There are some excellent scenes in the Hobbit films (mostly the first and second ones). The gathering of dwarves at

Aug 22, 2022
11:21:13pm

durandal Rampant AI

Bilbo's house, Riddles in the Dark, Bilbo and Smaug's conversation. But there is just so much unnecessary bloat that it ruins those excellent moments.

Report problem with this ad

durandal

Previous username: science pete
Bio page: durandal
Joined: Feb 8, 2011
Last login: Nov 27, 2024
Total posts: 28,557 (11,335 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

As dumpster firish as most of the Hobbit movies are. Smaug is phenomenal they

Pepe

8/22/22 10:15pm

I didn’t mind the storyline at all. Just hated all the CGI. It was almost a

Chefcurry

8/22/22 10:18pm

Amen! The CGI made it so the movies can't age well and made it feel less epic

hardcorecoug

8/22/22 10:49pm

I thought Martin Freeman was perfect as Bilbo

Zap Rowsdower

8/22/22 10:19pm

I read that as Milton Friedman. He was diminutive, so it could have worked!

Cougar Junkie

8/22/22 10:23pm

I like Freeman/Bilbo better than Wood/Frodo.

Corn

8/22/22 10:23pm

RE: I like Freeman/Bilbo better than Wood/Frodo.

WJCougar

8/22/22 10:33pm

If they had cut it down to two movies like originally planned it would’ve have

Pepe

8/22/22 10:33pm

There are some excellent scenes in the Hobbit films (mostly the first and second ones). The gathering of dwarves at

durandal

8/22/22 11:21pm

I'd say about 75% of the trilogy is great, but the other 25% is horrible

Hup

8/23/22 12:36am

No mention of the ridiculous

mtnbiker

8/22/22 11:31pm

Any chance VidAngel could do a "book cut" (like the StarWars no-JarJar cut) that

Posting on CougarBoard