but...I'll post a logical response anyway, I suppose.

Regardless of what you think, any objective observer would have to agree that he is certainly good enough to start at BYU, and is good enough to do some pretty amazing things here. The weight of the evidence is against your post (just think of his HS accomplishments, his mechanics and skills, and his personality and competitiveness).

Everything points to him having a great QB career at BYU if given the opportunity. Are you suggesting that he will never get that opportunity? Mark this down...He will have a chance to compete for a starting QB position at BYU, and if he gives the team the best chance of winning, then he will start. Because this has yet to be determined, there is no way that you or any of us can say definitively that he will or will not start. Any attempt is futile.