Sign up, and you'll be able to vote in polls. Sign up
Jan 2, 2011
4:02:01pm
Repost with more detail: Conan's College Football
Playoff proposal.

This proposal is designed to have a playoff and keep the bowls intact. Basically, there is a 16 team playoff with each of the 11 conference champions plus five at-large teams being seeded. Using a BCS type formula, the teams are ranked 1-16 and seeded just like the NCAA basketball tournament.
Some of you are incensed that FIU and Northern Illinois would be in the playoffs because there is not way in heck they are one of the best 16 teams in the country. Think of it this way though, they would be playing Auburn and Oregon, thus giving those teams a reward for having a perfect regular season. Plus, every D-1 team is eligible for a national championship, not matter what conference they're from.
The higher seed plays at home. It's too hard for fans to travel around the country week after week if their team wins. Home games would sell out and generate a lot of money for both teams. The first round would start on the first Saturday of December. The real, final, championship game would be held at a neutral location in large NFL-sized stadium (Miami, New Orleans, Dallas, Phoenix, LA) two weeks after the semi-finals.
Another caveat. Only two teams per conference are allowed in the tournament. This is to make sure it doesn't turn into an SEC or Big 10 post season tourney. Also, it limits the possibility of rematches between conference members.
Here's what the bracket would look like if it were held this season:

1. Auburn
16. FIU

8. Arkansas
9. Boise State

5. Wisconsin
12. Nevada

4. Stanford
13. UCF

6. Ohio State
11. Virginia Tech

3. TCU
14. UConn

7. Oklahoma (Would have to make an minor adjustment to the seeding to avoid this conference re-match)
10. Missouri

2. Oregon
15. Northern Illinois



What about the bowls? Under the Conan plan, the bowls would be ranked based on payout amounts. They would then be allowed to choose from the remaining teams not included in the tournament. The Rose bowl would be the first to choose, the New Orleans Bowl would be the last. The Rose Bowl, for example, could choose to keep the PAC 10/Big 10 tie-in or choose a different team from another conference if the PAC 10 has another bad year and/or sanctions. In my example below, the BCS bowls choose teams based on their conference affiliation and highest ranked available opponent (that's how utah gets an Orange Bowl invite).
Below the bowls are ranked based on payout and teams are assigned to them based on conference tie-in. Again, in under the Conan plan bowls can invite any available team once the bowls above them have invited their teams. There are no conference tie-ins
Some bowls need to die or be allowed to take 5 win teams. I prefer they die, but if they are allowed to take 5-win teams, the bowl teams may look something like this:

2010 Bowls and Payouts (in millions) (* = 5-win team)
1. Rose 17.0 USC vs. Michigan State (Keeping with the Big 10 vs. Pac 10 tradition)
2. Sugar 17.0 LSU vs. Texas A&M (SEC tie-in)
3. Fiesta 17.0 Oklahoma State vs. Alabama (Big 12 Tie-in)
4. Orange 17.0 Florida State vs. Utah (ACC Tie-in)
5. Chick-fil-A 5.65 South Carolina vs. Maryland
6. Capitol One 4.25 Penn State vs. Florida
7. Cotton 3.575 Nebraska vs. Mississippi State
8. Insight 3.325 Baylor vs. Iowa
9. Outback 3.10 Illinois vs. Georgia
10. Gator 2.75 Tennessee vs. Michigan
11. Alamo 2.25 Northwestern vs. Washington
12. Holiday 2.20 Texas Tech vs. Arizona
13. Champs Sports 2.13 North Carolina State vs. Pitt
14. Pinstripe 2.00 Syracuse vs. Kansas State
15. Sun 1.90 Miami (FL) vs. Notre Dame
16. Liberty 1.70 SMU vs. South Florida
17. Music City 1.60 Tennessee vs. Boston College
18. Kraft Fight Hunger 1.575 Hawaii vs. Arizona State*
19. BBVA Compass 1.50 Louisville vs. Kentucky
20. TicketCity 1.20 Indiana vs. Texas*
21. Independence 1.10 Georgia Tech vs. San Diego State
22. Las Vegas 1.00 Air Force vs. Oregon State*
23. Beef O Bradys 1.00 Temple* vs. Tulsa (No Big East team with 5 wins, Temple gets the nod)
24. Meineke 1.00 North Carolina vs. Colorado* (No Big East team with 5 wins, Colorado gets the nod)
25. Military 1.00 BYU vs. Army
26. New Mexico 0.75 Marshall* vs. Fresno State (No MWC team with 5 wins, Marshall gets the nod)
27. Hawaii 0.75 Southern Mississippi vs. Idaho
28. Poinsettia 0.75 Houston* vs. Navy (No MWC 5 team with 5 wins available, Houston gets the nod)
29. Armed Forces 0.75 MWC* vs. East Carolina
30. GoDaddy 0.75 Miami (OH) vs. Middle Tennessee
31. Little Caesars 0.75 Lousiana-Monroe* vs. Ohio (No Big 10 team with 5 wins available, UL-Mon gets the nod)
32. Humanitarian 0.75 Louisiana Tech*vs. Toledo
33. Texas 0.6125 Iowa State* vs. Western Michigan (No Big 10 Team available, W. Mich gets the nod)
34. New Orleans 0.325 Troy vs. UTEP


It's not perfect. Your thoughts?
This message has been modified
Originally posted on Jan 2, 2011 at 4:02:01pm
Message modified by on Jan 2, 2011 at 4:02:01pm
Conan O'Fresno
Previous username
fresnocoug
New username
Conan
Bio page
Conan O'Fresno
Joined
Jun 14, 2005
Last login
Jun 30, 2015
Total posts
0 (0 FO)
Messages
Author
Time

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.