My Account
Sign up, and you can make all message times appear in your timezone.
Sign up
Report problem with this ad
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Dec 9, 2024
7:03
:15
pm
mjmill
All-American
Isaac Wilson has been downgraded
He was a 91 composite 4-star coming out of high school. 247 has assigned him an 86 grade 3-star transfer rating.
Serious question: who’s a better QB prospect right now: McCae Hillstead or Isaac Wilson? I’m torn.
This message has been modified
Originally posted on Dec 9, 2024 at 7:03:15pm
Message modified by mjmill on Dec 9, 2024 at 7:34:34pm
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Report problem with this ad
mjmill
Bio page
mjmill
Joined
May 6, 2011
Last login
Dec 25, 2024
Total posts
3,153 (81 FO)
Report problem with this ad
Messages
Author
Time
Isaac Wilson has been downgraded
mjmill
All-American
Dec 9, 7:03pm
That should have happened the day he signed to play QB at Utah
CougarCanuck76
Dec 9, 7:04pm
Hillstead has proven more at the FBS level, TBD who will end up being better.
Junior Deputy
Dec 9, 7:04pm
From what I’ve seen of Hillstead during fall camp, I truly believe he could
Das_Countach
Dec 9, 7:31pm
At 5'10", I hope he's not a side-arm.
Plantagenet
Dec 9, 8:25pm
Uhhh no, he’s never played the same level of competition
ChinaFan
Dec 9, 9:56pm
He’s never had near the surrounding cast or coaching either. Goes both ways
palangi
Dec 9, 10:24pm
That is what he should have been rated out of HS
Jericho
Dec 9, 7:05pm
No way to determine that
Cougrrrs Roll
Dec 9, 7:10pm
You can absolutely have too many QBs, especially with rosters getting smaller
tacallaway
Dec 9, 7:11pm
I'm repeating what I've heard from coaches
Cougrrrs Roll
Dec 9, 7:41pm
How is Hillstead still a RS Fresman going forward?
Charles Darwin
Dec 9, 7:12pm
My error: he’ll be a redshirt sophomore. Corrected
mjmill
Dec 9, 7:34pm
A lot of success is circumstantial.
whoneedscorners?
Dec 9, 7:16pm
#NYJets
thegoodmeister
Dec 9, 8:12pm
Yup
jaba166
Dec 10, 3:42am
His ranking was that high because of the Covid season his brother had
KYU
Dec 9, 7:18pm
His high school career was excellent.
PJMort
Dec 9, 7:42pm
Isn’t Hillstead smaller than a short Isaac Wilson
BYU'01
Dec 9, 7:44pm
<< Deleted >>
runnincoug
Dec 9, 7:48pm
Hillstead listed at 5'10"
Cougrrrs Roll
Dec 9, 7:50pm
so they’re probably the same
palangi
Dec 9, 7:53pm
You think Hillstead is the first player to list his legit height (w/o cleats)?
BYU'01
Dec 9, 8:10pm
Yep very first
palangi
Dec 9, 10:25pm
Wilson is listed at 6'0"
ManicBlue
Dec 9, 11:12pm
I’m not a fan of QBs shorter than 6 feet
texaskevin
Dec 9, 8:11pm
I’d care more about the results
palangi
Dec 9, 8:19pm
Go with the player that’s faster and more athletic
I'mBatman
Dec 9, 7:49pm
McCae
kahuna
Dec 9, 8:22pm
Hillstead was undeniably better against lesser competition as a true freshman
NYC and Japan
Dec 9, 8:34pm
I don’t get this. Hillstead led USU in passing in 3 games: all G5 & all losses
BYU'01
Dec 9, 8:49pm
It’s simple
I'mBatman
Dec 9, 8:52pm
Wilson completed more passes, for more yards, against better teams & won games
BYU'01
Dec 9, 9:37pm
Hillstead’s running ability is next level
deliciousmocha
Dec 10, 12:45am
RE: I don’t get this. Hillstead led USU in passing in 3 games: all G5
NYC and Japan
Dec 9, 9:24pm
They did not “have the same number of passing yards”
BYU'01
Dec 9, 9:36pm
Hillstead had higher completion percentage and QB rating.
cwilke1
Dec 9, 11:34pm
We should have them play one on one to find out
MaxxPower
Dec 9, 8:56pm
I think given the right situation Isaac could be a dang good college QB. Kid is
Riseandshoutboys
Dec 9, 9:23pm
Are you all out of faith, is this how you feel?
TunaNoCrust
Dec 9, 9:41pm
Illusion never changed into something real
shaggy
Dec 9, 10:52pm
Come on you skipped the best line 😭
Polecat
Dec 9, 11:19pm
I’m going for the base skill and the one that has a chip on his shoulder to be a top tier QB. That is Wilson is my bet.
Rhino84
Dec 10, 12:19am
I think that's hillstead who is buried on the depth chart itching for his chance
runnincoug
Dec 10, 5:56am
He’s not buried. He’s 3rd string rn— Bohanon leaves and I’m pretty confident hes
Das_Countach
Dec 10, 7:15am
Sounds like Hillstead will be motivated to start if given the chance. Nice chip
runnincoug
Dec 10, 9:10am
Report problem with this ad
Posting on CougarBoard
In order to post, you will need to either
sign up
or
log in
.
Report problem with this ad