percentile of fandem to BYU. What did you expect? Program seems to be trending downward over past 3 years. Kalani's results have been rather sporadic. So yeah, devoted fans on a message board are going to complain.
No one is disparaging his name. No one is making egregious personal comments (which of course are out of line). Criticism has been pretty professional. No one is saying he sucks as a person (he's an amazing individual who represents BYU exceptionally well)
It comes with the territory. He is a P4 head coach. Making $3-4M a year probably. Fans are frustrated with inconsistent performance.
If a leader was performing very poorly at their job, and you were a stakeholder in the company, would you not want change?