His ceiling being right in competition for a conference title

Report problem with this ad

Nov 17, 2024
3:45:59pm

CasualFan Truly Addicted User

Year 2 and a trip to the playoffs?

Yeah. That’s probably the ceiling.

This message has been modified

Originally posted on Nov 17, 2024 at 3:45:59pm

Message modified by CasualFan on Nov 17, 2024 at 3:46:11pm

Report problem with this ad

CasualFan

Bio page: CasualFan
Joined: Sep 29, 2014
Last login: Nov 17, 2024
Total posts: 3,802 (0 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Has Kalani hit his ceiling as a coach? Should have won the game, but the

Cosmo Kramer

3:43pm

His ceiling is as high as byu is willing to pay for coordinators…

conetah

3:44pm

And to clarify, paying the same coordinator more won’t make him better.

bluecougar1985

3:47pm

This point has been lost on BYU at times. And on Coaches.

Madam Pattirini

4:31pm

Exactly this. Kalani probably isnt a scheme guru, but if he can hire right and

Resurgens

5:58pm

No, but A-Rod may have.

Yucatan

3:44pm

…Super Bowl by now!!!

niqmadu

3:44pm

His ceiling being right in competition for a conference title

CasualFan

3:45pm

Can't keep his players motivated, all the way to the end.

Cosmo Kramer

3:48pm

Horrible take

JKLCoug

3:51pm

Could be, that's why I asked the question.

Cosmo Kramer

3:52pm

Nope. Try again.

gopman

3:53pm

Bronco had a ceiling, and I was good with that. Many double digit win seasons,

Cosmo Kramer

3:55pm

Bronco had one double digit season in his last 6

donnerstag

4:18pm

I didn't look it up, I remember having more ten win seasons than not.

Cosmo Kramer

4:20pm

He definitely peaked in his first 5 years

donnerstag

5:30pm

That (among others) has been an issue his entire tenure.

gopman

3:52pm

Which is the norm for 97.5% of coaches out there, and that's ok.

Cosmo Kramer

3:57pm

<< Deleted >>

gopman

4:03pm

The TOP 25% of head coaches lose to multiple inferior opponents

gopman

4:09pm

And beating several teams he has no business beating.

CasualFan

4:04pm

He has but those wins have been offset with losses to Toledo, USF, UMass,

gopman

4:13pm

Address the point

CasualFan

4:30pm

At the same RATE as Kalani? Lol.

gopman

4:36pm

Yes. Look around the conference. BYU has a better record against bad teams

CasualFan

4:41pm

I'm talking about his entire tenure as head coach. Jay Hill is the reason

gopman

4:49pm

And I’m sure you know nothing of the tenure of all the other coaches in

CasualFan

4:53pm

I don't care about other head coaches. I care about ours. You still

gopman

4:59pm

What does this even mean?

NYCougz

3:46pm

Can he float to the ceiling?

Cosmo Kramer

3:47pm

RE: Can he float to the ceiling?

NYCougz

3:49pm

This is not a slam on kalani. I think he should stay, he's good for the kids and

Cosmo Kramer

3:46pm

Time to hit the panic button again!!!!

Cooouuugs

3:48pm

It's only been 5 minutes.

maYbe

3:49pm

seriously, CB is hilarious.

runnincoug

5:14pm

Why is this panic? It's a legit question without feeling the need to fire him.

Cosmo Kramer

3:50pm

Legit answer then is no. he had 4 wins last year, 9+ this year, he's growing

runnincoug

5:15pm

He hit his ceiling last year. It's all downhill from there

Belboz

3:49pm

Definitely. Time to fire him!

shoganai

3:49pm

Didn't say that

Cosmo Kramer

3:50pm

If you conclude the answer is yes, the demand to fire him is inevitable. May as

shoganai

4:07pm

That is not true. How many Vince Lombardi s and Nick Sabans are there?

Cosmo Kramer

4:19pm

I think he is and can be as good as his coordinators allow him to be. He's a great ambassador for the school and

foofcoug

3:49pm

Well thought out response. I love kalani as the HC and want him to stay. Just

Cosmo Kramer

3:52pm

How much credence do you lend to salary as being a limiting factor in

Cosmo Kramer

4:32pm

If that is the case then BYU is shooting itself in the foot. You're not going to get much real value if you shop at Temu

foofcoug

4:50pm

I think this is a conversation to have when the record isn't 9-1

MarylandFan

3:50pm

Just a bad night. He must’ve been motivating enough to get them to 9-0.

CougarGuy84

3:53pm

Just going by what the players said.

Cosmo Kramer

3:56pm

I don't put much stock in coach or player speak. I think the players

GSwarriorcoug

3:54pm

If so, it's probably among the ceilings of the best coaches in college football

Spindash

3:55pm

That is a well thought out answer. I agree with that.

Cosmo Kramer

4:00pm

well, he has blown through whatever ceiling this team should’ve accomplished this year

JOPE

3:55pm

That is true. They could have easily lost the OSU game and the Utah game.

Cosmo Kramer

3:59pm

He's shattered his past ceiling this year.

Posting on CougarBoard