Page 1 - CougarBoard

You don't have the ability to post right now...

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

📌 Beehive Meals is now shipping across the West; Expanding our reach to more fans

Sponsor

4:58pm

📌 Get your 1984 BYU Football 40th Anniversary Magazine at Deseret.com/1984/

Sponsor

3:10pm

📌 CougarBoard has partnered with Parker Kingston to design these shirts commemorating his punt return TD (2 options)

@CougarBoard Verified ✔️

10:52am

ACC command center crew: “We can’t tell. How many losses does VT have? No TD.”

rivercitycoug

9:37pm

If I was vtech coach. First words at press conference are

cougarfann888

9:37pm

Time to hold Refs accountable... Need full explanation on these calls. Too much

Cougar TD

9:36pm

I still can't believe that. The initial call and review. No one had any idea

westsidecoug

9:36pm

really bad that a team can have 100 loses, and be 20+ games up on another team

Count Cougar

9:35pm

Miami proven a paper tiger

DJROSS Food Fanatic

9:35pm

No ref was even close to be able to call a td. Correct call.

Idacoug

9:35pm

Doesn't really matter if a ref was in position to call it or not. The call was

SUAVO

9:36pm

I’ve never seen that context make them take call on the field less seriously

Warner

9:36pm

Yeah, the 2 guys back there weren’t exactly hustling.

CougGolf

9:36pm

That’s not how it work. they made a call on the field and that should have stood

BamaCoug

9:36pm

But they were close enough to call it incomplete? I don’t get your logic

TADOW

9:36pm

Once a call is made you have to have clear and obvious evidence to overturn. It

Cougar TD

9:37pm

They should have ruled it incomplete initially. Not enough to overturn

CougGolf

9:34pm

Not enough evidence to overturn

Snipe

9:36pm

Didn't look like he ever had control, but I don't know that the evidence was enough to overturn.

Byron McNertney Solid 6 (8 if you're drunk)

9:34pm

Unless they had different views in the booth, not sure how they overturn

txblue

9:35pm

Game of the year. GO CANES

UTAHCANE

9:33pm

Barely beat a 2-2 team at home is the game of the year?

WJCougar

9:35pm

Get rid of instant replay. They don’t even follow their own rules governing it

zerome4sooners

9:33pm

Seriously... Terrible call

Cougar TD

9:34pm

yes please. Im sick of it.

rha1211

9:34pm

Slows down the game so much. Just not worth it

zerome4sooners

9:36pm

They always say they have different angles than we see. They probably spliced

Cougarite

9:36pm

One thing for sure… Miami does not look like the #7 team

Peterbilt

9:33pm

Yes, overrated for sure.

VirginiaPeanut

9:34pm

Miami boosters to the replay booth

TADOW Truly Addicted User

9:33pm

I think I agree with the call but I don’t agree with the overturn

df101coug

9:33pm

ACC saw their only chance of 2 playoff births flash before their eyes and made a business decision

Perseguir Pine Rider

9:33pm

That one will be talked about all week.

byujacob INSUFFERABLE KNOW IT ALL

9:33pm

Maybe all season for the Canes

byujacob

9:34pm

If Miami keeps winning, all year. I wonder if the poll voters will react to the call

TADOW

9:35pm

I think that’s the right call. He never really had possession.

RalphWiggam

9:33pm

You literally cannot be sure of that. We all saw the same angles. No evidence he never had possession.

byujacob

9:33pm

BOOOOOOOO!

Dark Forest Green

9:33pm

That is obviously a coward call. Not enough cojones to say it stands

Zerigke Ally Zerigke

9:33pm

That’s a robbery. Straight up corrupt.

Six Foot Seven

9:33pm

Replay the game!

DieHarder

9:33pm

Hmmmm

UVCoug

9:33pm

ACC officials need to keep their playoff hopes alive

PING Man

9:32pm

A call like that needs a full explanation by the crew.

VirginiaPeanut

9:32pm

Surprised it got overturned, shouldn't have been called a TD on the field

BYUFootballisBack

9:32pm

I feel the same way.

allaboutthegainz

9:33pm

Corrupt... Terrible call

Cougar TD

9:32pm

Never should have been ruled a TD they got it right

Big12Yfan

9:32pm

Doesn't matter... They called it a TD. Should have stayed a TD

Cougar TD

9:33pm

Ball moved when he hit the ground...that was a TD

Don_Juan_El_Guapo

9:33pm

Then you misunderstand the rule.

benny1982

9:37pm

I didn’t see clear video of the ball moving around until he was sitting on the ground. There was some blurry or

cheezedawg

9:34pm

Like you could even know that or see that in the review

HRCougar

9:34pm

Miami was tremendously lucky to win this game.

BluesBrother

9:32pm

So much for the ruling in the field;)

CougGolf

9:32pm

I reaffirm my position smr…

BamaCoug

9:32pm

ACC has to protect its highest ranked team

LaVellIfIKnow

9:32pm

Looked like the ball might've been moving as the WR went to the ground. But might isn't enough to change a called TD.

unctoothman To extract or not to extract..

9:32pm

You could see the ball moving the entire time.

RdF3

9:32pm

You must have a better TV than me

gww687

9:34pm

There's a difference between moving and firm control, though. The ball can move and you still have control, esp in a

unctoothman

9:35pm

Tech just got ripped off!

BYU I Bleed Blue

9:32pm

ACC gonna get sued again

Samsonite

9:32pm

That was the ACC making a business decision to protect a bigger brand.

Pierre Delecto

9:32pm

Refs making a physical safety decision.

DiamondMo

9:32pm

ACC protecting their top ranked team. Nothing there to be able to reverse.

squints

9:32pm

Anybody who thinks that was a VT touchdown is either blind or doesn’t understand football rules.

RdF3 Inactive user

9:32pm

And yet…it took the refs 5 minutes to review

UVCoug

9:36pm

I agree with that. He didn’t have clear control throughout

DavisCoCoug

9:32pm

Yeah I can’t believe they even called it a TD on the field

YOHONOMOTO

9:32pm

I agree. So maybe two wrongs - call on the field and the decision to overturn it - made a right?

unctoothman

9:33pm

I don’t think that was clear in the video at all- enough to overturn

cheezedawg

9:32pm

You can’t tell that from the review

HRCougar

9:34pm

Right call. Sorry Hokies

Flippy

9:32pm

ACC ref cheaters

RGGeemer

9:32pm

PAC refs moved to the ACC

valcorger

9:32pm

Wow they reversed it. Didnt think there was enough evidence.

dallasbyu

9:32pm

I think that's the right call

libertycoug

9:32pm

BOOOOOO. HOKIE HOKIE HOKIE HI RAE RI OLD VPI

kccougar VABL

9:32pm

What ever happened to indisputable evidence?

allaboutthegainz

9:32pm

Refs were scared about getting home

paulb

9:32pm

Booooo

Cougs4Lfe

9:31pm

👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎

valcorger All-American

9:31pm

Refs will live

kansascougar

9:31pm

Corrupt review officials

LaVellIfIKnow

9:31pm

Chickens

Tygger

9:31pm

Horrible call... Can't overturn that

Cougar TD

9:31pm

POLL: Well

Methusaleh22

9:31pm

The fact there's this much debate over it says the call should have stood.

jreid191

9:33pm

No way

txblue

9:31pm

Dang

cheezedawg Properly rated

9:31pm

Garbage

TADOW Truly Addicted User

9:31pm

Cowards

Jericho

9:31pm

Boooooooooo….cheaters

idcougarfan

9:31pm

Right call

volleyjiver

9:31pm

WOW. Reversed.

byujacob INSUFFERABLE KNOW IT ALL

9:31pm

Acc protecting their top dogs. Terrible call

cougarfann888

9:31pm

I don't think this is getting over turned

Coug Texan

9:31pm

It wrongly was

paulb

9:31pm

RE: I don't think this is getting over turned

Mister P

9:31pm

Bull

Samsonite

9:31pm

Malarky

paulb

9:31pm

Live footage of the replay command center:

VirginiaPeanut

9:31pm

Poor Miami.

byujacob INSUFFERABLE KNOW IT ALL

9:31pm

RE: Poor Miami.

benny1982

9:31pm

.imaiM rooP

byujacob

9:36pm

I think it’s a touchdown but there is no way you can prove it either way. Ruling on the field stands.

cheezedawg Properly rated

9:31pm

“I don’t think you can overturn the call on the field” - me during like 99%

DieHarder

9:30pm

I don’t think he caught it but I don’t think they can overturn it

DanSmith

9:30pm

Well I know nothing

DanSmith

9:31pm

It's awesome being able to see what the booth is looking at

cougarfann888

9:30pm

Gotta go with call of field

Tygger

9:30pm

Nothing there to overturn call on the field

Tare

9:30pm

Going to be tough to overturn that

kirkko

9:30pm

He had control..landed and then ball comes out

Don_Juan_El_Guapo

9:30pm

lol where in the world is control established?

YOHONOMOTO

9:30pm

Andre has it right. Call was TD. Call stands.

paulb

9:30pm

Nobody is going to like the outcome of this.

BigHouse Coug

9:30pm

Pretty sure one team/fanbase will…

BamaCoug

9:30pm

Just saying there is no clear, obvious decision.

BigHouse Coug

9:31pm

Does the ground cause the “bobble?” I think it’ll be call stands

Viva Campeche

9:29pm

lol I have no idea how they should call this lol

macdizzle

9:29pm

Looks like the ball is moving around

Big12Yfan

9:29pm

I would hate to be that ref

Samsonite

9:29pm

How brave are these officials?

Pablo Bot

9:29pm

I fear for the refs safety if they uphold this

DavisCoCoug

9:29pm

They should announce it from the locker room.

TLCougar

9:30pm

TOUCHDOWN!!!

Dark Forest Green

9:29pm

Throw back to that Seattle-Packers game years ago. Refs have no idea

arcawley

9:29pm

This is almost impossible to tell….poor refs

kansascougar

9:29pm

It's too hard to tell. Ball is definitely bobbling.

westsidecoug

9:28pm

I love college football

Mathew

9:28pm

Ball is bouncing all over. No catch.

Hyrum in Houston

9:28pm

It's not bouncing around until his butt hit the turf.

byujacob

9:29pm

And after a defender yanked at it after they were on the ground imo.

bluecougar1985

9:33pm

How are people disputing this? Ball constantly bounces around, never hits the ground, and Miami catches it. He was out

RdF3 Inactive user

9:28pm

Are you a Miami fan?

Jwine21

9:28pm

I hate Miami. This is easy though.

RdF3

9:29pm

That’s what I’m seeing too. I don’t see where 9 ever has control.

YOHONOMOTO

9:31pm

He had both hands on the ball when he came down

carlstud

9:28pm

Touchdown

idcougarfan

9:28pm

For those who bought tomorrow’s ticket through BYU, what section are you in?

GoodGuyGary1

9:28pm

Controlled to ground. Loose after he is down.

Tygger

9:28pm

TD for sure. Nice Va Tech

chismoso

9:28pm

Will Miami get fined for fans rushing the field with a loss?

dallasbyu

9:28pm

He looks down with the ball before it’s moving around.

rivercitycoug

9:28pm

Unclear. Replay the down!

DieHarder

9:28pm

Wow, what a stressful call for these refs haha. Hated either way here.

VirginiaPeanut

9:28pm

The longe this is reviewed, the more likely VT gets screwed

TADOW Truly Addicted User

9:28pm

I don't think he has control ... no td

Avery

9:28pm

Play should stand... TD

Cougar TD

9:28pm

It looks incomplete. Never really had it imo.

PJMort

9:28pm

Hope I’m wrong

PJMort

9:29pm

Seems pretty clear he had it. TD VT.

LaVellIfIKnow

9:27pm

Where are you seeing number 9 with control?

YOHONOMOTO

9:29pm

Have to go with the play as stands IMO n

BamaCoug

9:27pm

Looks like the defender popped it out after he hit the ground. TD?

byujacob INSUFFERABLE KNOW IT ALL

9:27pm

That’s what I see

TADOW

9:30pm

I think it’s a TD. He has it

macdizzle

9:27pm

Bonkers

Methusaleh22

9:27pm

I wanted VT but how in the world would that be a TD?

YOHONOMOTO

9:27pm

Butt was down with control

paulb

9:27pm

idk if you can overturn it

FieroCoug All-American

9:27pm

Hope VT doesn’t get screwed

Peterbilt

9:27pm

25 committed massive PI

cougarfann888

9:27pm

You can German suplex a guy on a hail Mary and they will never call it

darkcoug

9:28pm

Wow

Conan Best Poster on CB -JD Power

9:27pm

It’s a clear TD

Disco Lemonade

9:27pm

I disagree. He never has clear possession

DanSmith

9:27pm

He does. You can see the white Miami glove pull his hand loose after down by contact.

fldnstrm

9:28pm

No way and I hate Miami. He never had it.

Cnation

9:28pm

No possession

arcawley

9:28pm

It's not clear at all

volleyjiver

9:31pm

I don’t know how you overturn the call on the field there.

allaboutthegainz

9:27pm

What is happening? This is crazy

Coug Texan

9:27pm

Didn't think that was controlled by VT, but they can't possibly overturn it

volleyjiver

9:27pm

I think it's a td. What a game

Jwine21

9:27pm

Hopefully TD so we get some awesome dejected fan shots.

byubyu

9:27pm

It’s a clear INT. The VT receiver never had control.

RdF3 Inactive user

9:27pm

I don't see anyone in control of that ball.

HuskerFan2

9:27pm

No way they could’ve ruled that a TD from their view. Crazy

arcawley

9:27pm

😳😳😳😳

kansascougar

9:27pm

Dang. Not a TD

darkcoug Underperforming

9:26pm

Oh man I dunno

DavisCoCoug

9:26pm

I think that’s a TD

Viva Campeche

9:26pm

I don't think it is, but not sure they overturn it.

Corn Pop

9:28pm

FS1
BYU Radio

BYU Radio

Top 10 recent

Boskovic is the real deal

EGOR INSANITY - one of the best things I’ve ever seen in BYU hoops

Don’t hold your breath on AJ.

CougarBoard has partnered with Parker Kingston to design these shirts commemorating his punt return TD (2 options)

I'm not a fan of us flying this afternoon. I would have flown in early this AM

Another great thing about the basketball program is KY:

Robbie McCombs BYU basketball preview is out. $10 which seems well worth it to support a legit insider into BYU bball.

This is awesome!

Did Colorado’s social team cross a line here?

😉

Site Statistics

Today

Posts: 5,764
Threads: 767
Visitors: 5,066
Logins: 3,526

Yesterday

Posts: 6,130
Threads: 678
Visitors: 5,312
Logins: 3,580

Currently Online

Total: 768
Subscribers: 567
Non-subscribers: 121
Non-login: 80

More statistics

Report problem with this ad