BYU grads make more on average the first 4 years after graduation. However, there are majors at both schools where earnings are higher than at the other. My friends that went to byu are all teachers, they are all principals or vice principals now they all make about 1/2 of what I made with a finance degree. However, I have no doubt they made more of an impact on society than I did. They were/are a positive influence on hundreds of kids.