I also really like the Block Y, and the Beet Digger on the Block Y

Sign up, and you'll be able to vote in polls. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Oct 16, 2024
7:57:09pm

TheHop Intervention Needed

I also really like the Block Y, and the Beet Digger on the Block Y

Report problem with this ad

TheHop

Bio page: TheHop
Joined: Oct 30, 2001
Last login: Oct 16, 2024
Total posts: 14,931 (116 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Reminder: sailor Coug is derivative and mediocre. We have better retro logos.

russkiejedi

Oct 16, 7:19pm

I mean, so is having a letter repping your school. We just happen to have the

The Pope

Oct 16, 7:28pm

RE: I mean, so is having a letter repping your school. We just happen to have the

mvtoro

Oct 16, 7:30pm

LOL, silly comparison. Letters come in a lot of different fonts and are drawn

russkiejedi

Oct 16, 7:35pm

Which sailor Coug do you think is so similar to ours? The WSU one you showed is far inferior IMO and strengthens the

mvtoro

Oct 16, 7:42pm

The differences between the freshman cap logos are much more subtle than between

russkiejedi

Oct 16, 7:48pm

They are incredibly different to my eye. Not subtle at all. Similar in that they both have a hat and that’s about it.

mvtoro

Oct 16, 7:55pm

LOL, dude, settle down. I'm not having a design argument with you. Sure there

russkiejedi

Oct 16, 8:02pm

🤣 A design argument is exactly what we’re having. Sorry if my actually having expertise in that upsets you, but I’m not

mvtoro

Oct 16, 8:13pm

No, we're having an argument about preferences. I said the logo was derivative

russkiejedi

Oct 16, 8:19pm

Preferences about what? A design? 🤣🤣🤣 What do you think a design argument looks like? Math?

mvtoro

Oct 16, 8:44pm

No, preferences about a logo. The relative design merits of the various freshman

russkiejedi

Oct 16, 9:10pm

“Those are my opinions about the logo, informed by the fact that *the design* is strikingly similar…” -You 🤣

mvtoro

Oct 16, 9:35pm

RE: The differences between the freshman cap logos are much more subtle than

Mississippi

Oct 16, 7:56pm

RE: The differences between the freshman cap logos are much more subtle than

russkiejedi

Oct 16, 8:02pm

*freshman cap Coug

BYUFBDAD

Oct 16, 7:49pm

*Arthur Evans cartoon mill Cougar

foofcoug

Oct 16, 7:51pm

RE: Reminder: sailor Coug is derivative and mediocre. We have better retro

TheHop

Oct 16, 7:50pm

That’s the best logo. Stretch Y and Beetdigger are 2 and 3 (no particular order)

Oct 16, 7:55pm

I also really like the Block Y, and the Beet Digger on the Block Y

TheHop

Oct 16, 7:57pm

Stretch Y is #1 for me from a logo-design perspective. It’s a great logo. Simple. Scales. Instantly recognizable. Not

mvtoro

Oct 16, 8:02pm

Stretch Y is best in Utah. But it's easily confused with Yahoo for non college

RUNBYU1

Oct 16, 9:26pm

Beetdigger Cougar is the best out of state IMO. It says 'BYU' and shows a Cougar

RUNBYU1

Oct 16, 9:27pm

Second to the stretch Y IMO. But it’s great. Gets a nostalgia bump. I think the Y is widely known now, but you’re right

mvtoro

Oct 16, 9:37pm

Strongly disagree. Stretch Y is the best for usability, but Beetdigger is the

russkiejedi

Oct 16, 8:06pm

That one is fine but it looks like a high schooler designed it.

Oct 16, 8:10pm

What is the beetdigger?

crack

Oct 16, 8:27pm

LaVell era primary logo with the Coug eating the U.

russkiejedi

Oct 16, 8:29pm

Ahh - I never knew that was the name of it. Thanks.

crack

Oct 16, 8:46pm

"It's da best!"

RUNBYU1

Oct 16, 9:28pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad