Page 1 - CougarBoard

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

📌 Beehive Meals is now shipping across the West; Expanding our reach to more fans

Sponsor

4:58pm

📌 Get your 1984 BYU Football 40th Anniversary Magazine at Deseret.com/1984/

Sponsor

3:10pm

📌 CougarBoard has partnered with Parker Kingston to design these shirts commemorating his punt return TD (2 options)

@CougarBoard Verified ✔️

10:52am

I notice we don’t list a class for Boskovic. Probably still figuring it out.

LeGrandBleu

10:05pm

Refs need a training on what indisputable evidence means.

775coug

10:03pm

Shouldn’t there be a 15 yard penalty for the bench leaving the sideline before the end of the game?

touchdownbyu All-American

10:00pm

RE: Shouldn’t there be a 15 yard penalty for the bench leaving the

Stucoug83

10:01pm

Only during a play.

RGGeemer

10:02pm

Minny got off that humongous KAT deal and got a first out of it? Sheesh.

BGRTHNUMEGO

9:55pm

Really looking forward to Lowe’s breakdown on ESPN

BGRTHNUMEGO

10:01pm

100% know if byu was in Miami’s shoes, every single one of you would agree

Idacoug

9:55pm

And how about you? What if you BYU was in VT’s place?

Samsonite

9:56pm

I would be very frustrated but would also know the ball was never caught

Idacoug

9:58pm

Uh huh. So is your point that you believe there was indisputable evidence to

Samsonite

10:00pm

I saw the ball was never possessed by any team.

Idacoug

10:01pm

Please answer the question I asked.

Samsonite

10:02pm

I did.

Idacoug

10:02pm

So you saw indisputable evidence? Yes or no.

Samsonite

10:04pm

Yes. It wasn’t possessed. The ref saw the same thing and called it.

Idacoug

10:05pm

So you’ve changed your opinion. Interesting.

Samsonite

10:06pm

Go read the comments on the postgame r/CFB thread. Seems that everyone

allaboutthegainz

10:00pm

I would think we caught a lucky break as we didn’t have indisputable evidence

Warner

10:03pm

I think it probably wasn't a catch, but there wasn't a clear view of it IMO

Projectoor

10:05pm

Not me. I hate that they ignore the rules. I understand that if they keep doing

rha1211

10:07pm

Now that we are the Big12’s undefeated flagship program

YOHONOMOTO

9:52pm

RE: Now that we are the Big12’s undefeated flagship program

PortlandCoug

9:53pm

RE: Now that we are the Big12’s undefeated flagship program

valcorger

9:57pm

They need to just change the rule to when a play is reviewed the replay

ybecausethatswhy

9:49pm

I kind of agree with this on scoring plays. Not other plays

cougarfann888

9:50pm

Plus games would all be 30+ minutes longer

TADOW

9:53pm

That'd be a nice process for a game-ending play like this one.

DirtyWater

9:53pm

Refs should be allowed not to make a call on the field if they didn’t have a

allaboutthegainz

9:53pm

I think they have to make a call on the field, unless you want 10x as much

Samsonite

9:55pm

I would think there would not be many plays where the refs don’t have a good

allaboutthegainz

9:58pm

Understood. Refs still need to make a call in the field. Just dont make the

ybecausethatswhy

9:58pm

There would be a lot more replay and a lot worse officiating with that approach.

Samsonite

10:03pm

Disagree.

macdizzle

9:58pm

The rule is fine. No matter how you define it there will be fringe calls that

shoganai

10:02pm

It’s so nice to see UW lose. The Utes of the PNW.

YOHONOMOTO

9:47pm

Big boys of the PAC losing to Rutgers, the Vanderbilt of the B1G.

DirtyWater

9:52pm

The pac was weak

Ojiisan

9:53pm

I think the camera angle from the front showed the VT guy losing control of the

shoganai

9:47pm

If that angle was definitive, shouldn’t it have taken a lot less time to review?

allaboutthegainz

9:50pm

Probably. Once they showed it on ESPN I thought the debate was over, but I

shoganai

9:52pm

Sheesh. What a mess.

allaboutthegainz

9:54pm

Not at all. A thrilling game with an amazing photo finish that fans will be

shoganai

9:59pm

The first episode of The Penguin...

Adrielle Board Misanthrope

9:46pm

Shohei now .004 behind Arraez for the batting title and triple crown.

Methusaleh22

9:45pm

Who said it isn’t an epic year? Is epic limited to only the best of that year?

bluecougar1985

9:47pm

Here’s two off the top of my head

Warner

9:54pm

That first one was absolutely correct.

TCuz

10:07pm

they just hate the Dodgers

Count Cougar

9:47pm

First NL triple crown since 1931 if he can do it

crimedog

9:53pm

Does anybody know who the commentators are tomorrow so I can start complaining about them now and go to bed angry?

TADOW Truly Addicted User

9:45pm

Let’s hope BYU gets the Canes treatment tomorrow by the Big12 refs. Geez.

MHOP

9:45pm

Not likely. Baylor is the home team and the long established Big 12 team.

Hinta

9:45pm

Remember when the reigning PAC-12 champ lost to Rutgers in year 1?😂

Cougs4Lfe

9:43pm

ACC begs the replay rules to keep Miami unbeaten. Irrefutable… my pompi!

RealityCheck All-American

9:42pm

I think you could see the ball moving until Miami guy had it

YOHONOMOTO

9:45pm

He had it when he hit the ground. That is clearly what the official thought.

RealityCheck

9:46pm

Hope Washington is enjoying their new home. That’s a long flight after a loss

Ojiisan

9:41pm

They got what they wanted

El Careeb

9:42pm

Actually, they only got half of what they wanted for the first 5-7 years.

Sparkling Delirium

9:48pm

I agree with this.

westsidecoug

9:41pm

The problem is complete inconsistency. There needs to be a standard

cougarfann888

9:46pm

Nope. "The way you do anything is the way you do everything". Horrible take. The

rha1211

9:46pm

I had the same thoughts but different conclusion.

775coug

9:49pm

I agree. Good take.

rha1211

9:51pm

Would be cool for some one new to win the ACC. Go SMU!

BigHouse Coug

9:41pm

Washington joins the Big 10 and then loses to Rutgers Lol. What are we doing?

boorad

9:40pm

Jed Fisch’s schtick at AZ was he was loyal and would never leave. Doesn’t work

puntersarepeople

9:44pm

Their reward? A bus ride to Newark followed by a 6hr red-eye flight home

Tare

9:46pm

Never trust a kicker.

Spiff SequelTrilogyFan

9:40pm

Unless it’s Brandon Aubrey

WDaddy

9:40pm

I'd trust that SMU kicker

Jesse Pinkman

9:41pm

RE: Never trust a kicker.

PJMort

9:43pm

I trust BYU’s Will Ferron

DizzyDean

9:45pm

Likely enough evidence to rule that he did NOT

Endocoug

9:39pm

Your word likely is the problem. The standard is indisputable evidence

cougarfann888

9:42pm

What I mean is it was likely that the official

Endocoug

9:46pm

I dont think a player out of bounds touching the ball makes it dead. I thought

rha1211

9:49pm

Why the thumbs down. I'm I wrong? I edited my post to make it more clear.

rha1211

10:05pm

If Rutgers loses, we riot.

AZPTCOUG

9:39pm

Rutgers is 4-0

paulb

9:39pm

Zero chance this kid makes it. They should throw a Hail Mary.

allaboutthegainz

9:39pm

Not even close.

allaboutthegainz

9:40pm

Wasn't even close

HuskerFan2

9:40pm

Rutgers going to make him think about it.

paulb

9:38pm

The fact that everyone saw the angles in slomo and still can't agree what happened is exactly why the call should STAND.

byujacob INSUFFERABLE KNOW IT ALL

9:38pm

The ball was loose right as the players hit the ground

Endocoug

9:42pm

You don't know that. We all saw the same clips and it was impossible to tell that.

byujacob

9:44pm

I saw the ball loose right after the players hit the ground.

Endocoug

9:48pm

There was one angle that looked definitive to me, and the others supported it.

shoganai

9:48pm

What’s the rule on that? We know that wouldn’t be a catch in the nfl. The expert said once a body part touches

22jrob22

10:07pm

The Rutgers injury seems sus...

Cougs4Lfe

9:37pm

But it helps Washington, so it really isn't

paulb

9:38pm

Maybe he's trying to give the D time to catch their breath

Cougs4Lfe

9:39pm

ACC command center crew: “We can’t tell. How many losses does VT have? No TD.”

rivercitycoug

9:37pm

If I was vtech coach. First words at press conference are

cougarfann888

9:37pm

No indisputable evidence to overturn it.

Snipe

9:38pm

Time to hold Refs accountable... Need full explanation on these calls. Too much

Cougar TD

9:36pm

I still can't believe that. The initial call and review. No one had any idea

westsidecoug

9:36pm

really bad that a team can have 100 loses, and be 20+ games up on another team

Count Cougar

9:35pm

Miami proven a paper tiger

DJROSS Food Fanatic

9:35pm

No ref was even close to be able to call a td. Correct call.

Idacoug

9:35pm

Doesn't really matter if a ref was in position to call it or not. The call was

SUAVO

9:36pm

I’ve never seen that context make them take call on the field less seriously

Warner

9:36pm

Yeah, the 2 guys back there weren’t exactly hustling.

CougGolf

9:36pm

That’s not how it work. they made a call on the field and that should have stood

BamaCoug

9:36pm

Good on the ref to make the correct call regardless.

Idacoug

9:37pm

Not how it works.

mulletino

9:38pm

Tell that to the ref who just made the correct call.

Idacoug

9:39pm

Is he in the room with you right now?

Samsonite

9:40pm

Good mature comeback. Go listen to the prophets talk a year ago.

Idacoug

9:42pm

Is the prophet also in the room with you right now?

Samsonite

9:44pm

Dang. You need to get off this board and breathe.

Idacoug

9:45pm

That’s cool you think they made the right call. It’s just not how the rules work.

mulletino

9:40pm

Tell that to the ref that made the call then.

Idacoug

9:41pm

RE: Tell that to the ref that made the call then.

mulletino

9:42pm

RE: Tell that to the ref that made the call then.

Idacoug

9:43pm

You realize that’s a weird reply, right?

Samsonite

9:42pm

No. He made the right call.

Idacoug

9:43pm

Ends justify the means, if you know you’re right… that’s how it works right?

Samsonite

9:43pm

Ref was right. Sorry.

Idacoug

9:44pm

Do you always believe rules should be disregarded if you really believe you’re

Samsonite

9:45pm

I believe the right call was made in that specific situation.

Idacoug

9:48pm

RE: I believe the right call was made in that specific situation.

mulletino

9:56pm

You do realize it was impossible for the ref to be right. He had to break the

rha1211

9:56pm

Actually that’s what makes the ref a bad ref.

MHOP

9:40pm

But they were close enough to call it incomplete? I don’t get your logic

TADOW

9:36pm

Once a call is made you have to have clear and obvious evidence to overturn. It

Cougar TD

9:37pm

It was a mistake. They overturned their mistake. Correct call.

Idacoug

9:38pm

And broke the rules to do it.

DiamondMo

9:40pm

🤣

Idacoug

9:45pm

So you would disregard the rules if you were a ref, based on your feelings?

Samsonite

9:47pm

Based on logic and fact.

Idacoug

9:49pm

Since when does everyone have same perspective of logic and fact...

MHOP

9:51pm

Some people are just black/white thinkers.

Samsonite

9:52pm

terrible take. This is laterally a game governed by rules. Your premise is rules

rha1211

9:58pm

RE: 🤣

MHOP

9:49pm

Doesn't work that way. Opinions go out the window. Indisputable evidence is need

Cougar TD

9:40pm

I know it’s hard for some types to understand, but you can just make up rules

Samsonite

9:41pm

You're making the wrong argument

A_blue_car

9:42pm

They should have ruled it incomplete initially. Not enough to overturn

CougGolf

9:34pm

Not enough evidence to overturn

Snipe

9:36pm

But if they call incomplete they can’t review. Correct? The rule is bad.

DiamondMo

9:42pm

Didn't look like he ever had control, but I don't know that the evidence was enough to overturn.

Byron McNertney Solid 6 (8 if you're drunk)

9:34pm

Unless they had different views in the booth, not sure how they overturn

txblue

9:35pm

The view I see was no control in the air

I'mBatman

9:39pm

Game of the year. GO CANES

UTAHCANE

9:33pm

Barely beat a 2-2 team at home is the game of the year?

WJCougar

9:35pm

Every team will have close calls. Gotta pull it out when you play like poop

Sparkling Delirium

9:41pm

But that was not the game of the year

WJCougar

9:42pm

Get rid of instant replay. They don’t even follow their own rules governing it

zerome4sooners

9:33pm

Seriously... Terrible call

Cougar TD

9:34pm

yes please. Im sick of it.

rha1211

9:34pm

Slows down the game so much. Just not worth it

zerome4sooners

9:36pm

I agree. If they got it right I may say it's worth it. I think they are

rha1211

9:44pm

They always say they have different angles than we see. They probably spliced

Cougarite

9:36pm

I thought they had less than the people watching TV. Something about having to

rha1211

9:42pm

One thing for sure… Miami does not look like the #7 team

Peterbilt

9:33pm

Yes, overrated for sure.

VirginiaPeanut

9:34pm

Miami boosters to the replay booth

TADOW Truly Addicted User

9:33pm

With a side order of … it is miami after all

YoungstownCoug

9:43pm

And then when they end up losing a game or two in the next couple of weeks

Sparkling Delirium

9:43pm

I think I agree with the call but I don’t agree with the overturn

df101coug

9:33pm

ACC saw their only chance of 2 playoff births flash before their eyes and made a business decision

Perseguir Pine Rider

9:33pm

That one will be talked about all week.

byujacob INSUFFERABLE KNOW IT ALL

9:33pm

Maybe all season for the Canes

byujacob

9:34pm

If Miami keeps winning, all year. I wonder if the poll voters will react to the call

TADOW

9:35pm

I think that’s the right call. He never really had possession.

RalphWiggam

9:33pm

You literally cannot be sure of that. We all saw the same angles. No evidence he never had possession.

byujacob

9:33pm

BOOOOOOOO!

Dark Forest Green

9:33pm

That is obviously a coward call. Not enough cojones to say it stands

Zerigke Ally Zerigke

9:33pm

That’s a robbery. Straight up corrupt.

Six Foot Seven

9:33pm

FS1
BYU Radio

BYU Radio

Top 10 recent

EGOR INSANITY - one of the best things I’ve ever seen in BYU hoops

Boskovic is the real deal

Don’t hold your breath on AJ.

CougarBoard has partnered with Parker Kingston to design these shirts commemorating his punt return TD (2 options)

I'm not a fan of us flying this afternoon. I would have flown in early this AM

Another great thing about the basketball program is KY:

This is awesome!

Robbie McCombs BYU basketball preview is out. $10 which seems well worth it to support a legit insider into BYU bball.

Did Colorado’s social team cross a line here?

😉

Site Statistics

Today

Posts: 5,978
Threads: 806
Visitors: 5,105
Logins: 3,541

Yesterday

Posts: 6,130
Threads: 678
Visitors: 5,312
Logins: 3,580

Currently Online

Total: 653
Subscribers: 494
Non-subscribers: 98
Non-login: 61

More statistics

Report problem with this ad