Yeah that’s actually pretty rare. And not worth all the problems you’d get by

Sign up, and CougarBoard will remember which categories you want to view. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

May 15, 2024
9:43:07pm

Samsonite All-American

Yeah that’s actually pretty rare. And not worth all the problems you’d get by

removing the plate umpire.

Report problem with this ad

Samsonite

Previous username: TriggerWarning
Bio page: Samsonite
Joined: Aug 9, 2007
Last login: Oct 31, 2024
Total posts: 47,104 (2,802 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Someday I'll tell my grandkids we had a guy behind the catcher who decided if a

May 15, 9:33pm

The strike zone shown on tv is often wrong. But aside from that, horrible idea

Samsonite

May 15, 9:37pm

Nobody's complaining about the calls an inch outside the magic box. We're

May 15, 9:42pm

Yeah that’s actually pretty rare. And not worth all the problems you’d get by

Samsonite

May 15, 9:43pm

It's not rare. Ump score cards are never 100%. Why not make it 100%

May 15, 9:47pm

Wasn’t your last post a complaint about a call that was barely outside the box?

gaffer

May 15, 9:44pm

Yes, calls that would have been correct with robo umps. Isn't the idea to get

May 15, 9:46pm

I don’t actually think the idea is to get it right all the time. But also that

gaffer

May 15, 9:55pm

That's the dumbest thing I've ever heard. If it's outside the plate (I'll allow

May 15, 10:11pm

Yup.

RootieBoy

May 15, 9:46pm

That's a ball. The 1st one was significantly worse. Guessing you won't

May 15, 9:50pm

This one? I am not sure it is worse, but definitely not significantly worse.

RootieBoy

May 15, 9:56pm

In fact, the second one appears to be closer to the zone than the first SO Ohtani had.

RootieBoy

May 15, 9:57pm

You need your eyes checked number 1. 2nd of all there's definitely nothing

May 15, 10:06pm

Just saw my optometrist on Monday, actually. I'm set.

RootieBoy

May 15, 10:20pm

Was never about a slight against the Dodgers. The bad calls against LA are

May 15, 10:23pm

Why? They are doing it in the minors

Jdoc

May 15, 9:42pm

Replays and robo calls are ruining the game.

May 15, 10:09pm

They’ll still have that. Sounds like MLB is leaning towards the challenge system rather than full ABS (robot calls).

TCuz

May 15, 9:47pm

Yes, for now. We will see where it is in 20 years

cougarfann888

May 15, 9:49pm

Right, thus the OP. No way it doesn't ultimately end up there and the game

May 15, 9:51pm

They'll go to unlimited appeals before they get rid of the plate ump.

shimmy

May 15, 9:53pm

They've already done evert pitch robot calls in the minors.Accuracy down to 3 mm

May 15, 9:58pm

What do you think operates the appeal system?

shimmy

May 15, 10:15pm

I understand how it works. I'm just saying if we can get every call right with

May 15, 10:20pm

I believe that last year the Bees league

Jdoc

May 15, 9:51pm

AAA uses both systems. They have challenge system certain days of the week, and full ABS the others

TCuz

May 15, 9:54pm

Probably a good idea to start with the challenge system. Most umpires are

Jdoc

May 15, 9:59pm

Yes, here’s a chart from Fangraphs on ump accuracy by year

TCuz

May 15, 10:03pm

Yes, I can’t stand catcher framing. Interesting chart. I am not surprised

Jdoc

May 15, 10:11pm

Ultimately - most fans don’t care if umps are better or worse today than in the past.

cougXor

May 16, 7:33am

Challenge system is a good start.

May 15, 9:52pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad