Tim McTyer stuck for a couple years, and it's Brian Mitchell.

Report problem with this ad

Jan 13, 2022
6:19:43pm

Y05 All-American

This message has been modified

Originally posted on Jan 13, 2022 at 6:19:43pm

Message modified by Y05 on Jan 13, 2022 at 6:20:20pm

Report problem with this ad

Y05

Previous username: Yz1
Bio page: Y05
Joined: Feb 16, 2010
Last login: Nov 25, 2024
Total posts: 22,334 (576 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

POLL: How would an all-time greatest BYU players team compete in the NFL?

RSL I am a dad joke

1/13/22 6:02pm

Steve Young, Austin Collie, Dennis Pitta, Jamaal, Tait, Fred Warner.

Dangerous

1/13/22 6:04pm

And an OL, DL, DBs?

shamc

1/13/22 6:13pm

Warner plays defense, so we shouldn't give him the ball.

Coach's Dad

1/13/22 6:14pm

What are we feeding him?

Cougs or die

1/13/22 6:15pm

Utes

RSL

1/13/22 6:20pm

I amend mine. Each player at his prime could probably be superbowl worthy.

CougaRR4L

1/14/22 10:13pm

Can we just put Allgeier on the team as well. If nothing else for our 4th down back

Osteotome

1/15/22 12:04am

Just think about it. How many played in the Super Bowl? A ton. Many even won.

Y05

1/15/22 4:08am

They’d be ok, but I think the team would struggle at WR and DB in the NFL

Hup

1/13/22 6:07pm

DB’s would be Sorensen, Michael Davis.

Dangerous

1/13/22 7:15pm

Didn’t Eric Bergeson play a few years?

Big12Yfan

1/13/22 8:21pm

Holmoe as well. Altogether, not very good against nfl speed

Hup

1/13/22 10:24pm

Our pass defense would be very vulnerable

NOCAL_YFAN

1/13/22 6:07pm

Put together a team of players at their peak they would be a pretty good team

mudpupper

1/13/22 6:09pm

Has BYU had an NFL kicker?

RSL

1/13/22 6:10pm

Lee Johnson punted

Big12Yfan

1/13/22 6:12pm

Owen Pochman

molodyets

1/13/22 6:12pm

TIL he had a (short) NFL career. Only hit 47% of his field goals.

RSL

1/13/22 6:21pm

Lee Johnson but he was a punter mainly.

mudpupper

1/13/22 6:12pm

DL - Ziggy, Jason Buck, Sean Knight, Khyris, Brett Diesel, Hoke, Ryan Denney

NOCAL_YFAN

1/13/22 6:14pm

Yeah DL all time is actually pretty dang good, oline too

Big12Yfan

1/14/22 9:43am

Let's not forget Travis Hall.

Y05

1/14/22 10:51am

WR would be a mess. DBs subpar. Everyone else strong with A+ coaching and QB play

Odysseus

1/13/22 6:11pm

No one really outside of Collie, right?

RSL

1/13/22 6:11pm

I can't think of another even moderately successful BYU WR in the NFL.

mudpupper

1/13/22 6:13pm

Kozlowski?

RSL

1/13/22 6:15pm

Koz stuck longer than Collie IIRC

fulano

1/13/22 6:17pm

6 years in the NFL, but also injury ridden.

RSL

1/13/22 6:23pm

Mostly special teams.

Y05

1/13/22 6:23pm

Only because of concussions.

BlooCoog

1/13/22 6:38pm

+ a broken leg

RSL

1/13/22 6:39pm

Golden Richards and Todd Watkins

Big12Yfan

1/13/22 6:13pm

Kozlowski stuck in the league a few years.

cougfanblue

1/13/22 6:20pm

Mahe played WR at byu but was a third down back in the NFL iirc

Big12Yfan

1/13/22 6:23pm

Who would be the DB’s?

RalphWiggam

1/13/22 6:15pm

Holmoe maybe? Aaron Francisco?

cougfanblue

1/13/22 6:18pm

Tim McTyer stuck for a couple years, and it's Brian Mitchell.

Y05

1/13/22 6:19pm

Can’t believe I forgot Brian…but Patrick was his younger brother. He played a

RalphWiggam

1/13/22 6:23pm

Michael Davis a current starter?

mudpupper

1/13/22 6:31pm

He was on my list.

RalphWiggam

1/13/22 6:35pm

Rex Berry, was all pro a couple of years. Dick Felt, a former coach was

Bullrider

1/13/22 8:39pm

Todd Christensen TE but was a great receiver for the raiders

Osteotome

1/13/22 7:05pm

I thought that Todd Christensen played fullback at BYU.

84 natlchamps

1/13/22 8:26pm

At BYU all WAC Fullback NFL All Pro 4, Pro Bowl x 5 NFL receptions leader 2 times 10 year NFL 2 Super Bowl & broadcaster

Osteotome

1/13/22 11:51pm

Should be in the hall of fame imo

Big12Yfan

1/14/22 9:43am

Also, who is the starting QB? Steve Young?

RSL

1/13/22 6:12pm

Obviously

Big12Yfan

1/13/22 6:14pm

Probably Virgil Carter. Bill Walsh really liked him.

Y05

1/13/22 6:27pm

I say 1. Ty Detmer, 2. Jim McMahon 3. Robbie Bosco 4. Steve Young 5. Marc Wilson

84 natlchamps

1/13/22 8:33pm

We’ve got ourselves a long snapper!

cougfanblue

1/13/22 6:13pm

I'm flattered, but I haven't played since Peewee days.

RSL

1/13/22 6:14pm

Elder Sikahema returning punts.

cougfanblue

1/13/22 6:21pm

I suppose Andy Reid as coach, but Brian Billick would do okay too

The Chelsea Dagger

1/14/22 9:25am

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad