Completely agree, though Madsen showing as 29th in QBR. But much better than 62

Nov 29, 2024
12:20:37pm

legiaourbana 3rd String

I like Jake, but 62nd in QBR, which adjusts for strength of Defense faced, has him almost exactly in the middle of 129 ranked QBs.

Report problem with this ad

legiaourbana

Bio page: legiaourbana
Joined: Nov 18, 2004
Last login: Nov 29, 2024
Total posts: 330 (1 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Hate to say it but BSU Madsen > Retzlaff

Das_Countach

11:59am

I bet Retzlaff would love to play against stacked boxes and bad competition

kimdaddy35

12:00pm

And a complimentary running game like Madsen gets

2FarGone

12:02pm

Madsen - 21 TDs vs 3 int’s, Retz 20:10… if BYU has Madsen, they’re 11-0 rn- Retz

Das_Countach

12:06pm

Again, the life of a QB becomes much easier with an other worldly running game

kimdaddy35

12:08pm

Not true

thewaterboy

12:11pm

I was a star in elementary football recess, sounds like I should tryout

puntersarepeople

12:14pm

RE: I was a star in elementary football recess, sounds like I should tryout

thewaterboy

12:15pm

Sark made a huge jump his Sr. year in 1996 thanks to McKenzie

gopman

12:19pm

I dont know why its so hard for many to accept Retz is just average- every stat

Das_Countach

12:14pm

The point is Madsen is average at best

puntersarepeople

12:15pm

No, Madsen QBR is top 25, Retz is 62nd, literally average

Das_Countach

12:17pm

Retzlaff dominated Wyoming. Madsen plays a team that bad more often than not

puntersarepeople

12:19pm

Completely agree, though Madsen showing as 29th in QBR. But much better than 62

legiaourbana

12:20pm

If you truly believe MWC defenses are on par with the Big 12 I have a

gopman

12:33pm

Other than Jeanty, Madsen would have better offensive weapons, a better line at

Das_Countach

12:42pm

QB still has to make his reads & throw the ball. And there's still the

gopman

12:53pm

Yet in the one game Madsen played against a good team (Oregon), his QBR was 60.4

Junior Deputy

12:34pm

Retzlaff has faced far superior defenses compared to what Madsen has

gopman

12:22pm

Helps to have the best RB since Barry Sanders 😂

arcawley

12:00pm

It also helps to not throw the ball into the defensive linemen 5 times a game.

byubyu

12:04pm

Without Jeanty, Boise is mid at best, including Madsen

letthewookieewin

12:00pm

Koetter >>>>>>>> Arod

Chester Copperpot

12:02pm

Naw.

The Pope

12:16pm

Haven’t seen BSU run a jet sweep today. Koetter has coached in the NFL.

Chester Copperpot

12:18pm

And was fired. He was also a tool bag at ASU. I repeat, naw on DK

The Pope

12:39pm

Jake is an average QB. Half the time your happy and the other half not so much.

maYbe

12:04pm

Retz is good when it doesn’t matter, between the 20s, when there’s no pressure

Das_Countach

12:09pm

And Madsen hands it off when the game is on the line. Great comparison

puntersarepeople

12:10pm

Yes when the game was on the line vs Oklahoma St and Utah he sure let the pressure get to him.

kimdaddy35

12:18pm

Always anomalies. Vs Utah, he was bailed out, but how about OU last year,

Das_Countach

12:20pm

He was bailed out against Utah? You aren't very intelligent

kimdaddy35

12:22pm

lol, now I know you lost the debate w/ your weak personal attacks 😂🤡

Das_Countach

12:24pm

You thought we were debating? That is pretty funny.

kimdaddy35

12:25pm

You lost bro, 😂 you always revert to personal attacks when you lose

Das_Countach

12:26pm

RE: You lost bro, 😂 you always revert to personal attacks when you lose

kimdaddy35

12:29pm

lol, the irony coming from the oft mocked Kimdaddy 😂😂

Das_Countach

12:30pm

Bailed out? You sound like a Ute

arcawley

12:25pm

Bailed out meaning he played like trash- 0 tds, 45 QBR, 45 completion %, 3 sacks

Das_Countach

12:29pm

Funny you try to back track as we were talking about late game situations, not the entire game.

kimdaddy35

12:32pm

I’ve backtracked on nothing…

Das_Countach

12:33pm

Then late game how was Retzlaff bailed out against Utah. Explain yourself.

kimdaddy35

12:34pm

…I did already— do you even read anything?

Das_Countach

12:38pm

That is what I thought. Either you aren't bright enough to realize quoting game stats

kimdaddy35

12:51pm

lol, personal attacks again I see because you have no argument 😂 try again bud!

Das_Countach

12:53pm

Hate to say it? Then don't.

Benfica1

12:21pm

I hate to say it, but its true… hes hit his ceiling and making crucial mistakes

Das_Countach

12:32pm

He’s playing through injury right now and isn’t fully himself most recently

puntersarepeople

12:39pm

RE: He was bailed out against Utah? You aren't very intelligent

kimdaddy35

12:27pm

Sounds like you don’t really hate to say it, which is a shame cuz it’s a 🤡 take

Junior Deputy

12:31pm

How is calling a 62nd rated QB avg, which by definition is avg… would love to

Posting on CougarBoard