My Account
Report problem with this ad
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Sep 8, 2024
8:11
:08
am
shimmy
In play, run(s)
And how many unquestionably garbage throws did he make? The guy has not shown any semblance of accuracy. He's had one
decent game against an FCS school. He makes the right decisions on the read option.
But you're right, he does share some really bad games in his record like all the BYU greats. I bet almost every hall of famer had some awful games.
This message has been modified
Originally posted on Sep 8, 2024 at 8:11:08am
Message modified by shimmy on Sep 8, 2024 at 8:13:04am
Message modified by shimmy on Sep 8, 2024 at 8:19:12am
Message modified by shimmy on Sep 8, 2024 at 8:19:25am
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Report problem with this ad
shimmy
Previous username
AFCoug83
Bio page
shimmy
Joined
Jan 15, 2008
Last login
Nov 13, 2024
Total posts
122,017 (37,856 FO)
Report problem with this ad
Messages
Author
Time
I was optimistic that BYU could win 6 games this year, beat the preseason
Coug98
Sep 8, 7:30am
I’m more confident after watching games this weekend. A bunch of higher-rated
Dangerous
Sep 8, 7:32am
The O will get better, the RBs will improve. Baylor and UH
jigidajrit
Sep 8, 7:48am
Exactly how I felt yesterday
CPAcoug87
Sep 8, 8:01am
UH just played top 25 Oklahoma down to the wire. I don't get how that game
cwilke1
Sep 8, 8:50am
Last game of season, I like our chances
jigidajrit
Sep 8, 9:33am
BYU lost its last game of the season last year. I don't know why being last
cwilke1
Sep 8, 11:38am
Gives our O more time to develop
jigidajrit
Sep 8, 11:58am
it gives Houston's O more time to develop too
cwilke1
Sep 8, 1:31pm
Why would the RBs improve if Martin is injured?
ochobeeguy
Sep 8, 9:29am
More reps. Improvement from Fridays showing post-LJ
jigidajrit
Sep 8, 9:32am
We were 12 point underdogs and won! Even with the mistakes on offense which I
Dangerous
Sep 8, 7:37am
You've just inadvertently hit on the difference between pro & anti Kalani
Blue Print
Sep 8, 7:48am
Why do you think the mistakes on offense will be corrected?
shimmy
Sep 8, 7:51am
Because I believe you can get better and some games just have more issues than
Dangerous
Sep 8, 8:03am
Want to know who else had some horrible games? Peyton Manning, Tom Brady, Dan Marino, John Elway, and thousands of awful
shimmy
Sep 8, 8:06am
Glad I can enjoy a win and not be poopy all weekend like a bunch of you. Enjoy
Dangerous
Sep 8, 8:20am
Dude, who do you think you're talking to? I am very much an "enjoy the ride" guy. But the other side of that coin is not
shimmy
Sep 8, 8:41am
Did BYU get better last year?
ochobeeguy
Sep 8, 9:31am
This is my question too.
Coug98
Sep 8, 8:28am
SMU was hugely overrated. They looked terrible against Nevada and us.
Frankfromtheballpark
Sep 8, 8:22am
Negative Nancy
cambo
Sep 8, 7:39am
Just being realistic
Coug98
Sep 8, 8:29am
We all appreciate you being more enlightened than the rest of us.
CPAcoug87
Sep 8, 8:32am
I’ll gladly eat crow, but deep down you know I’m right. I’m glad you are a
Coug98
Sep 8, 8:43am
I don’t know that they won’t make it to 6 wins and neither do you.
CPAcoug87
Sep 8, 9:04am
No...you are being negative
cambo
Sep 8, 10:58am
The defense has been so good. The offense on Friday was so bad. It’s frustrating
Idacoug
Sep 8, 7:39am
How many games wld you have predicted the 2008 BYU Cougs wld win if you'd been
oxcoug
Sep 8, 7:42am
Would you have the info from 2007 showing that Max was actually a pretty decent qb?
shimmy
Sep 8, 7:53am
As long as you also had the info that 2007 team had a strong OL, the best WR in
oxcoug
Sep 8, 7:58am
Then yeah, I'd have been optimistic about 2008 as I was then. Retzlaff has never shown an ability to throw the ball
shimmy
Sep 8, 8:02am
Sure. Retzlaff has never had the GOAT WR, the GOAT TE and an established OL
oxcoug
Sep 8, 8:08am
And how many unquestionably garbage throws did he make? The guy has not shown any semblance of accuracy. He's had one
shimmy
Sep 8, 8:11am
Actually less than the garbage throws Max made when going 11/30, 17/40 and 21/45
oxcoug
Sep 10, 8:51am
Retzlaff is no Max Hall. I get that Detmer, Young, and other BYU QB greats have
Coug98
Sep 8, 8:41am
He's a 'turnover machine' who has as many total INTs in the first six games of
oxcoug
Sep 10, 8:48am
I see 5
PhilPete
Sep 8, 7:52am
This is Deja vu of last year. Everyone is super confident that we make a bowl.
Chasicle
Sep 8, 8:22am
I think so too…I hope I’m wrong. Vegas was wrong on the game against SMU, and
Coug98
Sep 8, 8:50am
SMU win guarantees Bowl game…..you will pay the price for your lack of vision
Chicago Cougar
Sep 8, 8:35am
Name the wins…call your shot. Which games does BYU win.
Coug98
Sep 8, 8:52am
BYU will win Wyoming, Houston, Baylor, ASU, KSU, and possibly another upset.
BYU I Bleed Blue
Sep 8, 9:01am
At the start of the season I had us beating SIU, Wyoming, Baylor, ASU, and
Coug98
Sep 8, 9:25am
Agreed - the defense has been much better and the offense has been worse
BYU Fan
Sep 8, 9:01am
Hill needs to be elevated to HC immediately.
Mitty
Sep 8, 9:06am
The wins just aren't there. Other teams after struggling start to bring in
Mitty
Sep 8, 9:03am
We already have two wins, next week will be one more. We should beat Baylor and
BYU I Bleed Blue
Sep 8, 9:06am
Fool's gold. UH and Baylor will improve as the season goes on. Yewtah
Mitty
Sep 8, 9:25am
A lot of our future opponents looked very beatable yesterday
goidcougs
Sep 8, 9:06am
As do we.
Happy As Larry
Sep 8, 10:42am
So it all averages out
Carnac
Sep 8, 10:45am
I remain optimistic, it is a happier place to be! We are 2-0 we will get better
Dat_rmishner
Sep 8, 10:50am
"Piss poor performance?" Uh. We were double-digit dogs and won.
Brandoblueblood
Sep 8, 11:00am
Some of our fans choose to be miserable
Carnac
Sep 8, 11:04am
I think most people think it was more of a sign that SMU was horrible than BYU
Chasicle
Sep 8, 11:33am
18 points will get you a win against Wyoming but it won’t in conference
Coug98
Sep 8, 12:12pm
Report problem with this ad
Posting on CougarBoard
In order to post, you will need to either
sign up
or
log in
.
Report problem with this ad