weren't working. Finally we set a live trap. It actually has to enter the trap and when it takes the bait the doors slam shut. Less than an hour later we caught it. They cost more but it worked like a charm and it's reusable.

Here's the one we got

Kensizer Humane Rat Trap, Chipmunk Rodent Trap That Work for Indoor and Outdoor Small Animal - Mouse Voles Hamsters Live Cage Catch and Release 1-Pack https://a.co/d/553bLQH