My Account
Report problem with this ad
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Aug 2, 2024
11:27
:06
am
rtNelson
All-American
The Hall v Wilson results are surprising.
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Report problem with this ad
rtNelson
Bio page
rtNelson
Joined
Sep 17, 2008
Last login
Sep 16, 2024
Total posts
10,151 (38 FO)
Report problem with this ad
Messages
Author
Time
Results of QB ranking survey. 58 Total votes.
Garra_Charrua
Aug 2, 11:10am
I'll update results later if you still want to take it. Link to survey:
Garra_Charrua
Aug 2, 11:14am
Marc Wilson and Gifford Nielsen are way too high
RealTaysomHill
Aug 2, 11:16am
No way.
BlueFever
Aug 2, 11:23am
I agree they’re foundational to the BYU QB factory. But isn’t the foundation at the bottom? BYU built up from them
RealTaysomHill
Aug 2, 11:32am
Virgil Carter was the foundation. It was there when they came along.
Bullrider
Aug 2, 11:40am
Carter predates the factory.
BlueFever
Aug 2, 11:56am
Sorry, I see him as the beginning along with three old geysers I asked feel.
Bullrider
Aug 2, 4:50pm
It's more about who had greater impact on their time.
BlueFever
Aug 2, 11:57am
The Hall v Wilson results are surprising.
rtNelson
Aug 2, 11:27am
Taysom is the worst passer of them all by far. Surprised he is that high.
D.T. Survivor
Aug 2, 11:33am
And the best runner by a lot. Question isn’t *only* passing. But I agree he’s probably high by actual BYU career. If
mvtoro
Aug 2, 1:07pm
Jaren should be higher than Zach. He actually beat Utah. Almost single-handedly
Magneto
Aug 2, 11:54am
Zach woulda beat them if he’d had Tyler Allgeier at RB lol
puntersarepeople
Aug 2, 12:18pm
Tyler Allgeier might be the best RB BYU has had. He was incredible!
Garra_Charrua
Aug 2, 12:25pm
His punch out vs ASU is an all-time play. Usually a RB is a QBs friend because he takes pressure off the pass game. Not
mvtoro
Aug 2, 1:19pm
Tyler put the game away at the end but Jaren’s runs and passes to Nacua were out
Magneto
Aug 2, 1:45pm
Zach had an amazing game vs the Utes once but got stuck with having a 4th string
puntersarepeople
Aug 2, 3:14pm
The problem with most QB rankings is we base them too much on record and team performance. He’s the most important
mvtoro
Aug 2, 1:16pm
Recency bias there. Gifford #4, Mark Wilson #5. Also, Hall and Doman ahead of Z Wilson.
roseyscenario
Aug 2, 1:40pm
Report problem with this ad
Posting on CougarBoard
In order to post, you will need to either
sign up
or
log in
.
Report problem with this ad
