I separate transfers from recruits. I wouldn't ever call a transfer a BYU recruit.

Dec 19, 2024
4:06:13pm

kimdaddy35 Former Fly Half

But I guess that is where CrimWalCoug and I differ. No big deal.

But to deliciousmocha's point, A-Rod has done horribly with QB recruiting. Ever since Hall and Wilson left (both recruited by previous regimes) we have not had any home grown QBs.

Report problem with this ad

kimdaddy35

Bio page: kimdaddy35
Joined: Aug 23, 2010
Last login: Dec 20, 2024
Total posts: 52,445 (1,561 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Noah Lugo in the portal

RH84025

Dec 19, 3:50pm

Hasta lugo

GfB

Dec 19, 3:51pm

Portuguese?

Plantagenet

Dec 19, 4:54pm

Close, that would be Ate Logo

J-Rod

Dec 19, 5:14pm

Well, we can’t hit on all of our HS quarterback signees.

DieHarder

Dec 19, 3:54pm

Or even one.

kimdaddy35

Dec 19, 3:59pm

Yeah it’s pretty bad at this point

palangi

Dec 19, 5:43pm

edit: horrible

palangi

Dec 19, 5:44pm

Good thing A-Rod's crushing it with QB recruiting

deliciousmocha

Dec 19, 3:54pm

Sark coming back for a couple years since his JUCO time no longer counts. Plus nobody but Retzlaff will play so it makes

byuTX

Dec 19, 3:56pm

Considering the QBs ahead of Lugo are also ARod recruits . . .

CrimWalCoug

Dec 19, 3:56pm

They are? I'm pretty sure they are all transfers.

kimdaddy35

Dec 19, 3:59pm

Which were recruited by…

HFF

Dec 19, 4:01pm

I separate transfers from recruits. I wouldn't ever call a transfer a BYU recruit.

kimdaddy35

Dec 19, 4:06pm

We don’t recruit transfers?

Jericho

Dec 19, 4:44pm

Why not? You have to recruit transfer last the same you have to recruit HS guys

arcawley

Dec 19, 4:45pm

This is a little odd. Transfers are recruited just like HS'ers.

LifeLongLakerFan

Dec 19, 5:19pm

Maybe in the 90s, but in 2024 you gotta recruit the portal.

shimmy

Dec 19, 5:51pm

When the guy you expected to sit behind for 2 years all of a sudden gets an

Kajdin

Dec 19, 4:00pm

Noah was close with Waller and played together growing up. Hope this does not

Captain Stubing

Dec 19, 4:00pm

This makes me sad. BYU relying on transfers in the QB room I think gives us a lot of good guys,

kimdaddy35

Dec 19, 4:03pm

Take a look at the college landscape. How many successful college QBs are at

LifeLongLakerFan

Dec 19, 5:22pm

At this rate, BYU will have a full roster next week.

Belboz

Dec 19, 4:04pm

So is that a sign that Jake is planning to stay 2 more years?

NOCAL_YFAN

Dec 19, 4:04pm

He doesn't have that option as of now. He could try and sue the NCAA. To me the law will be

kimdaddy35

Dec 19, 4:07pm

I think plenty of other players will appeal that they will have to make a rule

Huge Manatee

Dec 19, 4:09pm

When was the last time the NCAA won a lawsuit?

Schultz is back

Dec 19, 4:11pm

very unlikely it gets resolved for a couple years. NCAA may suspend enforcement of the rule

byuTX

Dec 19, 4:35pm

Why? He was probably going to start or compete after restslaff left next year.

Cjwildboy

Dec 19, 4:29pm

Did the coaches tell him Ryder Lyons is coming?

shakavaka

Dec 19, 5:06pm

I hope so.. USC has 5 signed QB's. He could compete next year against Retzlaff and would take it after Jake leaves.

AltTabbins

Dec 19, 5:13pm

Ryder is class of 2026 and possibly a mission kid.

Cougstreak

Dec 19, 8:31pm

RE: Ryder is class of 2026 and possibly a mission kid.

AltTabbins

Dec 19, 8:39pm

I wonder if his landscape changed. He got lots of offers but only 2 from P4 (BYU and Indiana).

AltTabbins

Dec 19, 5:17pm

Was this a nudge out the door or something else?

jre85

Dec 19, 6:24pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad