Well I think they aren’t good at all. I believe we are but SMU sucks

Report problem with this ad

Sep 18, 2024
5:32:05pm

Don Carlton All-American

Report problem with this ad

Don Carlton

Previous username: Idahofallsblue
Bio page: Don Carlton
Joined: Apr 10, 2011
Last login: Sep 19, 2024
Total posts: 18,245 (880 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Amazing how a 3 point win @ SMU has changed perceptions of this team.

rad dawg

Sep 18, 11:27am

RE: Amazing how a 3 point win @ SMU has changed perceptions of this team.

ebv

Sep 18, 11:28am

We'll learn how good SMU is this Saturday when TCU plays @ SMU.

Mostlyaccurate

Sep 18, 11:29am

Even more crazy is how unimpressed some BYU fans are at BYU beating a P4 team on the road as a 2 score underdog.

mulletino

Sep 18, 11:29am

True, I forgot how big of a P4 powerhouse SMU is.

Plato

Sep 18, 11:34am

Is that what I said or did I say we beat a P4 team on the road as a 2 score underdog? Stay focused.

mulletino

Sep 18, 11:35am

Socrates is doing his best to try to calm Plato down.....with little success.

StarMan

Sep 18, 11:40am

You definitely made the implication. Why else would you say P4 team?

Plato

Sep 18, 11:46am

Because they’re in a P4 conference. Isn’t that the definition?

mulletino

Sep 18, 11:47am

First year in P4 is different than a team that has been recruiting in a P4 for

here's to hoping

Sep 18, 1:39pm

HUGE recruiting difference between a 1st year P4 team and a 2nd year P4 team. 🫤

StarMan

Sep 18, 2:51pm

Did you forget how to read?

Abe Froman

Sep 18, 12:08pm

I think he reads fine, it’s the comprehension part that’s tough for some.

NonmormonYfan89

Sep 18, 1:49pm

nope, he didn't. Not only does he read, but he also demonstrated the capacity

Czar-castic

Sep 18, 3:46pm

Fight! Fight! Fight!

TNT

Sep 18, 4:41pm

Great win and super fun to be there. Not sure how much it means yet.

rad dawg

Sep 18, 11:43am

SMU could be a really good team or they could be awful. It’s too soon to tell.

allaboutthegainz

Sep 18, 11:31am

Pretty sure the really good team is not a possibility, but they

Plato

Sep 18, 11:35am

RE: Pretty sure the really good team is not a possibility, but they

mulletino

Sep 18, 11:36am

Why not? They have a lot of talent.

allaboutthegainz

Sep 18, 11:37am

Just seems very unlikely given their results through three games.

Plato

Sep 18, 11:49am

I peg you as a guy who sees the glass as half empty. 🙂

TrueBlue58

Sep 18, 12:11pm

And are you judging that as a negative? Would seem pessimistic 😉

BYUDM93

Sep 18, 4:48pm

Nah - I see the glass as too big! 😬😎

TrueBlue58

Sep 18, 7:14pm

Nice! I enjoy challenging the paradigm on this one. If my goal is to drink what

BYUDM93

8:40am

Well I think they aren’t good at all. I believe we are but SMU sucks

Don Carlton

Sep 18, 5:32pm

There were many, many posts the week before SMU game that SMU was our hardest

Doogal McCougar

Sep 18, 11:34am

Forget the post from red dawg - I WANT SOME BRISKET! OOOHH that looks good!

jaba166

Sep 18, 6:40pm

From preseason I thought, if we get that W at SMU, we go bowling. There are

paulb

Sep 18, 11:34am

That is what I thought last year when BYU got 5 wins 🙂

WJCougar

Sep 18, 11:39am

Yeah, that does still have me worried, but I'm hopeful.

paulb

Sep 18, 11:44am

Counterpoint. How we played in all 3 games is taken into account.

Blueto

Sep 18, 11:39am

SMU's best RB is out against TCU, so that hurts their chances against TCU

CLCougar

Sep 18, 11:40am

Broader view, BYU has significantly outplayed expectations (see spreads) in 3 straight games

kccougar

Sep 18, 11:41am

SMU statically had the best defense we’d see this year

kapcreations

Sep 18, 11:59am

If people expected 5 wins and a loss to SMU, expecting 6 wins now

Belboz

Sep 18, 12:28pm

The negative Nancy's will point to SMU having a bye and say the TCU game is not

NYC and Japan

Sep 18, 2:24pm

You're not wrong. Still feels good and I prefer to be optimistic anyways.

boctabulous

Sep 18, 4:21pm

My thoughts: Prognostications before season were mediocre-ish on both sides of

rcbyufan

Sep 18, 4:34pm

Pay attention. BYU was favored by only about 10 vs Wyoming. Won by 20,

Cougarbib

Sep 18, 4:47pm

I don't think beating SMU is the only available datapoint.

Socrates Johnson

Sep 18, 6:33pm

Absolutely curious to see how SMU does this week, since they had been scoring

jaba166

Sep 18, 6:37pm

I am most curious to see their QB situation.

rad dawg

Sep 18, 6:46pm

And there it is again - the Brisket. I must stop clicking on your posts when

jaba166

12:47am

u @Okie State would like a word. u has an easy schedule. This is their big test.

Cougarbib

Sep 18, 11:06pm

that’s how it is for a lot of teams right now. ESPECIALLY in the SEC. such massive reactions to teams playing nobody

Posting on CougarBoard