Anyone who thinks there is no genetic component to obesity also thinks the earth

May 15, 2024
8:00:04pm

TO11 All-American

is flat. It's really pretty much non-debatable at this point. Of course it's not the only facet, it's clearly multifactorial with factors like diet, culture, and lifestyle.

This message has been modified

Originally posted on May 15, 2024 at 8:00:04pm

Message modified by TO11 on May 15, 2024 at 8:00:27pm

Report problem with this ad

TO11

Bio page: TO11
Joined: Sep 24, 2016
Last login: Oct 31, 2024
Total posts: 3,431 (0 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Regarding obesity being genetic

Black Diamond Bay All-American

May 15, 7:54pm

I can believe that genetics make it harder for some to lose weight,

Cougar Junkie

May 15, 7:58pm

Yes, I love it when a person says that despite consuming less calories than they

Ozymandias

May 15, 8:01pm

If you've ever seen the horrible photos of Nazi concentration camps, you

Cougar Junkie

May 15, 8:04pm

Plenty of people starved in those camps. Poor example.

Yiowa

May 15, 8:09pm

Disagree. It shows that there was no medical condition that kept a person fat.

Cougar Junkie

May 15, 8:17pm

I don’t think anyone is really wondering whether fat people can die thin.

Yiowa

May 15, 8:32pm

False dichotomy. It's not as if as soon as fat people become thin, they die.

Cougar Junkie

May 15, 8:35pm

If that body type was the standard of “health” how difficult would it be to

Yiowa

May 15, 8:58pm

I'm saying that between obesity and becoming rail thin due to calorie

Cougar Junkie

May 15, 9:02pm

I mostly agree with you there. 99.9% of people can achieve a sustainable healthy

Yiowa

May 15, 9:20pm

Well when you actually are forced to not eat. There are medical and psychologic

kotacoug

May 15, 8:36pm

Both obesity and alcoholism can be overcome, either voluntarily or

Cougar Junkie

May 15, 8:47pm

The first person to bring up Nazis in an argument loses the argument.

ochobeeguy

May 15, 8:33pm

Swap Nazi camps with North Korean ones. Is that better?

Cougar Junkie

May 15, 8:43pm

My wife operates at a calorie deficit all the time and reaches a point where she

gwalker

May 15, 8:11pm

Here is the secret. She isn’t operating at a 350 calorie deficit. Her metabolism

Ozymandias

May 15, 8:18pm

That could well be. She isn’t gluttonous by any means. Often eats around 1000

gwalker

May 15, 8:20pm

Her metabolism may be slow because she is starving herself. She really

kotacoug

May 15, 9:07pm

Be sure her calorie intake includes protein daily.

Bullrider

May 15, 9:11pm

For women I think the oft overlooked culprit to stubborn weight is birth control. Messing with your hormones will

Black Diamond Bay

May 15, 8:24pm

Hate to break it to you but 350 x7 will never equal a 1 lb fat loss. You would

kotacoug

May 15, 8:39pm

That’s right. I forgot the number. But she’s clearly doing that if her

gwalker

May 15, 8:55pm

I agree. Like I said, I'm married to a reformed fatty, from a fat family and he's managed it.

Black Diamond Bay

May 15, 8:05pm

Anyone who thinks there is no genetic component to obesity also thinks the earth

TO11

May 15, 8:00pm

I think people have an issue when others say nothing can be done because it’s

Longseason

May 15, 8:05pm

Of course your metabolism is connected to your genetics, but nobody has to be

Ozymandias

May 15, 8:27pm

Let’s not go binary on us.

Archaea

May 15, 8:31pm

I didn't believe that it is learned. I think controlling it is a learned behavior and so we trying to instill good

Black Diamond Bay

May 15, 8:44pm

Learned is a more specialized sense.

Archaea

May 15, 9:20pm

This is me, I have two settings hungry and stuffed.

Cosmodiar

May 15, 8:00pm

Why do some people feel it necessary to belittle very sad people about their

Bullrider

May 15, 8:32pm

Because they don't struggle, thus it is easy for everyone.

ochobeeguy

May 15, 8:36pm

Belittle? I believe some worry about the cost to our already

Archaea

May 15, 8:37pm

What you say is true but does little to help the obese. Why don’t you prove

Bullrider

May 15, 8:50pm

Do those that overburden the healthcare system care?

Archaea

May 15, 9:14pm

I'm sorry that you feel belittled, but I'm not really seeing where that happened.

Posting on CougarBoard