They were when Texas played them.

Report problem with this ad

Nov 12, 2024
7:37:33am

Skeptical Optimist Political Junky

Report problem with this ad

Skeptical Optimist

Previous username: workindev
Bio page: Skeptical Optimist
Joined: Aug 2, 2006
Last login: Nov 14, 2024
Total posts: 84,387 (4,475 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Listening to longhorns radio this morning talk about cfp rankings

creameryon9th

Nov 12, 6:44am

Someone send them a picture of Taysom.

Japan Coug

Nov 12, 6:46am

with tag "this is what will happen when you lose to Arkansas this weekend and

oryguncoug

Nov 12, 9:12am

RE: Listening to longhorns radio this morning talk about cfp rankings

momowagon

Nov 12, 6:48am

They don’t realize their success is tied to a coach from BYU

GoodBetterBestBYU

Nov 12, 6:56am

One of the “head winds” BYU faces is that they played SMU and K-State too early

Japan Coug

Nov 12, 7:02am

Critical thinking is becoming a lost art practiced only by nerds

ryebrye

Nov 12, 7:06am

Huh? Texas beat #10 Michigan on the road this year, and #18 OU in the rivalry game

Skeptical Optimist

Nov 12, 7:11am

And #25 Vanderbilt on the road

Skeptical Optimist

Nov 12, 7:12am

And none are ranked due to multiple losses. MI and OU are “terrible”this year.

ImuaKahuku

Nov 12, 10:40am

Texas is good

GoodBetterBestBYU

Nov 12, 7:13am

Top 10 in offensive points per game, passing yards per game, total yards per game, #2 in defensive yards

Skeptical Optimist

Nov 12, 7:24am

Michigan has since been exposed as very mediocre, and Oklahoma too. Not only is

Japan Coug

Nov 12, 7:14am

Is this TIC? I feel like this is TIC

wildeone

Nov 12, 7:15am

Why would it be TIC? You can easy look for yourself.

Skeptical Optimist

Nov 12, 7:22am

Because both Michigan and Oklahoma were exposed as frauds. Both unranked.

Brandoblueblood

Nov 12, 10:04am

They were ranked when Texas played them. And you simply can't argue that doesn't

Skeptical Optimist

Nov 12, 10:14am

So does our game against SMU not count because they weren't ranked at the time?

stansburycoug

Nov 12, 10:34am

I've said a few times in this thread that both metrics count.

Skeptical Optimist

Nov 12, 11:22am

Beating FSU shouldn't count for anything. They were bad all year

stansburycoug

Nov 12, 11:44am

Those games mean zero to the ctee. They care about the playoff top 25

BYU '80

Nov 12, 1:11pm

What? Neither OU or Michigan is ranked. Texas is good though.

Incentivize

Nov 12, 7:31am

They were when Texas played them.

Skeptical Optimist

Nov 12, 7:37am

And that means nothing.

wildeone

Nov 12, 8:06am

Disagree. It means a lot. So does current ranking.

Skeptical Optimist

Nov 12, 9:07am

So does a win over FSU early in the season should be considered a quality win?

wildeone

Nov 12, 9:10am

If they are ranked when you played them, it would be considered a win over a ranked opponent

Skeptical Optimist

Nov 12, 9:32am

So you think Georgia Tech beat a top-10 team that is currently 1-9?

wildeone

Nov 12, 9:55am

Of course. It's right here:

Skeptical Optimist

Nov 12, 10:07am

and that # next to Florida State refers to last year's team, not this year

Hill4Heisman

Nov 12, 1:10pm

Well, Utah was a top 10 team 5 weeks into this season, so we have a top10 win?

Brandoblueblood

Nov 12, 10:07am

And FSU was ranked #2 preseason.

squidmark

Nov 12, 10:24am

At the same time admitting we're good when it's convenient for them.

tony

Nov 12, 7:12am

BYU is Schrodingers cat. Good when they need us to be good, otherwise bad.

StanfordCougar

Nov 12, 7:18am

I think you may have the wrong cat.

DirtyWater

Nov 12, 7:33am

But he’ll never know if he’s wrong or right. Maybe he’s wrong and right

DanSmith

Nov 12, 11:07am

BYU is simultaneously good and bad unless they are observed, which is hard

fatcracker

Nov 12, 12:17pm

Best part of being in B12 is we can play our way in on the field. We are not going to change perceptions in 1 year.

Longhaul

Nov 12, 8:13am

My eye roll was directed at Texas, not this post.

TRUE_BLUE_COUGY

Nov 12, 8:34am

Entitled thinking by those Longhorns.

Forzaitalia

Nov 12, 8:58am

"SMU is really good because their only loss was to a good BYU team. But also,

TheNerd

Nov 12, 9:03am

MODERATORS: We need an "I'm pissed off" emoticon. It would be appropriate for this thread.

Knight-who-says-ni

Nov 12, 9:30am

So true, so true - same (lack of) logic, different teams on east coast radio

StoneyCurtis

Nov 12, 9:32am

Welcome to the beauty pageant

Posting on CougarBoard