Look at our history with four star guys.

Sign up, and you'll be able to ignore users whose posts you don't want to see. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Dec 16, 2024
4:14:46pm

BYU '80 Intervention Needed

Look at our history with four star guys.

Maybe he didn’t deserve that metric but byu doesn’t get many of this caliber recruit. At what point is it used against us that seemingly none turnout?

Give me a thumbs down. Who
Is the last four star that worked out? It will be said that BYU’s top recruits don’t develop there

This message has been modified

Originally posted on Dec 16, 2024 at 4:14:46pm

Message modified by BYU '80 on Dec 16, 2024 at 6:36:20pm

Report problem with this ad

BYU '80

Bio page: BYU '80
Joined: Jan 11, 2006
Last login: Dec 16, 2024
Total posts: 55,713 (151 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Aisea Moa entered into the portal.

ByuCrusader

3:13pm

This one hurts, ouch.

runnincoug

3:16pm

I don’t see that, all the LB’s are coming back

JOPE

3:55pm

Ouch

EM_Puma

3:16pm

Yeah, this sucks. He received a fair amount of PT mid-season, but Miles Hall

4:16pm

Source

ByuCrusader

3:17pm

BYU failed with another top recruit

BYU '80

3:18pm

To me this confirms that Kelly is back. We didn't fail him. We just have some

spidercoug

3:21pm

How did they fail? The guy gets PT, is playing behind three possible next level

BYUheaven

3:22pm

Thinking now though, hall, Esara, Glasker, Taggart all could be here in 2026,

cougaman

3:24pm

Sure….maybe not a sure fire starter but he was progressing well.

BYUheaven

3:28pm

He only has 2 years left though, and probably 5 guys already ahead of him with

cougaman

3:29pm

My bad, for some reason I thought he had three off the top of my head

BYUheaven

3:40pm

<< Deleted >>

BYUfannonLDS

3:34pm

You really have no idea if this is true or not. At least wait for some

LifeLongLakerFan

3:33pm

Look at our history with four star guys.

BYU '80

4:14pm

If a player fails to see the field who exactly failed? It seems byu is developing guys just fine…

GoodBetterBestBYU

7:13pm

What? He hardly saw the field and couldn’t bulk up to d line.

Mjolnir

3:55pm

Isn’t that a failure? We had a 4 star guy

BYU '80

4:21pm

You are reading way too much into the rankings

JKLCoug

5:14pm

It will be used against us with top recruits

BYU '80

6:37pm

Lol - so don’t play the best 11 players, play the highest ranked

JKLCoug

7:08pm

Remember the rankings at 24/7 are made by guys who were journalists in college.

GoodBetterBestBYU

7:14pm

Top recruits are overrated. Utah has failed with literally every single one of

uteman13

6:13pm

Not sure what to think about this source when they called him an edge rusher

cougaman

3:19pm

Is it about $$$$$$?

Big12Yfan

3:17pm

Why would be about $ if he was 3rd string?

Mjolnir

3:55pm

*gift cards

CrimWalCoug

4:05pm

Oh no

TNT

3:17pm

Dang… Is this one more about PT or money? He maybe wasn’t going to start next

cougaman

3:19pm

On second thought, I think this is about trying to start. Between Kelly, Glasker

cougaman

3:27pm

Which probably means his 4 star brother won't sign with BYU for 2026.

BYUfannonLDS

3:19pm

We still have his other brother and this is a PT issue. We have 3 NFL caliber

spidercoug

3:20pm

Dang. This is the first one that I’m super bummed about.

ballen

3:20pm

$$$ move

TANK

3:23pm

Isn’t his brother a huge recruit for 2026? If so, that probably hurts as much if

DieHarder

3:26pm

We’ll see if Sione stays though. Maybe the oldest brother can convince him

cougaman

3:28pm

This sucks, but this is new norm in NIL/transfer portal world. Be difficult to

kansascougar

3:28pm

This one’s a bummer

DavisCoCoug

3:34pm

Is it possible BYU will try and bring in Sione Fotu from Utah now?

BYUfannonLDS

3:35pm

If J Hill decides he is better (or anyone else). I trust him at this point

fulano

4:00pm

With his size I thought they might have tried moving him to edge next year. I think he’s got good enough motor to do it.

SolidBlue

4:38pm

He started at edge and was moved.

cougaman

4:52pm

Darn. Sure hope RB Moa does not follow.

Forzaitalia

4:48pm

Why would he? They aren't related.

4:48pm

Not even cousins of some sort?

Forzaitalia

4:52pm

Not any Moa.

CrimWalCoug

5:01pm

Why would he want to leave? PT? Money? Scheme?

Borg

4:48pm

2 years of eligibility, Esera likely passes him up on depth chart next season

4:52pm

Wasn't he struggling to add weight to his lanky frame and couldn't therefore get the strength needed for DL?

CLCougar

5:08pm

He seemed overrated

CaliforniaCougar22

7:04pm

Too bad, I like that Moa family!

GoodBetterBestBYU

7:15pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad