ranks" along w/ an overall weighted average that gives added weight to the resume ranks as I feel like that is what constitutes the teams that would be most deserving of the playoff". Resume ranks included are Massey BCS, Wolfe, Billingsly, Colley, and ESPN SOR (basically the 4 rankings still left over from the BCS era but w/ SOR added in as well). Quality ranks included are Massey, Sagarin, SP+, FEI, and FPI as I feel like those are generally the more well known and/or highly regarded quality ranks out there.

RESUME:
1. Oregon
2. Ohio St
3. Indiana
4. Texas
5. Georgia
6. Penn St
7. Alabama
8. SMU
9. Notre Dame
10. Miami FL
11. BYU
12. Ole Miss
13. Boise St
14. Clemson
15. Tennessee
16. Texas A&M
17. Colorado
18. South Carolina
19. Iowa St
20. Arizona St
21. Kansas St
22. Tulane
23. Missouri
24. Pittsburgh
25. Army


QUALITY:
1. Texas
2. Ohio St
3. Alabama
4. Ole Miss
5. Oregon
6. Georgia
7. Penn St
8. Notre Dame
9. Tennessee
10. Indiana
11. Miami FL
12. South Carolina
13. Clemson
14. Texas A&M
15. SMU
16. LSU
17. Iowa St
18. Boise St
19. USC
20. Colorado
21. BYU
22. Iowa
23. Tulane
24. Kansas St
25. Louisville


OVERALL (weighted average of the 2):
1. Oregon
2. Ohio St
3. Texas
4. Georgia
5. Penn St
6. Indiana
7. Alabama
8. Notre Dame
9. Ole Miss
10. Miami FL
11. SMU
12. BYU
13. Tennessee
14. Clemson
15. South Carolina
16. Boise St
17. Texas A&M
18. Colorado
19. Iowa St
20. Kansas St
21. Arizona St
22. Tulane
23. LSU
24. Missouri
25. Louisville