Part of the issue is, what is "it"?

Sep 6, 2024
11:46:59pm

Goliath CB users union organizer

If it dude partially raises his hand, it's hard to know for sure what he is doing or intending. I think that is the reason the rule is written the way it is.

Report problem with this ad

Goliath

Previous username: Koolio
Bio page: Goliath
Joined: May 25, 2005
Last login: Sep 18, 2024
Total posts: 31,533 (1,882 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

The fair catch late hit penalty

Goliath

Sep 6, 11:40pm

At least it kept us from playing prevent D

puntersarepeople

Sep 6, 11:41pm

He was in a full sprint while doing it kind of hard to do

KYU

Sep 6, 11:41pm

I don't recall it being in a full Sprint

Goliath

Sep 6, 11:42pm

I rewatched he definitely signaled for a fair catch, but it was very difficult to tell because he was sprinting. Also

KYU

Sep 6, 11:46pm

All the byu players other than McKenzie saw it. As a gunner you have to see it

7FootRussian

Sep 6, 11:44pm

Part of the issue is, what is "it"?

Goliath

Sep 6, 11:46pm

He made a full windmill motion.

RGGeemer

Sep 6, 11:49pm

I disagree and I think the other BYU players would too.

7FootRussian

Sep 6, 11:54pm

You disagree that is the reason the rule is written that way

Goliath

Sep 6, 11:58pm

Here's what North Texas did a year or two ago

Goliath

Sep 7, 12:01am

They showed a replay on tv, he definitely signaled clearly

RGGeemer

Sep 6, 11:46pm

I never got to see a review.

Goliath

Sep 6, 11:48pm

It was a very clear, full extension, windmill signal. Our man messed up.

Corn Pop

Sep 7, 5:59am

This. It was clear.

Ozymandias

Sep 6, 11:48pm

Yep. From the all 22 camera you see Mckenzie look up to see the ball right

rcbyufan

Sep 7, 12:06am

Isn't the ref supposed to blow the whistle after the catch? I don't think they

Posting on CougarBoard